Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 5;2020(8):CD012977. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012977.pub2

4. Details of asthma diagnosis and asthma severity in included reviews.

Review Asthma diagnosis Asthma severity
Inhaled treatment
Camargo 2003 No information provided Patients presenting to an ED or its equivalent
Griffiths 2013 Acute exacerbation of asthma Patients presenting to an ED
Vezina 2014 Acute asthma exacerbation Hospitalised for an acute asthma exacerbation
Knightly 2017 Acute asthma (excluded chronic or “stable” asthma). “We accepted any reasonable diagnosis of asthma, namely clinical and guideline‐based criteria” No information provided
Parenteral treatment
Mitra 2005 Acute severe asthma or status asthmaticus No definition provided for severe
Status asthmaticus defined as “acute, severe, refractory exacerbations”
Patients were attending ED, hospital wards, or intensive care
Travers 2012a Severe acute asthma No definition provided for “severe”. Included patients presenting to an ED (or its equivalent)
Travers 2012b Severe acute asthma No definition provided for “severe”. Included patients presenting to an ED or admitted to hospital
Griffiths 2016 Acute asthma Patients treated in the ED with acute asthma (all severities)
Jat 2012 Acute asthma exacerbation Not responded to standard therapy with aerosolised beta2‐agonist, with or without aerosolised anticholinergic drugs and oral or parenteral corticosteroid, for at least 1 hour
Other interventions to reduce the work of breathing
Rodrigo 2006 Clinical diagnosis asthma exacerbation (according to accepted criteria such as those published by the American Thoracic Society). Excluded patients with COPD Presenting to an ED or equivalent care setting. Excluded patients requiring mechanical ventilation at presentation
Korang 2016 Asthma attack (as defined by the trialists). Excluded children with pneumonia, aspiration, bronchiolitis, cystic fibrosis, or any ciliary dyskinetic syndrome Children hospitalised for an asthma attack
Other interventions
Normansell 2018 Asthma exacerbation. Excluded pneumonia, COPD, and bronchiectasis Presented to the ED, primary care, outpatient clinics, or inpatient wards. Included both inpatients and outpatients
Watts 2012 Acute asthma Presenting for acute medical care to an ED or equivalent setting

COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; ED: emergency department.