Table 1.
Our study discovery | Sample size by DNAm array | Replication GS/CATHGEN/HyperGEN | Combined discovery and replication | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DMP | Chr | Position (hg38) | Gene | Effect | p | 450K | EPIC 850 K | Effect | p | Effect | p |
cg13235761^ | 1 | 203,592,452 | − 37.61 | 4.33E−06 | 3048 | 2378 | − 25.28 | 5.08E−05 | − 29.81 | 1.88E−09 | |
cg26099045^* | 2 | 64,064,666 | 14.82 | 5.74E−06 | 3050 | 2378 | 11.24 | 1.01E−04 | 12.81 | 3.26E−09 | |
cg04428662^Ω* | 4 | 2,932,461 | MFSD10 | − 30.84 | 3.21E−06 | 3049 | 2378 | − 34.94 | 3.43E−07 | − 32.82 | 5.51E−12 |
cg23174201^* | 5 | 151,674,695 | SPARC | − 35.83 | 5.10E−06 | 3050 | 2378 | − 34.87 | 1.72E−07 | − 35.27 | 4.02E−12 |
cg17170437 | 6 | 44,229,461 | SLC29A1 | − 47.62 | 1.96E−06 | N/A | 2378 | − 18.62 | 1.49E−04 | − 24.24 | 3.80E−08 |
cg14871770 | 10 | 96,658,622 | CYP2C9, CYPC19 | − 53.12 | 1.98E−06 | N/A | 2378 | − 25.87 | 1.70E−04 | − 33.36 | 1.23E−08 |
cg02157636 | 11 | 68,709,367 | TESMIN | − 53.21 | 2.15E−06 | N/A | 2378 | − 27.25 | 1.14E−05 | − 33.33 | 8.58E−10 |
cg26039141^Ω | 11 | 75,402,116 | RPS3 | − 39.14 | 3.40E−06 | 3050 | 2378 | − 33.42 | 1.78E−05 | − 36.06 | 2.90E−10 |
cg22593432^* | 13 | 32,001,768 | − 29.91 | 1.54E−07 | 3050 | 2378 | − 17.66 | 1.79E−04 | − 22.64 | 4.61E−10 | |
cg11789371^* | 14 | 102,085,048 | HSP90AA1 | − 35.40 | 4.44E−06 | 3050 | 2378 | − 22.66 | 3.58E−04 | − 27.80 | 1.41E−08 |
cg05796561 | 18 | 57,128,273 | − 45.24 | 2.96E−06 | N/A | 2378 | − 22.91 | 1.69E−04 | − 29.24 | 1.41E−08 | |
cg17944885^Ω* | 19 | 12,114,920 | ZNF20, ZNF788P | − 32.71 | 1.41E−09 | 3048 | 2378 | − 16.34 | 5.67E−07 | − 20.72 | 1.24E−13 |
cg15787712^ | 19 | 13,837,429 | LOC284454, MIR23 | − 37.60 | 6.00E−09 | 3050 | 2378 | − 28.65 | 2.06E−05 | − 33.30 | 9.01E−13 |
p-value for replication < 6.4E−04 (Bonferroni correction for 78 DMPs tested). Four of the 13 DMPs that replicated were non-450K probes (cg17170437, cg14871770, cg02157636, cg05796561). Results from combined discovery and replication are also shown
GS Generation Scotland, N/A not applicable
^cis-meQTL from the BIOS QTL [36, 37]
ΩExpression quantitative trait methylation (eQTM) data from the BIOS QTL (enrichment p-value <0.01) [36, 37]
*cis-meQTL in the Framingham Heart Study [38]