Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 27;2020(8):CD013359. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013359.pub2

1. Key characteristics of included studies.

Study Index test Reference standard Study design HIV status Clinical setting High TB burden Specimens Uninterpretable results for tuberculosis detection
Anderson 2014 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Both Yes Sputum NR
Andriyoko 2019 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional NR NR Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, stool, sputum 6/40 (15%) stool, induced sputum or gastric aspirate specimen 1/30 (3%)
Atwebembeire 2016 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional Both NR No Sputum NR
Bacha 2017 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Both Yes Sputum 3/455 (0.6%)
Bates 2013 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional Both Inpatient Yes Sputum, gastric aspirate specimen 17/930 (1.8%)
Bhatia 2016 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional NR Inpatient Yes Cerebrospinal fluid NR
Bholla 2016 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cohort Both NR Yes Lymph node specimen 0/70 (0%)
Brent 2017 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both NR Yes Sputum NR
Bunyasi 2015 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Randomized trial HIV‐ Inpatient Yes Sputum, gastric aspirate specimen 47/4856 (0.9%)
Causse 2011 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional HIV‐ Laboratory No Gastric aspirate specimen, cerebrospinal fluid NR
Chipinduro 2017 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional Both Outpatient Yes Sputum, stool 1/218 (0.4%) induced sputum, 0/218 stool
Chisti 2014 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional NR Inpatient Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, sputum NR
Coetzee 2014 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional Both Both Yes Lymph node 1/110 (0.9%)
Das 2019 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional Both Both Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, cerebrospinal fluid, lymph node, sputum 2/181 (1%)
Gous 2015 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional NR NR Yes Sputum 27/467 (5.6%)
Hanrahan 2018 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cohort Both Outpatient Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, nasopharyngeal specimen, sputum, stool 15/114 (13%) stool, 1/57 (1.7%) gastric, 1/103 (.9%) IS
Hasan 2017 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional HIV‐ Both Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, stool, sputum NR
Kasa Tom 2018 Xpert MTB/RIF Composite Cohort Both Inpatient Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, sputum NR
Kim 2015 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional NR Inpatient No Lymph node specimen NR
LaCourse 2014 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional Both Inpatient No Sputum 0/300 (0%)
LaCourse 2018 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort HIV+ Inpatient Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, sputum, stool 2/150 (1.3%)
Ligthelm 2011 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional NR Both Yes Lymph node specimen 0/2 (0%)
Malbruny 2011 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional NR Laboratory No Gastric aspirate specimen, cerebrospinal fluid, lymph node, sputum NR
Marcy 2016 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cohort HIV+ NR Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, nasopharyngeal specimen, sputum, stool NR
Moussa 2016 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort HIV‐ NR No Sputum, stool 1/230 (.4%)
Myo 2018 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional Both Inpatient Yes Gastric aspirate specimen 4/231 (1.7%)
Nhu 2013 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional Both Inpatient Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, sputum, cerebrospinal fluid NR
Nicol 2011 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional Both Inpatient Yes Sputum NR
Nicol 2013 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Both Yes Sputum, stool NR
Nicol 2018 Xpert MTB/RIF and Xpert Ultra Culture, Composite Cohort Both Inpatient Yes Sputum NR
Orikiriza 2018 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Both No Sputum, stool 2/357 (0.5%) sputum, 1/64 (1.5%) stool
Pang 2014 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional Unk/NR Inpatient Yes Gastric aspirate specimen NR
Rachow 2012 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Both Yes Sputum NR
Reither 2015 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both NR Yes Sputum NR
Sabi 2018 Xpert MTB/RIF and Xpert Ultra Culture, Composite Cohort Both Both Yes Sputum 3/520 (0.5%)
Saini 2018 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional HIV‐ Inpatient Yes Bronchoalveolar lavage NR
Sekadde 2013 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional Both Both No Sputum 2/250 (0.8%)
Singh M 2016 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional NR Inpatient Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, sputum NR
Solomons 2015 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional Both Inpatient Yes Cerebrospinal fluid NR
Togun 2015 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cross‐sectional HIV‐ Outpatient No Sputum NR
Tortoli 2012 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional NR Laboratory No Gastric aspirate specimen, cerebrospinal fluid, lymph node specimen 0/306
Vadwai 2011 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional Both Both Yes Cerebrospinal fluid NR
Walters 2014 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional Both Inpatient Yes Bronchoalveolar lavage NR
Walters 2017a Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Both Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, sputum, stool 28/379 (7%)
Walters 2018a Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Both Yes Gastric aspirate specimen, sputum, stool 12/259 (5%) stool, 8/259 (3%) respiratory
Yin 2014 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture Cross‐sectional NR Inpatient Yes Bronchoalveolar lavage 4/255 (1.6%)
Zar 2012 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Inpatient Yes Nasopharyngeal specimen, sputum NR
Zar 2013 Xpert MTB/RIF Culture, Composite Cohort Both Outpatient Yes Nasopharyngeal specimen, sputum 12/1754 (0.6%)
Zar 2019 Xpert MTB/RIF and Xpert Ultra Culture, Composite Cohort Both Inpatient Yes Nasopharyngeal specimen, sputum NR

IS: induced sputum; NR: not reported; TB: tuberculosis.