Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 12;24(2):183–195. doi: 10.4048/jbc.2021.24.e20

Table 4. Comparison between gasless and gas-inflated techniques.

Features Gasless Gas-inflated
Common features Same patient position
Single hidden axillary incision
Same sentinel lymph node biopsy procedure
Differences
Size of the initial incision ≥ 4 cm Depends on the single port ring size; usually 2.5–3.5 cm
Subcutaneous flap lifting Self-retractor (Chung's) Gas insufflation
Working space area Wide Small space for port insertion
Surgical field Open Closed
Use of suction device Easy Difficult
Use of a single-port device No Yes or no
Nipple margin biopsy method Manual Robot-assisted
Advantage • Less fogginess because of open surgical field • Possibly less bleeding because of CO2 gas insufflation
• Steady elevation of subcutaneous flaps • Less need for additional manipulations for setting the robotic arms
• No air leak • Dissection of subcutaneous flaps while maintaining dome shape of the breast
• Surgeons with experience performing gasless thyroidectomy using a self-retractor are familiar with this technique
Disadvantages • Inevitable need to manipulate the position of the self-retractor to maintain a proper surgical view • Visual disturbance by smoke
• Potential risk of gas leak
• Subcutaneous emphysema
• Hypercapnia
• Air embolism