Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 29;2021(4):CD008189. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008189.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
ACTRN12610000631000 2010 Wrong intervention: acupuncture; no minimal comparison group (lifestyle advice in both groups)
Aflatoonian 2014 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (vitamin D)
Agricola 2014 Wrong study design: no RCT
Asemi 2014 Wrong patient population: not infertile (gestational diabetes)
Ashcroft 1997 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (patient education)
Bai 2019 Wrong intervention: intervention on psychological distress
Bailey 2015 Wrong patient population: recurrent miscarriages
Barbour 2020 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (counselling on infertility treatment)
Becker 2015 Wrong intervention: main component LGI ‐ diet (no advice)
Beerendonk 1996a Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; sodium restriction to reduce bloating
Beerendonk 1996b Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; sodium restriction to reduce bloating
Beerendonk 1999 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; sodium restriction to reduce bloating
Bell 2000 Wrong patient population: not infertile (antenatal population)
Bernard 2020 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (counselling on infertility treatment)
Bisht 2018 Wrong intervention: no RCT
Bodin 2017 Wrong patient population: not infertile
Bodin 2018 Wrong patient population: not infertile
Carpenter 2016 Wrong intervention: strict diet intervention; walnut supplementation
Chan 2012 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (integrative body/mind/body intervention)
Chan 2015 Wrong study design: no RCT
Chavarro 2016 Wrong study design: no RCT
Christensen 2017 Wrong study design: no RCT
Clark 2000 Wrong intervention: no minimal control (standard weight loss advice vs attendance at a group session)
Clifton 2017 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (mind/body intervention)
Clifton 2018 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (mind/body intervention)
Connolly 1993 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (psychological counselling)
CTRI201711010514 2017 Wrong intervention: strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Dancet 2019 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (sexual education intervention)
Domar 2009 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (mind/body intervention)
Domar 2011 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (mind/body intervention)
Domar 2019 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (mind/body intervention)
Dortaj 2016 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (mindfulness)
DRKS00017554 2019 Wrong patient population: not infertile
Einarsson 2017a Wrong intervention: strict weight loss intervention with liquid formula diet
Einarsson 2017b Wrong intervention: strict weight loss intervention with liquid formula diet
Einarsson 2018 Wrong intervention: strict weight loss intervention with liquid formula diet
Einarsson 2019 Wrong intervention: strict weight loss intervention with liquid formula diet
Elsinga 2008 Wrong study design: no RCT
Emery 2001 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (psychological counselling)
Emery 2002 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (psychological counselling)
Emery 2003 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (psychological counselling)
Emery 2004 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (psychological counselling)
Emery 2006 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (psychological counselling)
Espinos 2017 Wrong intervention: main component LGI ‐ diet (no advice)
Fauque 2007 Wrong study design: no RCT
Galhardo 2013 Wrong study design: no RCT
Garruti 2017 Wrong study design: no RCT
Gaskins 2018 Wrong study design: no RCT
Gaskins 2019 Wrong study design: no RCT
Gautam 2019a Wrong intervention: strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Gautam 2019b Wrong intervention: strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Goswami 2015 Wrong study design: no RCT
Guzick 1994 Wrong patient population: not infertile
Hamzehgardeshi 2019 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (fertility education and group counselling)
Hoirisch Clapauch 2017 Wrong patient population: recurrent miscarriages
HuMl 2016 Wrong study design: no RCT
IRCT201110267915N1 2014 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (psychological counselling)
IRCT201301189463N 2017 Wrong study design: no RCT
IRCT20150119020719N6 2018 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (fertility education and group counselling)
IRCT2016012610324N 2016 Wrong patient population: not infertile (preconception)
IRCT20160605028270N2 2020 Wrong intervention: strict exercise intervention (no exercise allowed outside intervention)
ISRCTN03259732 2014 Wrong patient population: not infertile (women planning pregnancy)
ISRCTN11081163 2016 Wrong patient population: not infertile (preconception)
ISRCTN17222161 2017 Other reason, trial superseded by another trial
Jaffar 2018 Wrong study design: no RCT
Jamali 2016 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; psychological and sexual counselling
Jiménez Tuñón 2017 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; supplements: melatonin, myo‐inositol, folic acid, selenium
Kaya 2016 Wrong study design: no RCT (interventional)
Kermack 2014 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict diet intervention
Kermack 2017 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict diet intervention
Kersten 2015 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component; tailored expected management and implementation
Kiel 2018 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised HITT)
Kirca 2019 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Li 2016 Wrong study design: no RCT
Li 2017 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (fertility education and counselling)
Lundgren 2016 Wrong intervention: strict exercise intervention (supervised)
Maleki 2017a Wrong intervention: strict exercise intervention (no exercise allowed outside intervention)
Maleki 2017b Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (no exercise allowed outside intervention)
Maleki 2017c Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (no exercise allowed outside intervention)
Maleki 2018 Wrong intervention: strict exercise intervention (no exercise allowed outside intervention)
Maleki 2020 Wrong intervention: strict exercise intervention (no exercise allowed outside intervention)
Mirghafourvand 2020 Wrong patient population: not infertile
Moran 2011 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict weight loss intervention and no minimal comparison group
Moran 2016b Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict weight loss intervention and no minimal comparison group
Mori 2009 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (stress management)
Mumford 2020 Wrong study design: no RCT
Naab 2019 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice (depression intervention)
Nayar 2017 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Nayar 2018 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
NCT01509066 2012 Wrong patient population: not infertile
NCT01566929 2012 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict weight loss intervention with liquid formula diet
NCT01716429 2012 Wrong patient population: solely PCOS
NCT01892111 2013 Wrong patient population: solely PCOS
NCT01933633 2013 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised)
NCT01952795 2013 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict weight loss intervention
NCT01954498 2013 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict diet intervention (walnut trial)
NCT02063256 2014 Wrong study design: no RCT
NCT02432209 2015 Wrong intervention: no minimal comparison group (lifestyle advice in both groups)
NCT02541487 2015 Wrong study design: no RCT
NCT02648555 2016 Wrong patient population: recurrent miscarriages
NCT02746601 2016 Wrong study design: no RCT
NCT02752555 2016 Wrong intervention: only lifestyle advice in control group (Intervention = Oral Carnitine)
NCT03050944 2017 Wrong study design: no RCT (association)
NCT03343405 2017 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (mind/body intervention)
NCT03348865 2017 Wrong intervention: psychological counselling
NCT03475199 2018 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict lifestyle intervention
NCT03553927 2018 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict weight loss intervention
NCT03898037 2019 Wrong intervention: no minimal comparison group (lifestyle advice in both groups compared to metformin)
NCT04002414 2019 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention depending on activity level
NCT04273048 2020 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict weight loss intervention
NCT04585581 2020 Wrong patient population: not infertile (< 6 months)
Nieschlag 1998 Wrong intervention: psychological counselling
Overdijkink 2018 Wrong study design: no RCT
PACTR201611001683280 2016 Wrong study design: no RCT
Pedro 2019 Wrong patient population: people desiring to become pregnant
Poehl 1999 Wrong study design: no RCT (and psychological counselling)
Psaros 2015 Wrong study design: no RCT (and mind/body intervention)
Rasoulzadeh 2013 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (psychological counselling)
Rasoulzadeh 2018 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (psychological counselling)
RBR‐7by76r 2016 Wrong intervention: no minimal comparison group (lifestyle advice in both groups)
Rothberg 2016 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict weight loss intervention (Optifast)
Sant'Anna 2017 Wrong intervention: no minimal comparison group
Schick 2019 Wrong intervention: positive adjustment coping intervention
Shahrestani 2012 Wrong intervention: mindfulness‐based cognitive group therapy (MBCT)
Sim 2012 Wrong intervention: strict weight loss intervention (VLED)
Sim 2014 Wrong intervention: strict weight loss intervention (VLED)
Skogsdal 2019 Wrong patient population: preconception lifestyle advice
Tolahunase 2017 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Tolahunase 2018 Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Tolahunase 2018a Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Tolahunase 2018b Wrong intervention: no preconception lifestyle advice; strict exercise intervention (supervised yoga visits)
Tsagareli 2006 Wrong study design: no RCT and strict weight loss intervention (Optifast)
Twigt 2012 Wrong study design: no RCT (association)
UMIN000009034 2012 Wrong study design: no RCT
UMIN000016168 2015 Wrong intervention (and study population): preconception lifestyle advice not main component (fertility education)
UMIN000027424 2017 Wrong study design: no RCT
Vause 2018 Wrong intervention: preconception lifestyle advice not main component (fertility education intervention)

HITT: XXX.

LGI: XXX.

MBCT: mindfulness‐based cognitive therapy.

PCOS: polycystic ovarian syndrome.

RCT: randomised controlled trial.

VLED: very low energy diet.