Table 6.
Causes of Regret
| Studies | Reasons of Regrets |
|---|---|
| Blanchard et al, 1989 | • 1 patient was dissatisfied with life as a woman and considered returning to the masculine role |
| • 1 patient reported that surgery failed to produce the coherence of mind and the body he wanted | |
| • 1 patient would not opt for a new surgery as it had not accomplished what she wanted | |
| • 1 patient dressed as a man but didn’t felt as feminine nor masculine | |
| Bouman, 1988 | Work and social acceptance |
| De Cuypere et al, 2006 | • Transmasculine = Physiologic period before GAS (delusional disorder-erotomaniac type), scored very low in credibility |
| • Transfemenine = Emotionally troubled by a break-up with his girlfriend | |
| Imbimbo et al, 2009 | NS |
| Jiang et al, 2018 | Didn’t want to wait genital electrolysis prior vaginoplasty |
| Kuiper et al, 1998 | • 4 patients mentioned they were not transsexual |
| • 1 patient after surgery she realized she did not want to live as a woman. 1 never wished for the surgery (forced by the partner) | |
| • 2 patients lost the partner and had social problems | |
| • 1 patient had no doubts (double role requested by the partner) | |
| Lawrence, 2003 | • 8 patients felt disappointed with physical or functional outcomes of surgery (lost clitoris sensation) |
| • 2 participants reported reversion to living as a man after GAS. There were family and social problems | |
| Olson-Kennedy et al, 2018 | NS |
| Pfafflin, 1993 | NS |
| Van de Grift et al, 2018 | • Transmasculine = Body does not meet the feminine ideal |
| • Transfemenine = Recurrent abdominal pains, dependence on exogenous hormones | |
| Wiepjes et al, 2018 | • 5 patients had social regret (still as their former role/“ignored by surroundings” or “the loss of relatives is a large sacrifice”) |
| • 7 patients had true regret (though that the surgery was the solution) | |
| • 2 patients felt non-binary | |
| Zavlin et al, 2018 | NS |
| Judge et al, 2014 | NS |
| Weyers et al, 2009 | NS |
| Poudrier et al, 2019 | Aesthetic outcomes |
| Laden et al, 1998 | NS |
NS, not specified.