Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 12;2021(3):CD013316. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013316.pub2

5. Details of articles describing a single method.

Author (year) Country of population/cohort Length of follow‐up (median in months (range)) Number of participants Tumour type IDH mutation status (% of WT) Technique used to assess MGMT methylation status
Abhinav 2013 UK NR 19 GBM NR MSP
Adeberg 2015 Germany NR 32 GBM NR MSP
Ahmed 2015 US 11.4 214 GBM NR mRNA levels
Alonso 2017 Spain NR 63 GBM: 97.2%; gliosarcoma: 2.8% 88.7 (data from 63/71 people) MSP
Appin 2013 US NR 236 GBM: primary: 89% (GBM with oligodendroglioma: 13.3%); secondary: 11% GBM: 91.4 (data from 116/208 people); GBM‐O: 65 (data from 20/28 people) MSP
Ardon 2012 Belgium 25.0 (10.5–42.2) 77 GBM (primary) NR MSP
Arita 2016 Japan NDR 193 GBM 100 PSQ
Badruddoja 2017 US NR 30 GBM NR qMSP
Balana 2016 Spain NR 93 GBM NR MSP
Balana 2017 Spain 17.0 (10.7–24.5) 256 GBM 94.5 (data from 162/256 people) MSP
Blumenthal 2017 US NR 1395 GBM NR qMSP
Boots‐Sprenger 2013 The Netherlands NR 333 GBM 84 (data from 226/333 people) MS‐MLPA
Brandes 2008 Italy 18.93 (6.6–62) 208 GBM NR MSP
Brandes 2009 Italy NR 37 GBM NR MSP
Brandes 2010 Italy NR 44 GBM NR MSP
Brandes 2014 Italy NR 116 GBM NR MSP
Brandes 2017 Italy NR 108 GBM NR MSP
Brennan 2013 US NR 332 GBM 93.4 (data from 423/543 people) Bead array
Burford 2013 UK NR NDR GBM NDR MSP
Burger 2017 Germany NR 32 GBM NR MSP
Butowski 2011 US NR 66 GBM and gliosarcoma NR MSP
Capellades 2018 Spain NR 292 GBM 96.6 MSP
Chakhoyan 2018 US NR 23 GBM NR MSP
Chen 2015 China 12.8 (4.0–37.7) 78 GBM NR IHC
Chen 2016 China NR 300 GBM 85.7 Bead array
Cheng 2015 China, US NR 285 (CGGA: 55; TCGA: 235) GBM NR Bead array (TCGA); PSQ (CGGA)
Chinot 2007 France 6 (0.9–19) 29 GBM NR IHC
Choi 2016 South Korea NR 112 (training cohort: 74; test cohort 38) GBM NR MSP
Clarke 2009 US 18.8 85 GBM NR MSP
Coburger 2017 Germany 40 (37–43) 170 GBM NR MSP
Colman 2010 US NR 101 GBM NR qMSP
Combs 2011 Germany NR 160 GBM (primary) 97.1 (data from 140/160 people) MSP
Cominelli 2015 Italy NR 70 GBM 95.7 MSP
Costa 2010 Portugal NR 90 GBM (primary) NR MSP
Criniere 2007 France 57.2 77 GBM NR MSP
Dahlrot 2017 Denmark NR 226 GBM (primary) NR PSQ
Das 2011 India NR 6 GBM NR MSP
Etcheverry 2014 France 15.5 399 GBM (primary) 91 PSQ
Felsberg 2011 Germany 48.6 64 GBM NR MSP
Fiano 2014 Italy NR 32 GBM NR MSP
Fontana 2016 Italy NDR 128 GBM NDR PSQ
Franceschi 2016 Italy NR 21 GBM NR MSP
Franceschi 2018 Italy NR 169 GBM NR MSP
Galldiks 2015 Germany NR 21 GBM NR MSP
Gallego Perez‐Larraya 2011 France NR 31 GBM NR qMSP
Gilbert 2013 Canada, European multicentres, US NR 762 GBM NR qMSP
Gilbert 2014 Canada, European multicentres, US NR 637 GBM NR qMSP
Gittleman 2017 US NR 799 GBM NR qMSP
Glas 2009 Germany 41.5 23 GBM NR MSP
Gorlia 2008 Belgium, Canada, Italy, Germany, Switzerland, the Netherlands NR 287 GBM NR MSP
Gramatzki 2016 Switzerland 9 108 GBM 100 MSP
Gutenberg 2013a Germany NR 17 GBM (primary) NR MSP
Gutenberg 2013b Germany 16.2 (1.4–54.1) 191 GBM (primary) NR MSP
Ha 2013 South Korea NR 10 GBM 75 qMSP
Haemmig 2014 Switzerland NR 60 GBM 85 qMSP
Han 2014 US NR 28 GBM NR MSP
Han 2015a China 13.7 (1–43) 152 GBM NR MSP
Han 2015b China 13.7 (1–43) 79 GBM 93.5 (data from 214 people) MS‐MLPA
Happold 2018 European multicentres 29 (25–35; CENTRIC cohort) 797 GBM NR qMSP
Hayes 2015 US 14.1 219 GBM 94.5 (data from 475 people) Bead array
Hegi 2004 Switzerland NR 38 GBM NR MSP
Hegi 2005 Canada, European multicentres NR 106 GBM NR MSP
Herrlinger 2006 Germany NR 31 GBM NR MSP
Herrlinger 2009 Germany 41.5 31 GBM NR MSP
Hervouet 2009 France NR 53 GBM NR MSP
Hobbs 2012 US 19.1 (8.1–74.6; survivors only) 312 GBM NR qMSP
Huang 2017 US NR 301 GBM NR mRNA levels
Hudson 2018 Australia NR 16 GBM NR PSQ
Inoges 2017 Spain NR 31 GBM NR MSP
Ishida 2015 Japan NR 46 GBM NR IHC
Ishikawa 2014 Japan 19.6 (7.3–48.7) 23 GBM 75 (data from the whole cohort) IHC
Ius 2018 Italy NR 116 GBM NR PSQ
Iwadate 2017 Japan NR 70 GBM 92 IHC
Jan 2018 Taiwan NR NDR GBM NDR MSP
Karim 2012 Egypt NR 34 GBM NR MSP
Kessler 2018 Germany, US NR 404 (Heidelberg cohort: 143; TCGA: 261) GBM 100 Bead array
Kim 2012 South Korea 22 (3–88) 93 GBM NR MSP
Kim 2017 South Korea 16.3 (0.3–105.1) 750 GBM NR MSP
Kim 2018 South Korea NR 93 GBM 86.8 (data from 91 people) qMSP
Klitkou 2014a Denmark NR 173 GBM (primary) NR IHC
Klitkou 2014b Denmark NR 173 GBM (primary) NR IHC
Klitkou 2014c Denmark NR 173 GBM (primary) NR IHC
Kong 2011 South Korea 16.5 (6.2–48) 90 GBM NR MSP
Kreth 2013 Germany NR 222 GBM NR MSP
Lakomy 2011 Czech Republic NR 38 GBM NR PCR‐HRM
Laxton 2013 UK NR 288 GBM 95.3 (data from 107/288 people) MSP
Lee 2013 South Korea 15 36 GBM NR qMSP
Lee 2017 South Korea NR 65 GBM 80 MSP
Li 2016a China NR 145 GBM 83.4 MSP
Li 2016b China NR 50 GBM (primary) 85.9 (data from 50/78 people) PSQ
Lombardi 2015 Italy NR 151 GBM 94 (data from 100/237 people) MSP and PSQ
Lombardi 2017 Italy NR 128 GBM NR PSQ
Ma 2016 China NR 56 GBM (primary) NR MSP
Majewska 2017 United Kingdom NR 99 GBM NR PSQ
Malmström 2012 Austria, Denmark, France, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey NR 72 GBM 99.7 (data from 291 people) qMSP
Malmström 2017 Denmark, Finland, Norway, Sweden 20 78 GBM 96.10% PSQ
Martini 2008 Italy NR 46 GBM NR MSP
McDonald 2015 Australia NR 33 GBM 93.90% PSQ
Metellus 2011 France 18.9 61 GBM NR qMSP
Meyronet 2017 Austria, Denmark, France, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey NR 6 GBM 100 PSQ
Michaelsen 2013 Denmark 60 (23–92) 163 GBM NR IHC
Michaelsen 2018 Denmark NR 415 GBM 100 mRNA levels
Minniti 2011a Italy NR 36 GBM (recurrent) NR MSP
Minniti 2011b Italy NR 83 GBM NR MSP
Minniti 2015 Italy 24.0 (standard RT + TMZ group); 22.5 (short course RT + TMZ group) 243 GBM NR MSP
Miyazaki 2014 Japan NR 117 GBM: 83.8%; GBM with oligodendroglioma: 16.2% 93.4 IHC
Montano 2011 Italy NR 73 GBM (primary) NR MSP
Morandi 2010 Italy NR 159 GBM NR qMSP
Motomura 2011 Japan 16.7 (3.4–46.7) 68 GBM (primary) 94.1 PSQ
Mur 2015 Spain NR 68 GBM 70.6 (unknown in 25%) Bead array
Nabors 2012 US NR 69 GBM NR qMSP
Nagane 2007 Japan 7.1 (2.4–16.7) 19 GBM (recurrent) NR Western blot analysis
Ohka 2011 Japan NR 51 GBM (primary) 94 PSQ
Ohno 2013 Japan NR 85 GBM NR PSQ
Ohno 2016 Japan NR 112 GBM 92 PSQ
Omuro 2014 US 42 40 GBM 100 qMSP
Pallini 2008 Italy NR 44 GBM NR MSP
Pambuku 2016 Italy NR 128 GBM NR PSQ
Park 2013 South Korea NR 75 GBM NR MSP
Pei 2013 China NR 54 GBM NR MSP
Picart 2018 France NR 14 GBM (cerebellar) 100 PSQ
Poulsen 2017 Denmark 14 146 GBM 98 IHC
Prados 2009 US 33.7 65 GBM and gliosarcoma NR MSP
Purkait 2016 India NR 114 GBM 93.3 MSP
Qi 2012 China NR 86 GBM (secondary) 26.6 (data from 79 people) MSP
Rankeillor 2014 UK NR 29 GBM (primary) NR MS‐MLPA
Rapkins 2015 Australia, US NR 319 (AGOG cohort: 160; UCLA cohort: 159) GBM NR MSP (UCLA); PSQ (AGOG)
Rapp 2013 Germany NR 85 GBM (primary) NR MSP
Reifenberger 2012 Germany 29 104 GBM NR MSP
Roh 2017 South Korea 20.8 252 GBM: 84.5%; giant‐cells GBM: 4.0%; GBM with oligodendroglioma: 11.5% 93.4 (data from 106/252 people) MSP
Romano 2013 Italy NR 47 GBM NR MSP
Rosati 2013 Italy 11.5 (1.5–58) 83 GBM: 95.2%; gliosarcoma: 2.4%; GBM with oligodendroglia: 2.4% 97.6 MSP
Rosenschold 2019 Denmark NR 412 GBM (primary) NR IHC
Rubio Fernandez 2014 Spain NR 65 GBM NR MSP
Sadones 2009 Belgium NR 32 GBM (recurrent) NR qMSP
Saito 2017a Japan NR 53 GBM (supratentorial) 49 (unknown in 49%) IHC
Saito 2017b Japan NR 36 GBM (supratentorial) NR IHC
Saito 2018a Japan NR 102 GBM (supratentorial) 75.5 IHC
Saito 2018b Japan NR 50 GBM (supratentorial) 100 IHC
Saito 2018c Japan NR 50 GBM (supratentorial) NR IHC
Salvati 2012 Italy NR 105 GBM (primary supratentorial) NR MSP
Sana 2014 Czech Republic NR 58 GBM (primary) NR PCR‐HRM
Saraiva‐Esperon 2014 Spain NR 25 GBM NR MSP
Sasaki 2018 Japan NR 101 GBM: 99%; gliosarcoma: 1% 99 qMSP
Schaich 2009 Germany NR 64 GBM (supratentorial) NR MSP
Schiffgens 2016 Germany, Italy NR 225 (Hannover cohort 1: 120); Bologna cohort: 105) GBM (primary) 91.4 (data from the Bologna cohort) MSP
Schulze Heuling 2017 Germany, US NR 275 GBM 100 Bead array
Shu 2018 China NR 265 GBM (primary) 100 PSQ
Sijben 2008 Canada NR 16 GBM (supratentorial) NR MSP
Singh 2012 India 13.15 (1.5–46) 16 Gliosarcoma NR MSP
Soike 2018 US NR 74 GBM 89.2 IHC
Stetson 2016 US NR 203 (training cohort: 102; validation cohort: 101) GBM Training cohort: 75 (unknown: 21%); validation cohort: 77 (unknown: 17%) Bead array
Stummer 2012 Germany 24 143 GBM NR MSP
Stupp 2009 Canada, European multicentres 61 (0.36–79) 287 GBM NR MSP
Stupp 2010 Germany, Switzerland 34 52 GBM NR MSP
Suchorska 2015 Germany NR 79 GBM (supratentorial) NR MSP
Tanaka 2014 Japan NR 45 GBM NR mRNA levels
Thon 2011 Germany 11 (5–33) 56 GBM NR MSP
Tini 2015 Italy NR 144 GBM NR MSP
Tini 2016 Italy 12 (6–84) 169 GBM 100 MSP
Tini 2017 Italy NR 222 GBM NR MSP
Toms 2018 Multicentre (North America, Europe, South Korea, Israel) NR 466 GBM (supratentorial) NR MSP
Trabelsi 2016 Tunisia NR 20 GBM NR MS‐MLPA
Urbschat 2017 Germany NR 72 GBM NR MSP
van Dijken 2019 China, Taiwan, the Netherland, UK NR 50 GBM 84 (missing in 8%) PSQ
Villani 2015 Italy 12 (3–27) 51 GBM (primary) NR PSQ
Wang 2014 China 47 (6–65) 78 GBM 52.6 MSP
Wang 2015a China NR 216 GBM 48.1 MSP
Wang 2015b Multicentre (North America and Europe) 31.9 (0.2–53.3) 831 GBM NR qMSP
Wang 2016 China, US NR 84 (CGGA: 21; TCGA: 63) GBM NR Bead array (TCGA); PSQ (CGGA)
Watanabe 2011 Japan 15.4 41 GBM NR IHC
Wee 2017 South Korea 20.5 340 GBM 93.8 MSP
Wee 2018 Japan, South Korea 18.4 692 GBM 92.3 MSP
Wei 2017 Taiwan NR 25 GBM NR PSQ
Weller 2015 Austria, Germany, Switzerland NR 105 GBM (recurrent) NR MSP
Weller 2017b Multicentre (165 hospitals in 22 countries) NR 745 GBM (EGFRvIII‐expressing) NR MSP
Weller 2009 Germany 29.4 (data from the whole cohort) 189 GBM: 96.7; giant cells GBM: 2.6%; gliosarcoma: 0.75 94.4 (data from the whole cohort) MSP
Westphal 2015 Germany NR 66 GBM NR PSQ
Wu 2018 US NR 285 GBM NR Bead array
Yan 2017 UK NR 31 GBM 90.3 PSQ
Yang 2015 China NR 229 GBM 76.3 (data from 274 people; unknown in 3.3%) PSQ
Yin 2017 France NR 106 GBM NR Bead array
Yin 2018 France 53 (8–113; Rennes and Angers datasets) 129 GBM NR Bead array
You 2013 Taiwan NR 32 GBM NR qMSP
Younis 2016 Egypt 13 (9–27) 73 GBM NR IHC
Yuan 2017a China NR 84 GBM NR PSQ
Yuan 2017b China NR 48 GBM NR PSQ
Yue 2014 China 17.5 (3–77) 62 GBM NR IHC
Zhang 2014 China NR 80 GBM NR PCR‐HRM
Zunarelli 2011 Italy 10.9 46 GBM (primary) NR MSP

EGFRvIII: epidermal growth factor receptor variant 3; GBM: glioblastoma; IDH: isocitrate dehydrogenase; IHC: immunohistochemistry; MGMT: O6‐methylguanine–DNA methyltransferase; mRNA: messenger ribonucleic acid; MS‐MLPA: methylation‐specific multiplex ligation‐dependent probe amplification; MSP: methylation‐specific polymerase chain reaction; NDR: not directly reported; NR: not reported; PCR‐HRM: polymerase chain reaction with high‐resolution melting; PSQ: pyrosequencing; qMSP: quantitative methylation‐specific polymerase chain reaction; RT: radiotherapy; TMZ: temozolomide; WT: wild‐type.