Table 1.
Study | (Sample Size) & Population | Intervention & Design | Muscle: EMG Index Test | Reference Standard | Target Response | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Respiratory Mechanics (Loading/Unloading) | Respiratory Sensation (Dyspnea) | |||||
Brochard et al. (1989) | (N = 8) subjects with RF & PMV | 4 levels of MV support (PSV 0 – 15 cmH2o), prospective cohort | SCM: EMGMAX | RR, VT, VE, Pdi, Edi, ΔPes - ΔV, , & diaphragm H/L frequency ratio | + | N/A |
Imsand et al. (1994) | (N = 5) subjects with RF | 3 levels of MV support (During SIMV-PSV mode: Low, medium & high), prospective cohort | SCM: EMGMAX & EMGTi | RR, VT, VE, PTP, Edi, ΔPes - ΔV, diaphragmatic EMGTi and TIe, & P0.1 | + | N/A |
Tassaux et al. (2002) | (N = 10) subjects with RF | Equal levels of MV support (during SIMV-PS & ASV modes), prospective cohort | SCM: EMGAUC | RR, VT, VE, & P0.1 | + | N/A |
Schmidt et al. (2013) | (N = 12) subjects with RF | 2 low & 2 high levels Of MV support (PSV 6–12 ml/kg), prospective cohort | Para, scalene & ala-nasi: EMGMAX, EMG/min & EMGAUC | RR, Vt, PVA & VAS-dyspnea | + | + |
Cecchini et al. (2014) | (N = 12) subjects with RF & PMV | 7 levels of MV support (during PSV & NAVA 7–20 cmH2O), prospective cohort | Scalene & ala-nasi: EMGAUC | RR, VT, Edi & | + | N/A |
Walterspacher et al. (2016) | (N = 9) subjects with RF & PMV | PCV & PSV at different body position, prospective cohort | Para: EMGMAX | RR, Borg scale & diaphragmatic sEMG | N/A | + |
Bellani et al. (2018) | (N = 14) subjects with RF | 3 levels MV support (during PSV changing by 4 cmH2O), prospective cohort | Para & SCM: EMGMAX, EMG/min & EMGMEAN | Pmus, Edi & diaphragmatic sEMG | N/A | N/A |
N/A, data not available, + responsive; PSV, pressure support ventilation; SIMV, synchronized intermittent mandatory ventilation; ASV, adaptive synchronized ventilation; NAVA, neurally adjusted ventilatory assist; PCV, pressure control ventilation; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; RF, respiratory failure; PMV, prolonged mechanical ventilation; SCM, sternocleidomastoid; para, parasternal; EMGMAX, maximum EMG activity; EMGAUC, EMG area under the curve; EMG/min, EMG activity per minute; EMGMIN, minimum EMG activity; EMGMEAN, mean EMG activity; EMGMAX-MIN, maximum-minimum EMG activity; Pdi, trans-diaphragmatic pressure; Edi, electrical activity of the diaphragm; RR, respiratory rate; VT, tidal volume; , minute ventilation; , oxygen uptake; P0.1, occlusion pressure at 1 milliseconds; PTP, pressure time product; ΔPes −ΔV, esophageal pressure – volume curve; EMGTi, duration of electrical activity; TIe mechanical duration of inspiratory effort; H/L, high/low; VAS, visual analogue scale; PVA, patient-ventilator asynchrony; Pmus, inspiratory muscle pressure; , end tidal carbon dioxide.