Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 20;9:651811. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2021.651811

Table 3.

Suggested tabular presentation for ROBIS results.

Review Phase 2 Phase 3
1. Study eligibility criteria 2. Identification and selection of studies 3. Data collection and study appraisal 4. Synthesis and findings Risk of bias in the review
Jang et al. (18) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg ? graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg
Smith et al. (19) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg
Gu et al. (20) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg ? graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg
Xie et al. (21) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg
Zhang et al. (22) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg
Schwarze et al. (30) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg
Jo and Lee (23) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg
Yang et al. (24) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg
Qian et al. (25) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg
Shen et al. (26) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg
Manheimer et al. (31) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg
Qu et al. (32) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg
Zheng et al. (27) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg
Yu (28) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg
Manheimer et al. (29) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg
El-Toukhy et al. (33) graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fpubh-09-651811-i0001.jpg

Inline graphic, low risk; Inline graphic, high risk; ?, unclear risk.