Skip to main content
. 2021 May 5;157(6):727–729. doi: 10.1001/jamadermatol.2021.1098

Table. Frequency and Source of Discrepancies in Tumor Stage Among Primary Cutaneous Melanomas Within SEER Registries, 2004-2017.

Years of diagnosis No. of discrepancies for each supplementary staging variable Total discrepancies by resulting stage changea
Breslow depth (SSF1)b Ulceration status (SSF2)b Presence of mitoses (SSF7)b Regional nodes positivec Clinical lymph node status (SSF3)c Other distant metastasisd SEER combined summary stage 2000e Not stage changing Stage increase Stage decrease
Introduction of AJCC 6th edition staging to SEER
2004 0 0 NA 20 4 0 129 13 118 22
2005 2 0 NA 12 7 0 107 12 101 15
2006 2 0 NA 12 8 0 111 12 110 11
2007 3 0 NA 15 6 0 106 9 105 16
2008 0 0 NA 25 13 0 111 16 109 24
2009 7 0 NA 25 22 0 115 30 109 30
Introduction of AJCC 7th edition staging to SEER
2010 29 356 355 20 28 0 118 23 121 762
2011 108 262 261 35 39 0 133 25 156 657
2012 134 217 217 60 91 0 243 51 304 607
2013 175 203 209 58 104 0 218 70 287 610
2014 131 170 175 61 113 0 240 103 282 505
2015 129 151 152 88 119 0 224 99 265 499
Introduction of UICC 7th edition staging to SEER
2016 0 105 713 72 38 3 202 0 811 322
2017 0 62 532 70 58 3 163 0 655 233
Totals 720 1526 2614 573 650 6 2220 463 3533 4313

Abbreviations: AJCC, American Joint Committee on Cancer; NA, not applicable; SEER, Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Program; SSF, site-specific factor; UICC, Union for International Cancer Control.

a

Stage-changing discrepancies are those that result in an increase or decrease to the tumor stage listed (eg, stage IIIB T4aN1bM0 tumor with site-specific factor 3 coded as “nodes negative on pathologic examination” would imply decrease to stage II).

b

Mismatch with T (tumor) component of TNM cancer staging system.

c

Mismatch with N (node) component of TNM cancer staging system.

d

Mismatch with M (metastasis) component of TNM cancer staging system.

e

The SEER Combined Summary Stage 2000 variable allowed for comparison of all 3 TNM components because it incorporates distant nodes/sites involved, regional by nodes involved, regional by extension only, regional by nodes involved and extension, regional not otherwise specified, and localized only.