Outcome category |
Outcome |
Specific outcome measure used |
Reviews |
Length of stay |
Emergency department length of stay |
ED treatment time (units not specified) |
Camargo 2003 |
ED treatment time (minutes) |
Griffiths 2016 |
Hospital length of stay |
Length of hospital stay (days) |
Normansell 2018 |
|
Length of hospital stay (hours) |
Mitra 2005; Travers 2012b; Vezina 2014; Griffiths 2016
|
PICU length of stay |
PICU length of stay (hours) |
Travers 2012a |
Hospital admission |
Hospital admission rate |
Hospital admission rate |
Camargo 2003; Rodrigo 2006; Jat 2012; Watts 2012; Griffiths 2013; Griffiths 2016; Knightly 2017
|
Intensive care unit admission |
Intensive care unit admission |
HDU/ICU admission rates |
Mitra 2005; Vezina 2014; Knightly 2017
|
Adverse effects |
All adverse effects |
All adverse events |
Normansell 2018 |
Adverse health effects |
Vezina 2014 |
Any adverse event (during admission) |
Knightly 2017 |
Any adverse events |
Knightly 2017 |
Serious adverse events |
Serious adverse events |
Korang 2016; Knightly 2017; Normansell 2018
|
Serious adverse events (during admission) |
Knightly 2017 |
Death |
Death |
Mitra 2005 |
Mortality |
Korang 2016 |
Tremor |
Tremor |
Camargo 2003; Mitra 2005; Travers 2012b; Griffiths 2013
|
Nausea/vomiting |
Nausea/vomiting |
Camargo 2003; Travers 2012b
|
Vomiting |
Mitra 2005; Travers 2012b; Griffiths 2013
|
Nausea |
Travers 2012b; Griffiths 2013
|
Cardiovascular adverse effects |
Hypotension |
Knightly 2017 |
Flushing |
Knightly 2017 |
Arrhythmia |
Mitra 2005 |
Dysrhythmia |
Travers 2012b |
Palpitations |
Travers 2012b |
Neurological adverse effects |
Headache |
Mitra 2005; Travers 2012b
|
Seizures |
Mitra 2005 |
Pneumonia |
Pneumonia |
Korang 2016 |
Abnormal laboratory results |
CPK elevation |
Travers 2012b |
CPK‐MB elevation |
Travers 2012b |
Hyperglycaemia |
Travers 2012b |
Hypokalaemia |
Travers 2012b |
Symptom scores |
Symptom scores |
Symptom scores |
Camargo 2003 |
Change in clinical score at 120 minutes (± 30 minutes) |
Griffiths 2013 |
Change in pulmonary index score (final assessment) |
Watts 2012 |
Dyspnoea or pulmonary index |
Rodrigo 2006 |
Asthma clinical scores 8 to 36 hours after initial treatment |
Vezina 2014 |
Yung asthma severity score at 60 minutes |
Knightly 2017 |
Change in symptom scores 6 to 8 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Change in symptom scores 12 to 18 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Change in symptom scores 24 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Pulmonary index score |
Jat 2012 |
Asthma symptom score in the acute phase |
Korang 2016 |
Lung function |
Peak expiratory flow |
PEFR values (end of study) |
Camargo 2003 |
Peak expiratory flow (L/min) |
Normansell 2018 |
Percentages of predicted PEFR at 8 to 36 hours after initial treatment |
Vezina 2014 |
Pulmonary function PEF L/min |
Knightly 2017 |
Change in PEF 6 to 8 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Change in PEF 12 to 18 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Change in PEF 24 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Pulmonary function |
Pulmonary function |
Rodrigo 2006 |
Forced expiratory volume – one second |
Change in %predicted FEV1 within 4 hours of enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Change in %predicted FEV1 6 to 8 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Change in %predicted FEV1 12 to 18 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Change in %predicted FEV1 24 hours after enrolment |
Mitra 2005 |
Pulmonary function %predicted FEV1 |
Knightly 2017 |
Change in FEV1 (predicted) |
Watts 2012 |
Change in FEV1 (litres) |
Watts 2012 |
Change from baseline in %predicted FEV1, 60 minutes after last dose of inhaled bronchodilator |
Griffiths 2013 |
Change from baseline in %predicted FEV1, 120 minutes after last dose of inhaled bronchodilator |
Griffiths 2013 |
FEV1 or PEFR |
%Change in FEV1 or PEFR at 60 minutes after last inhaled bronchodilator (± 15 minutes) |
Griffiths 2013 |
%Change in FEV1 or PEFR at 120 minutes after last inhaled bronchodilator (± 30 minutes) |
Griffiths 2013 |
Respiratory resistance |
%Change in respiratory resistance at 60 minutes after inhaled bronchodilator (± 15 minutes) |
Griffiths 2013 |
%Change in respiratory resistance at 120 minutes after inhaled bronchodilator (± 30 minutes) |
Griffiths 2013 |
Vital signs |
Oxygen saturations |
Oxygen saturations < 95% at 60 minutes (± 15 minutes) |
Griffiths 2013 |
Oxygen saturations < 95% at 120 minutes (± 30 minutes) |
Griffiths 2013 |
SaO2 |
Rodrigo 2006 |
Pulse rate |
Pulse rate (beats/min) at 2 hours |
Travers 2012a |
Respiratory rate |
Change in respiratory rate (breaths/min) (final assessment) |
Watts 2012 |
Blood pressure |
Blood pressure |
Mitra 2005 |
Mechanical ventilation |
Mechanical ventilation |
Rates of patients mechanically ventilated in ICU |
Mitra 2005 |
Clinical failure |
Clinical failure |
Clinical failure |
Travers 2012a; Travers 2012b
|
Relapse |
Relapse/return to hospital |
Relapse |
Griffiths 2013 |
Relapse within 7 days |
Watts 2012 |
Relapse within 72 hours of discharge from hospital |
Vezina 2014 |
Return to ED within 48 hours |
Griffiths 2016 |
Withdrawals |
Withdrawals |
Withdrawals |
Watts 2012 |
Overall withdrawals |
Vezina 2014 |
Withdrawals due to deterioration |
Vezina 2014 |
Withdrawals due to adverse health effects |
Mitra 2005 |
Withdrawals due to poor asthma control |
Mitra 2005 |
Treatment intensity |
Respiratory therapist time |
Respiratory therapist time |
Camargo 2003 |
Frequency of nebuliser treatment |
Time to SABA spaced at 4 hours or longer (hours) |
Vezina 2014 |
Number of nebulisers required in 24 hours |
Mitra 2005 |
Need for additional treatment |
Need for further treatment after study medication |
Need for repeat bronchodilator treatment after standard protocol prior to disposition |
Griffiths 2013 |
Need for corticosteroids in ED prior to disposition |
Griffiths 2013 |
Requirement for additional care at end of study |
Watts 2012 |
Need for supplemental asthma therapy |
Vezina 2014 |
Worsened and required other adjuvant therapy |
Jat 2012 |