Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 21;14:1141–1151. doi: 10.2147/JPR.S308006

Table 1.

General Characteristics of the Included 31 Studies

No. Included Trials Publication Language No. of Participants Intervention Course of Treatment
Trial Control Trial Control
1 Wasan 201019 English 21 19 Acupuncture Sham acupuncture 21d
2 Chen 201020 Chinese 50 50 Acupuncture Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation 5w
3 Su 201021 Chinese 30 30 Acupuncture Sham acupuncture 1 session
4 Shankar 201122 English 30 30 Electro-acupuncture Valdecoxib 3w
5 Hunter 201223 English 24 28 Ear acupuncture + exercise Exercise 12w
6 Yun 201224 English 124 63 Acupuncture Usual care 7w
7 Vas 201225 English 210 70 Acupuncture Conventional treatment 4w
8 Cho 201317 English 65 65 Acupuncture Sham acupuncture 6w
9 Shin 201326 English 29 29 Motion style acupuncture NSAIDs injection 1 session
10 Wand 201327 English 25 25 Sensory discrimination acupuncture Usual acupuncture 1 session
11 Weib 201328 English 79 77 Acupuncture + standard rehabilitation programme Standard rehabilitation programme 21d
12 Hasegawa 201429 English 40 40 Acupuncture Sham acupuncture 5 sessions
13 Seo 201730 English 27 27 Bee venom acupuncture + Loxonin Sham bee venom acupuncture + Loxonin 3w
14 Kizhakkeveettil 201731 English 34 67 Acupuncture Spinal manipulative treatment/integrative care 60d
15 Liu 201732 English 30 15 4/7 sessions acupuncture 10 sessions acupuncture 12w
16 Zhang 201733 Chinese 30 60 Acupuncture Sham acupuncture 1 session
17 Wu 201734 Chinese 30 30 Internal heating acupuncture Warm acupuncture 3w
18 Zheng 201835 English 63 27 Electroacupuncture/sham acupuncture Pain medication management (opioid medications) 10w
19 Lee 201836 English 20 20 Thread embedding acupuncture Acupuncture 8w
20 Heo 201837 English 18 21 Electroacupuncture + usual care Usual care 4w
21 Liu 201838 Chinese 42 42 Internal heating acupuncture Warm acupuncture 10d
22 Luo 201939 English 104 48 Acupuncture Usual care 7w
23 Vas 201940 English 165 55 Ear acupuncture + standard obstetric care Standard obstetric care 2w
24 Nicolian 201941 English 96 103 Acupuncture Standard care 4w
25 Li 201942 Chinese 49 49 Tiaoshen acupuncture Usual acupuncture 2w
26 Comachio 202043 English 33 33 Electro-acupuncture Manual acupuncture 6w
27 Bishop 202044 English 69 41 Acupuncture + standard care Standard care 6w
28 Sung 202045 English 19 19 Thread embedding acupuncture + acupuncture Acupuncture 8w
29 Li 202046 Chinese 30 30 Six-directions acupuncture Usual acupuncture 13d
30 Wang 202047 Chinese 34 34 Acupuncture at tendon lesions Usual acupuncture 4w
31 Yang 202048 Chinese 99 99 Floating acupuncture Usual acupuncture 10d