Table 3.
Comparison of different testing options for COVID-19.
| DESCRIPTION | NUCLEIC ACID AMPLIFICATION TEST | ANTIGENT TEST | ANTIBODY TEST |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Type | Viral, molecular | Viral, immunoassay | Serologic, immunoassay |
| Purpose | Diagnostic | Diagnostic, screening | Screening |
| Intended Use | Detect current infection | Detect current infection | Detect prior or recent infection |
| Analyte Detected | Viral RNA | Viral structural proteins | Virus-specific antibodies |
| Sensitivity | Generally high | Moderate to high | Moderate to high |
| Specificity | High | High | High |
| Test Complexity | Differs by test | Relatively easy to use | Relatively easy to use |
| Turnaround Time | 15 min to > 2 d | 15 min to > 2 d | 15 min to > 2 d |
| Operating Temperature | Need thermal cycling—some are isothermal | Ambient | Ambient |
| Results Presentation | Quantitative or qualitative | Visual or instrument read | Visual or instrument read |
| Authorized for Point-of-careUse | Some tests | Most tests | Some tests |
| Authorized for Use at Home | Very few, sample collection is possible at home for many tests | Some tests | No |
| Suggested Test Time | 1 d after infection to 14 d from symptom onset | 5-7 d from symptom onset | ≥ 15 d from symptom onset |
| Cost per Test | Moderate (≈ $100-$200) | Low (≈ $5-$50) | Moderate (≈ $100-$200) |
| Authorized Specimen Type | Nasopharyngeal, oropharyngeal, nasal, sputum, saliva | Nasopharyngeal, nasal | Whole blood, serum, plasma, fingerstick blood |
| Transport Medium | Viral transport medium or saline—nothing needed for some tests | Extraction medium | Anticoagulant—nothing needed for fingerstick tests |
| Disadvantages | High requirements for operators and laboratory conditions. High cost, complexity, and turnaround time | Less sensitive in the early stage of disease | Lower sensitivity and specificity. Cross-reactivity. Long window period |