Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 5;2020(8):CD012977. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012977.pub2

5. ROBIS assessment of included reviews.

Review Domain 1: study eligibility criteria Domain 2: identification and selection of studies Domain 3: data collection and study appraisal Domain 4: synthesis and findings Risk of bias in the review
Inhaled treatment
Camargo 2003 Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk
Griffiths 2013 Low concern High concern Low concern Low concern High risk
Vezina 2014 Low concern High concern Low concern Low concern High risk
Knightly 2017 Low concern High concern Low concern Low concern High risk
Parenteral treatment
Mitra 2005 Low concern High concern Unclear concern Low concern High risk
Travers 2012a Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk
Travers 2012b Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk
Griffiths 2016 Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk
Jat 2012 Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk
Other interventions to reduce the work of breathing
Rodrigo 2006 Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk
Korang 2016 Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk
Other interventions
Normansell 2018 Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk
Watts 2012 Low concern Low concern Low concern Low concern Low risk

Complete details of all components of the ROBIS assessment are presented in Appendix 4.