7. Comparison 1 results: coverage of appropriate treatment by an appropriate provider.
Outcome | Trial ID | Study design | Preintervention coverage | Postintervention coverage | Risk ratio (95% CI) | ||
iCCM | Control | iCCM | Control | ||||
Coverage of appropriate treatment from an appropriate provider for any iCCM illness | Mubiru 2015 (diarrhoea) | CBA | 2.2% 3/136 |
5.8% 11/191 |
16.1% 30/186 |
1.6% 3/188 |
10.11 (3.14 to 32.55)a |
Mubiru 2015 (malaria) | CBA | 32.4% 77/238 |
49.2% 184/374 |
64.1% 236/368 |
67.7% 342/505 |
0.95 (0.86 to 1.04)a | |
Yansaneh 2014 (diarrhoea) | CBA | 31.6% 237/751 |
35.67% 237/664 |
52.2% 335/642 |
53.8% 394/733 |
0.97 (0.88 to 1.07)a | |
Yansaneh 2014 (malaria) | CBA | 29.8% 581/1948 |
30.9% 562/1819 |
29.2% 412/1413 |
38.2% 712/1863 |
0.76 (0.69 to 0.84)a | |
Coverage of appropriate treatment from an appropriate provider for diarrhoea | Mubiru 2015 | CBA | 2.2% 3/136 |
5.8% 11/191 |
16.1% 30/186 |
1.6% 3/188 |
10.11 (3.14 to 32.55)a |
Yansaneh 2014 | CBA | 31.6% 237/751 |
35.67% 237/664 |
52.2% 335/642 |
53.8% 394/733 |
0.97 (0.88 to 1.07)a | |
Coverage of appropriate treatment by an appropriate provider for malaria | Mubiru 2015 | CBA | 32.4% 77/238 |
49.2% 184/374 |
64.1% 236/368 |
67.7% 342/505 |
0.95 (0.86 to 1.04)a |
Yansaneh 2014 | CBA | 29.8% 581/1948 |
30.9% 562/1819 |
29.2% 412/1413 |
38.2% 712/1863 |
0.76 (0.69 to 0.84)a |
CBA: controlled before‐after study; CI: confidence intervals; iCCM: integrated community case management. aWe recalculated results for Mubiru 2015 and Yansaneh 2014 based on unadjusted counts (see Data extraction and management).