Table 1.
General Characteristics of the Included 31 Studies
No. | Included Trials | Publication Language | No. of Participants | Intervention | Course of Treatment | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Trial | Control | Trial | Control | ||||
1 | Wasan 201019 | English | 21 | 19 | Acupuncture | Sham acupuncture | 21d |
2 | Chen 201020 | Chinese | 50 | 50 | Acupuncture | Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation | 5w |
3 | Su 201021 | Chinese | 30 | 30 | Acupuncture | Sham acupuncture | 1 session |
4 | Shankar 201122 | English | 30 | 30 | Electro-acupuncture | Valdecoxib | 3w |
5 | Hunter 201223 | English | 24 | 28 | Ear acupuncture + exercise | Exercise | 12w |
6 | Yun 201224 | English | 124 | 63 | Acupuncture | Usual care | 7w |
7 | Vas 201225 | English | 210 | 70 | Acupuncture | Conventional treatment | 4w |
8 | Cho 201317 | English | 65 | 65 | Acupuncture | Sham acupuncture | 6w |
9 | Shin 201326 | English | 29 | 29 | Motion style acupuncture | NSAIDs injection | 1 session |
10 | Wand 201327 | English | 25 | 25 | Sensory discrimination acupuncture | Usual acupuncture | 1 session |
11 | Weib 201328 | English | 79 | 77 | Acupuncture + standard rehabilitation programme | Standard rehabilitation programme | 21d |
12 | Hasegawa 201429 | English | 40 | 40 | Acupuncture | Sham acupuncture | 5 sessions |
13 | Seo 201730 | English | 27 | 27 | Bee venom acupuncture + Loxonin | Sham bee venom acupuncture + Loxonin | 3w |
14 | Kizhakkeveettil 201731 | English | 34 | 67 | Acupuncture | Spinal manipulative treatment/integrative care | 60d |
15 | Liu 201732 | English | 30 | 15 | 4/7 sessions acupuncture | 10 sessions acupuncture | 12w |
16 | Zhang 201733 | Chinese | 30 | 60 | Acupuncture | Sham acupuncture | 1 session |
17 | Wu 201734 | Chinese | 30 | 30 | Internal heating acupuncture | Warm acupuncture | 3w |
18 | Zheng 201835 | English | 63 | 27 | Electroacupuncture/sham acupuncture | Pain medication management (opioid medications) | 10w |
19 | Lee 201836 | English | 20 | 20 | Thread embedding acupuncture | Acupuncture | 8w |
20 | Heo 201837 | English | 18 | 21 | Electroacupuncture + usual care | Usual care | 4w |
21 | Liu 201838 | Chinese | 42 | 42 | Internal heating acupuncture | Warm acupuncture | 10d |
22 | Luo 201939 | English | 104 | 48 | Acupuncture | Usual care | 7w |
23 | Vas 201940 | English | 165 | 55 | Ear acupuncture + standard obstetric care | Standard obstetric care | 2w |
24 | Nicolian 201941 | English | 96 | 103 | Acupuncture | Standard care | 4w |
25 | Li 201942 | Chinese | 49 | 49 | Tiaoshen acupuncture | Usual acupuncture | 2w |
26 | Comachio 202043 | English | 33 | 33 | Electro-acupuncture | Manual acupuncture | 6w |
27 | Bishop 202044 | English | 69 | 41 | Acupuncture + standard care | Standard care | 6w |
28 | Sung 202045 | English | 19 | 19 | Thread embedding acupuncture + acupuncture | Acupuncture | 8w |
29 | Li 202046 | Chinese | 30 | 30 | Six-directions acupuncture | Usual acupuncture | 13d |
30 | Wang 202047 | Chinese | 34 | 34 | Acupuncture at tendon lesions | Usual acupuncture | 4w |
31 | Yang 202048 | Chinese | 99 | 99 | Floating acupuncture | Usual acupuncture | 10d |