Table 1.
Different Ultrasound Cardiac Calcification Grading Score. (A) Cardiac calcification grading score proposed by Tolstrup et al. [73]. (B) Semiquantitative Calcium Score Index (CSI) proposed by Corciu et al. [74] and modified and adopted by Gaibazzi et al. [72]. (C) Global cardiac calcium ultrasound score elaborated by Pressman et al. [77]. (D) Echocardiographic calcification score “echoCCS” proposed by Hirschberg et al. [80].
(A) Tolstrup et al. [73] | Grade | Aortic Valve Sclerosis | Mitral Annulus Calcification | Aortic Atheromatous Disease | |||||
Final Score Range: 0–10 | 0 | No thickening | Normal | Normal, <2 mm intimal thickness | |||||
1 | Slight ↑ reflectance, thickness < 2 mm | <5 mm | Intimal thickness 2–4 mm | ||||||
2 | Mild ↑ reflectance, thickness 2–4 mm | 5–10 mm | Intimal thickness > 4 mm | ||||||
3 | Generalized hyper-reflectance, thickness > 4 mm | >10 mm | Any protruding/mobile plaque | ||||||
4 | Markedly hyper-reflectant masses, thickness > 6 mm | ||||||||
(B) Corciu et al. [74] | Grade | Papillary Muscle Calcium | Mitral Annular Calcium | Aortic Valve Sclerosis | Aorta Root Calcium | ||||
Final Score Range: 0–8 | 0 | Absent | Absent | Normal cusp thickness (<2mm) and normal reflectivity | Absent | ||||
1 | Present | <5 mm | Cusp thickness > 2 mm and/or increased reflectivity | Present | |||||
2 | 5–10 mm | Thickness > 4 mm and/or diffuse or focal cusp hyperreflectivity | |||||||
3 | >10 mm | Thickness > 6mm and/or marked echoreflectivity | |||||||
(C) Pressman et al. [77] | Grade | Posterior Annulus Calcium | Posterior Mitral Leaflet Restriction | Anterior Annulus Calcium | Anterior Mitral Leaflet Restriction | Mitral Valve Calcium | Subvalvular Apparatus Calcium | Aortic Valve Calcium | Aortic Root Calcium |
Final Score Range: 0–13 | 0 | Absent | Absent | Absent | Absent | Absent | Absent | Absent | Absent |
1 | 1/3 of annulus | Present | Present (any mobility reduction) | Present (valve opening <10mm) | Mild | Present | Nodules in <3 leaflets | Present | |
2 | 2/3 of annulus | >Mild | Nodules in 3 leaflets but non-restrictive | ||||||
3 | 3/3 of annulus | Restrictive (meam gradient > 15 mmHg or reduced leaflets motion) | |||||||
(D) Hirschberg et al. [80] | Grade | Papillary Muscle Calcium | Mitral Annular Calcium | Aortic Valve Sclerosis | Aorta Root Calcium | Septal Calcium | |||
Final Score Range: 0–5 | 0 | Absent | Absent | Absent | Absent | Absent | |||
1 | Present | Present | Present | Absent | Present |