Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 6;7(3):448–457. doi: 10.1093/jhps/hnaa064

Table VII.

Interobserver and intraobserver reliability of Beck classification for labral tears

Interobserver agreement
Intraobserver agreement
Variable AC (SE) Kappa (SE) Proportion agreement (SE) AC (SE) Kappa (SE) Proportion agreement (SE)
Labral tear Beck classificationa 0.745 (0.078) 0.208 (0.301) 0.900 (0.030) 0.562 (0.103) 0.234 (0.160) 0.811 (0.040)
Clock face labral tear (yes/no)
 1 o′clock 0.876 (0.143) −0.059 (0.026) 0.889 (0.120) 0.929 (0.053) −0.034 (0.025) 0.933 (0.046)
 2 o′clock 0.876 (0.143) −0.059 (0.026) 0.889 (0.120) N/A N/A 1 (0)
 3 o′clock −0.229 (0.758) −0.260 (0.437) 0.378 (0.322) 0.412 (0.181) −0.250 (0.071) 0.600 (0.091)
 4–10 o′clock N/A N/A 1 (0) N/A N/A 1 (0)
 11 o′clock 0.901 (0.074) 0.153 (0.374) 0.911 (0.061) 0.890 (0.068) −0.053 (0.031) 0.900 (0.056)
 12 o′clock 0.199 (0.336) 0.016 (0.252) 0.556 (0.147) −0.245 (0.211) −0.435 (0.141) 0.333 (0.088)

Agreement measures are shown as point estimate (standard error). N/A is indicated when all observers rated the variable as ‘No’ or ‘Normal’.

a

Weighted agreement measure.