Trials of other interventions |
Study |
Interventions |
Results |
Outcomes |
Aldara 3M 2000a |
Topical 5% imiquimod cream (different vehicles) vs placebo for plantar warts |
ITT: no significant difference in clearance of warts between Aldara cream any delivery methods or vehicle control |
Cure in 10.0% to 12.8% in active treatment groups; 2.9% in vehicle control group |
Aldara 3M 2000b |
Topical 5% imiquimod cream (different vehicles) vs placebo for common warts |
ITT: no significant difference in clearance of warts between Aldara cream any delivery methods or vehicle control |
Cure in 9.5% vs 10.0% |
Faghihi 2010 |
Inoculation of 85% formic acid vs distilled water |
Formic acid more effective |
Cure in 91.3% vs 10.7% |
Gustafsson 2004 |
Alpha‐lactalbumin‐oleic acid (ALOA) vs saline |
'ALOA has beneficial and lasting effect' |
9/20 (45%) vs 3/20 (15%) with at least 1 wart resolved |
Huo 2010 |
Hyperthermia from infrared device vs placebo |
Hyperthermia more effective |
Cure in 15/30 (50%) vs 3/30 (10%) |
Khan 1999 |
Topical Thuja vs placebo |
Efficacy of Thuja demonstrated |
12/15 (80%) vs 5/15 (33%) showed resolution |
Khan 2000 |
Hexane vs chloroform vs ethyl acetate fractions of Thuja |
Chloroform fraction superior |
0/10 vs 10/10 vs 4/10 cases, respectively |
Nofal 2010 |
Intralesional MMR vs intralesional saline |
MMR more effective than saline |
Cure in 57/85 (67%) vs 11/50 (22%) |
Togsverd‐Bo 2010 |
Paring and intense pulsed light (IPL) vs paring alone |
No significant difference between the 2 treatments |
Cure in 9/45 (20%) vs 5/44 (11%) |
Wang 2002 |
Chinese herbal medicine + 0.1% retinoic acid vs retinoic acid alone |
Chinese herbal medicine + retinoic has a relatively good efficacy |
Cure in 57/70 (81%) vs 29/56 (52%) |
Wu 2005 |
Qu You Ding vs peptide butylamine liniment |
Qu You Ding has a higher cure rate than Peptide butylamine liniment |
Cure in 21/30 (70%) vs 17/30 (57%). In the Qu You Ding group, there were 2 cases of erythema, which cleared at 4 days |
Yazar 1994 |
Silver nitrate vs placebo |
Silver nitrate has a higher cure rate than placebo |
Cure in 15/35 (43%) vs 4/35 (11%) |
Zhang 1999 |
Chinese herbal medicine decoction vs electrocautery knife |
Chinese herbal medicine was more effective than cautery |
Recovery in 58/89 (65%) vs 7/18 (39%) |