Table 2 .
Potential use errors | Frequency of occurrence | Description and direct quotes from participants | Mitigation strategies | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Task 1—Cartridge setup | No standard materials used | 0 cases | ||
Damaged equipment | 1 case | ‘the various elements of the cartridge had come loose, and the lid had come off’ (CH2-CH3). | Leaflet for a rapid check of package content with visual | |
Misplaced cartridges | 0 cases | ‘It can only fit the right [location] at the right time. So, if you have picked up the wrong cartridge at that point when it prompted you to put it in, it wouldn’t fit’ (CH1) | One-way interlocking components | |
User forgets the correct sequence of steps | 0 cases | |||
Reagents not stored properly | 1 case | ‘Reagents are expected to be stored in a fridge and this was not explained clearly during the training’ (CH2-CH3). | Support for operators: implementation of training and Instruction for use (e.g. dedicated video demonstration regarding frequent errors and malfunctions) | |
Task 2—insert the cartridge and initiate test | Foil lid not removed as indicated | 2 cases | The aluminium foil did not remove one of the glue coverings: a small amount of glue and foil was left on the cassette. The prong got caught and it tipped it over slightly and took the casing off the prong (CH4). Unclear aluminium foil removal procedure – ‘One batch was processed without the foil being pulled back, but it seems to produce unchanged results. So, I’m not quite sure…And results were reported without the machine going into failure mode’ (CH4). |
Design changes I: dye-coloured glue coverings to make residual visible; Design changes II: peeling-off symbol depicted on the aluminium foil surface; Procedure changes: Internal quality control from operators (e.g. cartridge surface cleaning with dedicated wipe). |
Premix container not locked into place | 0 cases | |||
Fiddly parts not easily handled | 0 cases | |||
Reduced dexterity with gloves | 0 cases | |||
Misplaced transfer cartridges and extraction cartridges | 0 cases | |||
Labels not visible | 0 cases | |||
User forgets sequence of steps | 1 case | Sample run twice: no warning message – ‘With the second batch [of tests], I ran into a problem. I put a sample from the same tube into the process, so where only seven samples, one of them was duplicated. As soon as I moved on to the next sample, I realised it was a mistake’ (CH4) | ||
The user inserts incorrect extraction lot number and reagent lot number | 0 cases | |||
User not able to troubleshoot | 1 case | Malfunctioning door closing - ‘We had a problem with the door closure of the equipment, which the engineer came and sorted it out’. (CH4) | Rapid troubleshooting guide on-screen display. Support for operators: implementation of training and Instruction for use (e.g. dedicated video demonstration regarding frequent errors and malfunctions) |
|
Interface not prompting correctly | 1 case | Faulty message: the ‘remove the cartridge’ message appeared on screen although cartridges were correctly removed from the machine. Staff members reported splash marks and one stated ‘small splash marks on the cartridge holder which I gently wiped away with an antibacterial wipe. This worked and cleared the message and the machine continued to close the door and move on’ (CH2–CH3). The manufacturer was called, and he advised not to use alcohol-based wipes for this in future but that the response had otherwise been correct. The company did not foresee any risk of spillage. | Support for operators: implementation of training and Instruction for use (e.g. dedicated video demonstration regarding frequent errors and malfunctions) | |
Interface (touch screen) not responsive | 0 cases | |||
Task 3—Test results | Reactions interrupted before it’s finished | 0 cases | ||
Misinterpretation of test results | 1 case | The same sample runs twice on POCKIT™ Central: a positive result first and a negative result subsequently were shown (CH2). | Decisional algorithm to be explored/implemented | |
Results not saved appropriately | 0 cases | |||
results failed to be exported on a USB drive | 0 cases | |||
Task 4—dispose of the material | 0 cases |