Vanscheidt 2002a.
Study characteristics | ||
Methods | Study design: randomised, double‐blind, placebo‐controlled trial Method of randomisation: not stated Exclusions post randomisation: none Losses to follow‐up: 52/231 (22.5%) |
|
Participants | Country: Germany Setting: university Number: 231 patients Age: mean 55.1 (range 23 to 78) years Gender: 48 M:183 F Inclusion criteria: stages 3 to 5 of CEAP Exclusion criteria: surgical treatment of CVI; heart insufficiency; arterial occlusive disease; diabetes mellitus; neuropathy; acute thrombosis; lymphoedema; renal insufficiency or impaired liver function; malignant disease; pregnancy or breast feeding; major surgery; drugs with influence on the veins |
|
Interventions | Treatment: SB‐LOT (15 mg coumarin and 90 mg troxerutin) 2 tablets 3 × per day for 16 weeks Control: placebo Duration: 112 days Follow‐up: 112 days All participants received standard compression stockings during first 4 weeks |
|
Outcomes | Primary
Secondary
|
|
Notes | ||
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | Quote: "The randomisation schedule was generated by the validated PC programme RanCode plus, independently to all study participants. It was based on blocks of 4 patients. All medication was pre‐numbered and distributed to the centres" Comment: computer‐generated table of random numbers ensures a random sequence of participants |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Low risk | Quote: "Patients were included in the study by receiving the next consecutive random number. For each patient the study centres were supplied sealed envelopes with the treatment group information" Comment: sealed envelopes and allocation of participants by giving the next consecutive random number ensure fair allocation concealment |
Blinding (patients) | Low risk | Quote: "Placebo tablets matched the active tablets in taste, smell and appearance" Comment: Identical placebo ensures double‐blinding |
Blinding (study researchers) | Low risk | Quote: "Placebo tablets matched the active tablets in taste, smell and appearance" Comment: Identical placebo ensures double‐blinding |
Blinding (outcome assessment) | Low risk | Quote: "Placebo tablets matched the active tablets in taste, smell and appearance" Comment: Identical placebo ensures double‐blinding |
Incomplete outcome data | Low risk | Comment: number of participants in each group described, along with the most important characteristics and inclusion and exclusion criteria. In addition, study author stated the number of participants who withdrew from the study prematurely or were excluded after randomisation (22.5%). ITT analysis conducted |
Selective reporting | Low risk | Comment: no protocol identified, and no differences between outcomes reported in the methods section and those reported in the results section |
Other bias | Low risk | Comment: none detected |