Skip to main content
. 2020 Nov 4;2020(11):CD013004. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013004.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Aalbers 2012 Study design (no RCT)
Abdel‐Salam 2015 Type of participants (focus on cardiomyopathy, not heart failure alone)
Adamyan 2010 Study design (no RCT)
Adamyan 2011 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Adamyan 2013 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Adamyan 2015b Type of participants (focus on atrial fibrillation, not heart failure)
Al 2013 Study design (no RCT)
Amosova 2011a Study design (no RCT)
Amosova 2011b Study design (no RCT)
Amosova 2012a Study design (no RCT)
Amosova 2012b Study design (no RCT)
Amosova 2014 Study design (no RCT)
Cavusoglu 2012 Type of intervention (ivabradine plus dobutamine)
Cavusoglu 2015 Type of intervention (ivabradine plus dobutamine)
Chumburidze 2013 Study design (no RCT)
CN‐01908706 2018 Types of participants
Cocco 2013 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Cullington 2011 Study design (no RCT)
De 2014 Study design (no RCT)
De Ferrari 2008 Study design (no RCT)
EUCTR2011‐002520‐40‐IT Prematurely ended
Fomin 2016 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Gallet 2014 Study design (no RCT)
Gurcagan 2015 Study design (no RCT)
Hidalgo 2015a Study design (no RCT)
Hidalgo 2015b Study design (no RCT)
Hidalgo 2016a Study design (no RCT)
Hidalgo 2016b Study design (no RCT)
Hidalgo 2018 Study design (no RCT)
Iliuta 2014 Study design (no RCT)
Kanorsky 2016 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Kosheleva 2010 Type of participants (focus on congestive heart failure)
Lofrano‐Alves 2015 Study design (no RCT)
Lutay 2012 Type of participants (focus on myocardial infarction)
Mansour 2011 Type of participants (focus on cardiomyopathy, not heart failure alone)
Mert 2017 Study design (no RCT)
Nguyen 2017 Study design (no RCT)
Ozturk 2016 Study design (no RCT)
Pal 2015 Study design (cross‐over study with hypertensive volunteers)
Raja 2011 Type of participants (focus on myocardial infarction)
Raja 2018 Type of participants (focus on cardiomyopathy, not heart failure alone)
Rajagopal 2010 Study design (no RCT)
Reil 2012 Study design (no RCT)
Riccioni 2012 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Sallam 2016 Study design (no RCT)
Santos 2014 Study design (no RCT)
Sisakian 2014 Study design (no RCT) ("empirically allocated")
Tagliamonte 2016 Study design (no RCT)
Tregubov 2015 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Tumasyan 2009 Type of participants (focus on cardiomyopathy, not heart failure alone)
Vatinian 2015 Study design (no RCT)
Volterrani 2011 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Xu 2011 Type of intervention (comparator BB, not placebo or SC)
Yao 2014 Study design (no RCT)

BB = beta‐blocker, RCT = randomised controlled trial, SC = standard care