4. Details of asthma diagnosis and asthma severity in included reviews.
Review | Asthma diagnosis | Asthma severity |
Inhaled treatment | ||
Camargo 2003 | No information provided | Patients presenting to an ED or its equivalent |
Griffiths 2013 | Acute exacerbation of asthma | Patients presenting to an ED |
Vezina 2014 | Acute asthma exacerbation | Hospitalised for an acute asthma exacerbation |
Knightly 2017 | Acute asthma (excluded chronic or “stable” asthma). “We accepted any reasonable diagnosis of asthma, namely clinical and guideline‐based criteria” | No information provided |
Parenteral treatment | ||
Mitra 2005 | Acute severe asthma or status asthmaticus | No definition provided for severe Status asthmaticus defined as “acute, severe, refractory exacerbations” Patients were attending ED, hospital wards, or intensive care |
Travers 2012a | Severe acute asthma | No definition provided for “severe”. Included patients presenting to an ED (or its equivalent) |
Travers 2012b | Severe acute asthma | No definition provided for “severe”. Included patients presenting to an ED or admitted to hospital |
Griffiths 2016 | Acute asthma | Patients treated in the ED with acute asthma (all severities) |
Jat 2012 | Acute asthma exacerbation | Not responded to standard therapy with aerosolised beta2‐agonist, with or without aerosolised anticholinergic drugs and oral or parenteral corticosteroid, for at least 1 hour |
Other interventions to reduce the work of breathing | ||
Rodrigo 2006 | Clinical diagnosis asthma exacerbation (according to accepted criteria such as those published by the American Thoracic Society). Excluded patients with COPD | Presenting to an ED or equivalent care setting. Excluded patients requiring mechanical ventilation at presentation |
Korang 2016 | Asthma attack (as defined by the trialists). Excluded children with pneumonia, aspiration, bronchiolitis, cystic fibrosis, or any ciliary dyskinetic syndrome | Children hospitalised for an asthma attack |
Other interventions | ||
Normansell 2018 | Asthma exacerbation. Excluded pneumonia, COPD, and bronchiectasis | Presented to the ED, primary care, outpatient clinics, or inpatient wards. Included both inpatients and outpatients |
Watts 2012 | Acute asthma | Presenting for acute medical care to an ED or equivalent setting |
COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; ED: emergency department.