Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 20;14(1):1883911. doi: 10.1080/16549716.2021.1883911

Table 1.

Summary of the policy analysis findings using Kingdon’s three streams framework [34]

Stream Topic Factors facilitating SSB taxation Barriers to SSB taxation
Problem Current understanding of the problem of NR-NCDs
  • NR-NCDs considered a national problem, resulting in premature death & loss of productivity

  • NR-NCDs impact on individual, family & community because of high cost of lifelong treatment & loss of productivity

  • NR-NCDs recognised as an outcome of increased urbanisation

  • Primary focus of food policy is undernutrition and food security rather than unhealthy diet related to NR-NCDs

  • Sugar not specified as a target risk factor for NR-NCDs – no explicit target for sugar consumption reduction

Policy Existing policy environment addressing NCD intervention
  • Multi-sectoral approach to address NR-NCDs prevention

  • Coherence between central and community-based interventions

  • Excise tax of 39% levied on SSBs and non-SSBs; to increase Government revenue, not designed to support healthy consumption behaviour

  • Beverage consumption considered to be elastic; sensitive to price in the last five years

  • NR-NCDs interventions rely heavily on Government funding, which is considered to be unsustainable

  • SSB industry is one component of vision for national economic development

  • Public–private partnerships exist to maximise value chain from growing, manufacturing and marketing of sugar-containing products, including SSBs

  • Policy incoherence between Government’s vision for sugar industry and health goals to tackle NR-NCDs

  • Access to quality drinking water, which is still a major challenge for large proportion of population, may encourage consumption of SSBs.

Politics Stakeholder politics and SSB taxation
  • Opportunity exists for broad coalition of government and civil society players

  • Beverage industry is a duopoly, dominated by one large company – a subsidiary of a multi-national beverages concern

  • Local industry positions itself as good corporate citizen by providing jobs, paying taxes, and investing in social development