Table 1.
Empirical quantitative studies on psychological stress as a function of chronic environmental contamination, selected through the systematic review.
Publication | Contamination event/source | Region | Study design | Independent variable (s) | Dependent variable (s) | Risk of bias | n | r |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Behbod et al. (2014) | Tert-butyl mercaptan exposure, tank leak | Prichard, AL, US | Cross-sectional | Distance | General stress | Low | 204 | 0.24 |
Bevc et al. (2007)b | Landfill/waste site | Ft. Lauderdale, FL, US | Cross-sectional | Subjective | Depression, | Low | 223 | 0.230 |
PTSD | .26 | |||||||
Cline et al. (2014) | Asbestos exposure, industrial activity | Libby, MT, US | Cross-sectional | Proxy measure | General stress | High | 208 | 0.39 |
Couch and Mercuri (2007)b | Benzene exposure from industrial activity | Houston, TX, US | Case-control | Objective | General stress | Low | 341 | 0.580 |
550 | .430 | |||||||
386 | .340 | |||||||
405 | .31 | |||||||
Cutchin et al. (2008) | Industrial activity and refinery explosion | Texas City, TX, US | Before-and-after | Distance | General stress | Low | 315 | 0.15 |
Downey and Van Willigen (2005)b | Proximity to chronic industrial activity | Chicago & neighboring counties in IL, US | Cross-sectional | Objective | General stress | Low | 1210 | 0.230 |
.190 | ||||||||
Depression | .11 | |||||||
Elliott et al. (1997)a | Landfill | Milton, ON, CA | Before-and-after | High | ||||
Elliott et al. 2018 | Proximity to unconventional oil & gas wells | Belmont County, OH, US | Cross-sectional | Objective | General stress | Low | 66 | 0.16 |
Fitzgerald et al. (2008) | Polychlorinated biphenyl exposure, water, industrial activity | Hudson River Area, NY, US | Cross-sectional | Objective | Depression | Low | 243 | 0.16 |
Fortenberry et al. (2018)a | Lead exposure, water | Flint, MI, US | Cross-sectional | High | ||||
Ginsberg et al. (2012) | Chlorine exposure, railway accident | Graniteville, SC, US | Cross-sectional | Health | PTSD | Low | 225 | 0.45 |
Grasmück and Scholz (2005) | Heavy metal exposure, soil, industrial activity | Dornach, Switzerland | Case-control | Subjective | General stress | High | 57 | 0.63 |
Greve et al. (2005)b | Toxic waste cloud, railway accident | Eunice, LA, US | Case-control | Objective | General stress | Low | 78 | 0.370 |
Depression | .370 | |||||||
PTSD | .37 | |||||||
Greve et al. (2007)b | Toxic waste cloud, railway accident | Eunice, LA, US | Case-control | Objective | Anxiety | Low | 51 | .17c |
General Stress | .30c | |||||||
PTSD | .34c | |||||||
Anxiety | 51 | .36d | ||||||
Depression | .18d | |||||||
Ha et al. (2018)b | Heavy traffic roads contaminated by radiation | Seoul, South Korea | Cross-sectional | Subjective | Anxiety | Low | 8826 | 0.220 |
General stress | .19 | |||||||
Hastrup et al. (2007)b | Hazardous dumping, historic industrial activity | Anonymous | Case-control | Objective | General stress | Low | 290 | 0.280 |
Appalachian | .340 | |||||||
Community | Depression | .47 | ||||||
Korol et al. (1999) | Nuclear waste, government activities | Fernald, OH, US | Cross-sectional | Distance | PTSD | High | 91 | 0.54 |
Kruger et al. (2017a) | Lead exposure, water | Flint, MI, US | Cross-sectional | Subjective | PTSD | High | 786 | 0.25 |
Kruger et al. (2017b)b | Lead exposure, water | Flint, MI, US | Cross-sectional | Subjective | General stress | High | 834 | 0.250 |
.16 | ||||||||
Kruger et al. (2017c) | Lead exposure, water | Flint, MI, US | Cross-sectional | Subjective | General stress | High | 277 | 0.22 |
Levy et al. (2004)a | Environmental exposures, public housing | Boston, MA, US | Cross-sectional | High | ||||
Matthies et al. (2000)b | Benzo(a)pyrene exposure, soil, industrial activity | Dortmund-Dorstfeld, Germany | Case-control | Subjective | General stress | Low | 152 | 0.460 |
Objective | 415 | .17 | ||||||
McCarron et al. (2000)b | Landfill, chromium waste | Glasgow, Scotland | Case-control | Health | General stress | Low | 398 | 0.080 |
Objective | 798 | .001 | ||||||
McComas and Trumbo (2001)a | Landfills, chronic industrial activity | Various communities, NY State, US | Cross-sectional | High | ||||
McIntyre et al. (2018) | Chronic industrial activity | Various communities, Australia | Cross-sectional | Distance | General stress | Low | 2009 | 0.03 |
Peek et al. (2009)b | Chronic industrial activity | Texas City, TX, US | Cross-sectional | Subjective | General stress | Low | 2604 | 0.060 |
Depression | .13 | |||||||
Rehner et al. (2000) | Methyl parathion exposure, pesticide use | Jackson County, MS, US | Follow-up cohort | Time | Depression | Low | 115 | 0.25 |
Reif et al. (2003)a | Trichloroethylene exposure, water | Denver, CO, US | Cross-sectional | Low | ||||
Sansom et al. (2017) | Waste sites and industrial activity | Houston, TX, US | Cross-sectional | Time | General stress | High | 109 | 0.08 |
Santiago-Rivera et al. (2007) | Polychlorinated biphenyl exposure, water | Akwasasne Mohawk reservation, NY, US | Cross-sectional | Objective | General stress | Low | 353 | 0.18 |
Schade et al. (2015)a | 4-methylcyclohexane methanol exposure, solvent spill | Charleston, WV, US | Retrospective follow-up | High | ||||
Schade et al. (2016) | 4-methylcyclohexane methanol exposure, solvent spill | Charleston, WV, US | Retrospective follow-up | Health | General stress | High | 489 | 0.47 |
Song et al. (2018)a | Hydrogen fluoride exposure, spill/transport accident | Gumi, South Korea | Cross-sectional | Low | ||||
Ushijima et al. (2004) | Methylmercury exposure, water, industrial activity | Minamata City, Japan | Follow-up cohort | Health | General stress | High | 133 | 0.47 |
Vandermoere (2006) | Heavy metal exposure, soil, industrial activity | Kouterwijk, Belgium | Cross-sectional | Subjective | General stress | High | 98 | 0.38 |
Vandermoere (2008)b | Heavy metal exposure, soil, industrial activity | Kouterwijk, Belgium | Case-control | Objective | General stress | High | 300 | 0.420 |
.190 | ||||||||
Anxiety | .11 | |||||||
Verschuur et al. (2007)b | Rumored uranium exposure, airplane accident | Amsterdam, Netherlands | Before-and-after | Health | General stress | High | 1074 | 0.260 |
.390 | ||||||||
Anxiety | .340 | |||||||
PTSD | .36 | |||||||
Verschuur et al. (2008)b | Rumored uranium exposure, airplane accident | Amsterdam, Netherlands | Follow-up cohort | Health | Anxiety | High | 168 | 0.120 |
General Stress | .040 | |||||||
PTSD | .09 | |||||||
Weinert et al. (2011)b | Asbestos exposure, industrial activity | Libby, MT, US | Cross-sectional | Distance | General stress | High | 386 | 0.090 |
Depression | .03 | |||||||
Whiteman et al. (1995)a | Lead/chemical exposure, mining and industry | Kinston, Australia | Follow-up cohort | High | ||||
Zierold et al. (2004) | Arsenic exposure, water | Sinnipee/St. Peter, WI, US | Cross-sectional | Objective | Depression | High | 1185 | 0.38 |
k = 60 | N = 25,858 | r = 0.26 |
Studies not included in the meta-analysis.
Includes multiple effects from the same participants.
Effects from child participants.
Effects for parents of child participants.