Table 1.
Group | Parameters | California | Florida | New York | Texas |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Costs | Cost inputs | ||||
Direct cost of Diagnostic tests | IGRA (Interferon gamma release assay QuantiFERON-Gold)a [28] | $85 | $77 | $84 | $75 |
Chest radiograph [29] | $22 | $20 | $22 | $20 | |
Direct cost of latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) treatment | 3HP (isoniazid & rifapentine, 3 months, self-administered)b [30] | $451 | $404 | $443 | $394 |
Lab testsc [28] | $41 | $36 | $40 | $36 | |
Toxicity not requiring hospitalization [30] | $216 | $193 | $212 | $189 | |
Toxicity requiring hospitalization [31] | $6,926 | $6,208 | $6,802 | $6,053 | |
Direct cost of (drug susceptible) TB treatment | Inpatient costs [32] | $42,356 | $23,378 | $41,685 | $18,350 |
Outpatient costs [33] | $3,550 | $3,181 | $3,486 | $3,102 | |
Cost of living adjustment | Percentage of the national average price for healthcare [15] | 110.84 | 98.55 | 109.40 | 96.91 |
Effectiveness | Effectiveness inputs | ||||
Probabilities and discount rate | Probability of toxicity during LTBI treatment (without hospitalization) [11] | 3.2% | |||
Probability of toxicity during LTBI treatment (with hospitalization) [34] | 0.015% | ||||
Probability of case fatality of TB disease [17, 30] | 5.8% (9.2% for people living with HIV) | ||||
Discount rate, per year [16] | 3% | ||||
Probability of TB hospitalization [35] | 49% | ||||
QALY estimates d | Estimated quality-adjusted life years (QALY) lost per case of non-fatal TB disease (QALYs gained per TB case averted) | 0.12 | |||
Estimated QALYs lost per LTBI treatment completed [16] (probability * disutility of toxicity) | 0.002 |
Costs of additional testing among people with abnormal radiographs, such as for Mtb smear/culture, nucleic acid amplification testing, and drug susceptibility were not incorporated because these costs are not typically considered part of LTBI testing, though are part of testing persons to rule out TB disease prior to LTBI treatment.
We estimated 3HP costs as $369 per patient from the healthcare system perspective excluding directly observed therapy (DOT) costs from Shepardson et al, 2013 [30] and adjusted using the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) deflator to 2018, including cost-of-living adjustment by state. Based on 1 initial clinic visit, 2 monthly follow-up clinic visits, 3 months of medication, and 12 DOT visits
Lab tests include liver function test (hepatic function panel), complete blood count, and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) testing in the first month (except for people living with HIV after HIV diagnosis). We used the lab tests cost for people living with HIV as $21.84 in California, $19.58 Florida, $21.45 in New York, and $19.09 in Texas and by excluding the HIV testing cost.
Estimated results based on the QALY equation from Sassi et al. [16]