Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 5;2020(8):CD012977. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012977.pub2
Outcome category Outcome Specific outcome measure used Reviews
Length of stay Emergency department length of stay ED treatment time (units not specified) Camargo 2003
ED treatment time (minutes) Griffiths 2016
Hospital length of stay Length of hospital stay (days) Normansell 2018
  Length of hospital stay (hours) Mitra 2005; Travers 2012b; Vezina 2014; Griffiths 2016
PICU length of stay PICU length of stay (hours) Travers 2012a
Hospital admission Hospital admission rate Hospital admission rate Camargo 2003; Rodrigo 2006; Jat 2012; Watts 2012; Griffiths 2013; Griffiths 2016; Knightly 2017
Intensive care unit admission Intensive care unit admission HDU/ICU admission rates Mitra 2005; Vezina 2014; Knightly 2017
Adverse effects All adverse effects All adverse events Normansell 2018
Adverse health effects Vezina 2014
Any adverse event (during admission) Knightly 2017
Any adverse events Knightly 2017
Serious adverse events Serious adverse events Korang 2016; Knightly 2017; Normansell 2018
Serious adverse events (during admission) Knightly 2017
Death Death Mitra 2005
Mortality Korang 2016
Tremor Tremor Camargo 2003; Mitra 2005; Travers 2012b; Griffiths 2013
Nausea/vomiting Nausea/vomiting Camargo 2003; Travers 2012b
Vomiting Mitra 2005; Travers 2012b; Griffiths 2013
Nausea Travers 2012b; Griffiths 2013
Cardiovascular adverse effects Hypotension Knightly 2017
Flushing Knightly 2017
Arrhythmia Mitra 2005
Dysrhythmia Travers 2012b
Palpitations Travers 2012b
Neurological adverse effects Headache Mitra 2005; Travers 2012b
Seizures Mitra 2005
Pneumonia Pneumonia Korang 2016
Abnormal laboratory results CPK elevation Travers 2012b
CPK‐MB elevation Travers 2012b
Hyperglycaemia Travers 2012b
Hypokalaemia Travers 2012b
Symptom scores Symptom scores Symptom scores Camargo 2003
Change in clinical score at 120 minutes (± 30 minutes) Griffiths 2013
Change in pulmonary index score (final assessment) Watts 2012
Dyspnoea or pulmonary index Rodrigo 2006
Asthma clinical scores 8 to 36 hours after initial treatment Vezina 2014
Yung asthma severity score at 60 minutes Knightly 2017
Change in symptom scores 6 to 8 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Change in symptom scores 12 to 18 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Change in symptom scores 24 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Pulmonary index score Jat 2012
Asthma symptom score in the acute phase Korang 2016
Lung function Peak expiratory flow PEFR values (end of study) Camargo 2003
Peak expiratory flow (L/min) Normansell 2018
Percentages of predicted PEFR at 8 to 36 hours after initial treatment Vezina 2014
Pulmonary function PEF L/min Knightly 2017
Change in PEF 6 to 8 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Change in PEF 12 to 18 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Change in PEF 24 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Pulmonary function Pulmonary function Rodrigo 2006
Forced expiratory volume – one second Change in %predicted FEV1 within 4 hours of enrolment Mitra 2005
Change in %predicted FEV1 6 to 8 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Change in %predicted FEV1 12 to 18 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Change in %predicted FEV1 24 hours after enrolment Mitra 2005
Pulmonary function %predicted FEV1 Knightly 2017
Change in FEV1 (predicted) Watts 2012
Change in FEV1 (litres) Watts 2012
Change from baseline in %predicted FEV1, 60 minutes after last dose of inhaled bronchodilator Griffiths 2013
Change from baseline in %predicted FEV1, 120 minutes after last dose of inhaled bronchodilator Griffiths 2013
FEV1 or PEFR %Change in FEV1 or PEFR at 60 minutes after last inhaled bronchodilator (± 15 minutes) Griffiths 2013
%Change in FEV1 or PEFR at 120 minutes after last inhaled bronchodilator (± 30 minutes) Griffiths 2013
Respiratory resistance %Change in respiratory resistance at 60 minutes after inhaled bronchodilator (± 15 minutes) Griffiths 2013
%Change in respiratory resistance at 120 minutes after inhaled bronchodilator (± 30 minutes) Griffiths 2013
Vital signs Oxygen saturations Oxygen saturations < 95% at 60 minutes (± 15 minutes) Griffiths 2013
Oxygen saturations < 95% at 120 minutes (± 30 minutes) Griffiths 2013
SaO2 Rodrigo 2006
Pulse rate Pulse rate (beats/min) at 2 hours Travers 2012a
Respiratory rate Change in respiratory rate (breaths/min) (final assessment) Watts 2012
Blood pressure Blood pressure Mitra 2005
Mechanical ventilation Mechanical ventilation Rates of patients mechanically ventilated in ICU Mitra 2005
Clinical failure Clinical failure Clinical failure Travers 2012a; Travers 2012b
Relapse Relapse/return to hospital Relapse Griffiths 2013
Relapse within 7 days Watts 2012
Relapse within 72 hours of discharge from hospital Vezina 2014
Return to ED within 48 hours Griffiths 2016
Withdrawals Withdrawals Withdrawals Watts 2012
Overall withdrawals Vezina 2014
Withdrawals due to deterioration Vezina 2014
Withdrawals due to adverse health effects Mitra 2005
Withdrawals due to poor asthma control Mitra 2005
Treatment intensity Respiratory therapist time Respiratory therapist time Camargo 2003
Frequency of nebuliser treatment Time to SABA spaced at 4 hours or longer (hours) Vezina 2014
Number of nebulisers required in 24 hours Mitra 2005
Need for additional treatment Need for further treatment after study medication Need for repeat bronchodilator treatment after standard protocol prior to disposition Griffiths 2013
Need for corticosteroids in ED prior to disposition Griffiths 2013
Requirement for additional care at end of study Watts 2012
Need for supplemental asthma therapy Vezina 2014
Worsened and required other adjuvant therapy Jat 2012