5. ROBIS assessment of included reviews.
Review | Domain 1: study eligibility criteria | Domain 2: identification and selection of studies | Domain 3: data collection and study appraisal | Domain 4: synthesis and findings | Risk of bias in the review |
Inhaled treatment | |||||
Camargo 2003 | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Griffiths 2013 | Low concern | High concern | Low concern | Low concern | High risk |
Vezina 2014 | Low concern | High concern | Low concern | Low concern | High risk |
Knightly 2017 | Low concern | High concern | Low concern | Low concern | High risk |
Parenteral treatment | |||||
Mitra 2005 | Low concern | High concern | Unclear concern | Low concern | High risk |
Travers 2012a | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Travers 2012b | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Griffiths 2016 | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Jat 2012 | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Other interventions to reduce the work of breathing | |||||
Rodrigo 2006 | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Korang 2016 | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Other interventions | |||||
Normansell 2018 | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Watts 2012 | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low concern | Low risk |
Complete details of all components of the ROBIS assessment are presented in Appendix 4.