Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 6;2020(8):CD008227. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008227.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Ansaldi 1988 Cross‐over study with PERT for 5 days in each arm.
Araujo 2011 Doesn't appear to have a control group, PERT dosage increased according to fecal fat levels.
Beker 1994 Cross‐over study with PERT for 3 days in each arm.
Beverley 1987 Cross‐over study with 3 arms of 15 days each.
Borowitz 2011 The study drugs were given for a period of 6 days only after randomisation.
Bouquet 1988 Cross‐over study with each treatment period only 2 weeks.
Bowler 1993 Crossover study with 2 arms of 2 weeks each.
Brady 1991 Crossover study with 2 arms of 7 days each.
Brady 1992 Cross‐over study of enzymes given before and during meals; 2 periods of 1 week each.
Brady 2006 Cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 1 week each.
Breuel 1996 Study assesses pancreatic enzyme activity.
Butt 2001 Study assesses breath tests.
Chazalette 1988 Open label cross‐over study with periods of 1 week each.
Chazalette 1993 Parallel group study for a period of 8 days.
Colombo 2001 Study compares different methods for assessing exocrine pancreatic function.
Dalzell 1992 Meets inclusion criteria, but data not in usable format and will not be made available in the future
De Boeck 1998 Single dose intervention.
Desager 2006 Parallel study period of 10 days.
Duhamel 1988 Cross‐over study with 2 periods of 8 days each.
Duhamel 1998 Cross‐over study with 2 periods of 14 days each. Study assessed patient preference, but also assessed clinical symptoms.
Durie 1980 Cross‐over study with 4 preparations given for 1 week each.
Dutta 1988 Crossover study with each intervention given only on a single day.
Easley 1998 Cross‐over study with each intervention given only on a single day.
Eiel 2018 Intervention not relevant
Ellis 1994 Cross‐over study (assessing coating of PERT) with 2 weeks in each arm.
EUCTR 2007‐004004‐12 Participants not relevant (chronic pancreatitis & pancreatectomy)
EUCTR 2015‐001219‐11 Treatment period of 7 days
Foucaud 1989 Placebo‐controlled, parallel study but treatment period for 1 week.
Gan 1994 Cross‐over study with 2 arms of 14 days each.
Geyer 2019 Intervention not relevant
Goodchild 1974 Cross‐over study with 2 weeks in each arm.
Gow 1981 Cross‐over study of 4 periods of 14 days each.
Graff 2010 Intervention given for 5 days.
Heubi 2007 Cross‐over placebo‐controlled trial with 2 periods of 1 week each.
Heubi 2016 Cross‐over study with 1 week in each arm.
Hill 1993 Letter reports cross‐over trial to compare patient preference of different formulations; no other outcomes stated.
Hilman 1982 Cross‐over study with a total 2‐week study period.
Holsclaw 1979 Cross‐over study of 6 treatment (Viokase vs Cotazyme vs Pancrelipase with and without bicarbonate) periods of 3 weeks each.
Hubbard 1984 Study assesses use of bentiromide screening test.
Kalnins 2005 Cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 2 weeks each.
Kalnins 2006 Cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 14 days each.
Katona 2000 Not an RCT or a quasi‐RCT.
Khaw 1977 Cross‐over study with two treatment periods of 12 days each.
Konstan 2004 Intervention given only for 6 days.
Konstan 2008 Cross‐over trial with 2 treatment periods of 5 days each.
Konstan 2010 Treatment only 6 to 7 days in each arm of the 2‐phase cross‐over trial.
Kraisinger 1993 Cross‐over trial with 2 treatment periods of 4 days each.
Lancellotti 1996 Open‐label, cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 5 days each.
Lazaro 1990 Cross‐over trial with 2 periods of 6 days each.
Leitz 2009 Placebo‐controlled trial with a treatment period of 1 day.
Lubin 1979 Study assesses use of antacids in conjunction with PERT intervention not relevant.
Mack 1991 Cross‐over study assessing antibiotic absorption with PERT compared to without in a single intervention.
Mischler 1980 Cross‐over study with 2 arms of 5 days each.
Mischler 1982 Cross‐over trial 2 periods of 5 days each.
Morrison 1992 Not an RCT or quasi‐RCT.
Munck 2009 Cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 2 weeks each.
Munoz 1987 Cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 1 week each.
NCT00217204 Treatment period of 5 days.
NCT00449904 Not an RCT
NCT01327703 Cross‐over trial with treatment period of 14 days in each arm
NCT01652157 Not an RCT
NCT01851694 Intervention and outcomes not relevant.
NCT01858519 Not an RCT
NCT02137382 Cross‐over study with Creon/Creon N for 5 days in each arm.
NCT03746483 Cross‐over study with 3 weeks in each arm
Neijens 1982 Cross‐over study with treatment periods of 2 weeks each.
Perano 2014 Cross‐over trial with 2 single interventions on separate days.
Ritz 2004 Study evaluated a breath test used to assess fat malabsorption and not PERT.
Robinson 1989 Cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 2 weeks each.
Robinson 1998 Cross‐over study with 2 periods of 2 weeks each.
Santini 2000 Cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 1 week each.
Shah 1993 PERT taken for 2‐week period only.
Sinaasappel 1998 Cross‐over trial with 2 periods of 14 days each.
Stapleton 2001 Study assessing knowledge and education of PERT.
Stern 2000 Parallel RCT but duration only 5 ‐ 7 days.
Thomson 1993 Cross‐over trial with 3 periods of 7 days each.
Trapnell 2009 Cross‐over RCT with 5‐day course of PERT and same for placebo.
van der Haak 2016 Intervention not relevant.
Van de Vijver 2011 Treatment period only 5 days.
Vitti 1975 Study assesses antibiotic absorption when given with PERT.
Warwick 1982 Cross‐over study with 2 treatment periods of 1 week each.
Weber 1979 Cross‐over study with 2 periods of 8 days each.
Wooldridge 2009 Cross‐over study with 2 periods of 7 days each, followed by a non‐randomised extension study.
Zentler 1992 RCT with 3 interventions for 2 weeks each.

PERT: pancreatic enzyme replacement therapy
RCT: randomized controlled trial
vs: versus