Cornu‐Thenard 1985.
Study characteristics | ||
Methods | Study design: randomised, multi‐centre, double‐blind, placebo‐controlled Method of randomisation: random distribution of numbered batches Exclusions post randomisation: not stated Losses to follow‐up: not stated |
|
Participants | Country: France Setting: not stated Number: 83 patients Age: 20 to 65 years; mean 43.73 ± 11.92 years active group; mean 43.55 ± 11.42 years placebo group Gender: 6 M:77 F Inclusion criteria: symptoms related to CVI Exclusion criteria: severe damage to venous musculature requiring urgent treatment ‐ surgery or sclerosis; surgical operation on venous or deep or superficial vein thrombosis in the past year; sclerosis or heavy support bandages (light support bandages not excluded), major trophic lesions, Raynaud's syndrome, arteritis, lymphoedema, renal or cardiac insufficiency; anti‐migraine treatment, analgesic or anti‐inflammatory treatment, diuretic treatment, low‐sodium diet, treatment for cardiovascular system (except nifedipine) |
|
Interventions | Treatment: extract Ruscus aculeatus 75 mg plus hesperidin 75 mg plus ascorbic acid 50 mg per day (Cyclo 3) Control: placebo Duration: 60 days Follow‐up: 60 days Light compression therapy allowed |
|
Outcomes | Primary
Secondary
|
|
Notes | ||
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | Quote: "A double‐blind comparative study against placebo, using two groups treated in parallel, after random distribution of numbered batches of the two treatments to be compared" Comment: seems like a fair method of randomisation was conducted |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Comment: no information given about methods used for allocation concealment |
Blinding (patients) | Low risk | Quote: "The two products to be compared were presented in the form of identical capsules for both Cyclo 3 and placebo" Comment: Identical placebo ensures a fair method used for double‐blinding |
Blinding (study researchers) | Low risk | Quote: "The two products to be compared were presented in the form of identical capsules for both Cyclo 3 and placebo" Comment: Identical placebo ensures a fair method used for double‐blinding |
Blinding (outcome assessment) | Low risk | Quote: "The two products to be compared were presented in the form of identical capsules for both Cyclo 3 and placebo" Comment: Identical placebo ensures a fair method used for double‐blinding |
Incomplete outcome data | Unclear risk | Quote: no information provided about participants who withdrew prematurely from the trial |
Selective reporting | Low risk | Comment: no published protocol identified, and no differences between outcomes reported in the methods section and those reported in the results section |
Other bias | Low risk | Comment: none detected |