Table 2.
Group | Sex | Site§ | |||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(dependent CB vs recreational CB) | (dependent CB vs HC) | (recreational CB vs HC) | (Males vs Females) | Group-by-Sex | |||||||||||||
β | (95% CI) | p | β | (95% CI) | p | β | (95% CI) | p | β | 95% CI | p | β (95% CI) | (95% CI) | p | Var | ||
Brain volumes (mm3) | |||||||||||||||||
Amygdala | L | 16.37 | −115.85, 148.70 | 0.808 | −197.83 | −244.61, 48.95 | 0.191 | −114.20 | −245.18, 16.77 | 0.087 | 99.66 | 4.72, 194.60 | 0.040* | −38.36 | −174.89, 98.16 | 0.582 | 0.58 |
R | −25.05 | −150.76, 100.66 | 0.696 | 13.76 | −125.67, 153.20 | 0.847 | 38.82 | −85.61, 163.24 | 0.541 | 172.80 | 83.40, 262.20 | <001*** | −58.37 | −188.06, 71.32 | 0.378 | 0.58 | |
Hippocampus | L | 453.77 | −221.38, 328.91 | 0.702 | −31.70 | −337.34, 273.94 | 0.839 | −85.47 | −356.62, 185.69 | 0.537 | 53.82 | −135.67, 243.30 | 0.578 | −11.52 | −295.88, 272.86 | 0.937 | 0.03 |
R | −133.11 | −386.45, 120.22 | 0.303 | −63.80 | −345.06, 217.47 | 0.657 | 69.15 | −180.80, 319.43 | 0.587 | 118.58 | −58.27, 295.44 | 0.189 | 0.15 | −261.81, 261.49 | 0.999 | 0.06 | |
NAcc | L | −74.85 | −149.74, 0.04 | 0.051 | −41.69 | −124.76, 41.37 | 0.325 | 33.15 | −40.97, 107.29 | 0.236 | 35.57 | −17.88, 89.03 | 0.192 | 13.75 | −63.51, 91.01 | 0.727 | 0.65 |
R | −51.93 | −113.33, 9.47 | 0.097 | −18.71 | −86.83, 49.39 | 0.590 | 33.21 | −27.58, −94.00 | 0.284 | 21.85 | −21.95, 65.65 | 0.328 | −14.87 | −78.22, 48.47 | 0.380 | 0.88 | |
Insula | L | −290.49 | −688.94, 107.96 | 0.153 | −169.37 | −611.45, 272.70 | 0.453 | 121.12 | −273.01, 515.24 | 0.547 | 90.08 | −192.79, 372.96 | 0.533 | 172.93 | −238.28, 584.13 | 0.410 | 0.21 |
R | −204.12 | −60.63, 195.39 | 0.317 | −313.38 | −756.88, 130.13 | 0.166 | −109.25 | −341.65, 218.83 | 0.587 | −64.29 | −343.62, 215.03 | 0.652 | 318.70 | −93.88, 731.29 | 0.130 | 0.07 | |
OFC | |||||||||||||||||
lateral | L | −429.13 | −900.90, −42.62 | 0.075 | −201.77 | −725.12, 321.57 | 0.450 | 227.36 | −725.12, 321.57 | 0.340 | 173.94 | −161.72, 509.60 | 0.310 | 462.21 | −24.58, 949.01 | 0.063 | 0.32 |
R | −564.93 | −1058.51, −71.35 | 0.025*a | −702.11 | −1249.80, −153.41 | 0.012*b | −137.17 | −625.22, 350.87 | 0.582 | −3.27 | −351.64, 345.11 | 0.985 | 575.33 | 65.87, 1084.78 | 0.027*c | 0.15 | |
medial | L | −201.33 | −549.49, 146.84 | 0.257 | −182.06 | −568.43, 204.31 | 0.356 | 19.26 | −324.91, 363.44 | 0.913 | 23.27 | −222.03, 268.57 | 0.853 | 127.42 | −231.99, 486.82 | 0.487 | 0.13 |
R | −215.47 | −561.45, 130.51 | 0.222 | −278.42 | −662.29, −105.44 | 0.155 | −62.95 | −405.18, 279.28 | 0.496 | 76.62 | −171.78, 319.02 | 0.557 | 184.60 | −172.46, 541.65 | 0.311 | 0.21 | |
ACC | |||||||||||||||||
rostral | L | −233.80 | −543.58, 75.98 | 0.139 | −203.63 | −492.21, 84.95 | 0.167 | 30.16 | −247.86, 308.19 | 0.832 | 4.84 | −218.22, 227.89 | 0.966 | −78.23 | −403.14, 246.68 | 0.637 | 0.25 |
R | −89.39 | −371.23, 192.45 | 0.547 | −126.39 | −389.15, 136.36 | 0.346 | −37.01 | −290.17, 216.15 | 0.774 | 47.72 | −153.80, 249.25 | 0.643 | −43.38 | −339.29, 252.53 | 0.774 | 0.10 | |
caudal | L | −208.86 | −508.63, 90.91 | 0.172 | −274.13 | −555.09, 6.83 | 0.056 | −65.27 | −336.19, 205.65 | 0.637 | −265.70 | −469.06, −62.357 | 0.010* | 224.09 | −93.02, 541.19 | 0.166 | 0.00 |
R | −5.77 | −343.00, 331.46 | 0.973 | −55.018 | −369.24, 259.21 | 0.731 | −49.25 | −351.98, 253.49 | 0.750 | 172.43 | −69.87, 414.73 | 0.163 | −158.59 | −512.40, 195.23 | 0.380 | 0.18 | |
medial | L | −201.33 | −549.49, 146.84 | 0.257 | −182.06 | −568.43, 204.31 | 0.356 | 19.26 | −324.91, 363.44 | 0.913 | 23.27 | −222.03, 268.57 | 0.853 | 127.42 | −231.99, 486.82 | 0.487 | 0.13 |
R | −215.47 | −561.45, 130.51 | 0.222 | −278.42 | −662.29, −105.44 | 0.155 | −62.95 | −405.18, 279.28 | 0.496 | 73.62 | −171.78, 319.02 | 0.557 | 184.60 | −172.46, 541.65 | 0.311 | 0.21 | |
Cerebellum | |||||||||||||||||
GM | L | −738.06 | −3934.90, 2458.37 | 0.651 | −2.26 | −3534.43, 3547.96 | 0.999 | 740.32 | −2423.29, 3903.93 | 0.646 | 3461.28 | 1189.26, 5733.30 | 0.003** | 1676.65 | −1621.32, 4974.63 | 0.319 | 0.47 |
R | −1216.89 | −4765.03, 2331.20 | 0.501 | −261.34 | −3674.48, 4197.17 | 0.896 | 1478.23 | −2033.54, 4990.01 | 0.409 | 3110.34 | 584.19, 5636.49 | 0.016* | 2009.77 | −1651.08, 5670.61 | 0.282 | 0.48 | |
WM | L | −1141.32 | −2285.33, −2.70 | 0.051 | −1193.07 | −2462.19, 76.06 | 0.065 | −51.74 | −1183.74, 1080.25 | 0.929 | −377.17 | −1188.80 434.47 | 0.362 | 1507.86 | 327.38, 2688.33 | 0.012*d | 0.32 |
R | −1269.72 | −2495.49, −43.93 | 0.042*e | −1564.76 | −2924.55, −204.97 | 0.024*f | −295.05 | −1508.04, 917.95 | 0.634 | −136.99 | −1007.92, 733.94 | 0.758 | 1786.54 | 521.74, 3051.34 | 0.006**g | 0.36 |
ACC anterior cingulate cortex; β beta, CB cannabis users, CI confidence interval, GM grey matter, L left, HC controls, OFC orbitofrontal cortex, R right, Var variation, WM white matter. §Site level variation based on intraclass correlation (ICC).
*p(unc) <0.05, **p(unc) <0.01, ***p(unc) <0.001.
ad = −0.10.
bd = −0.17.
cFemale dependent CB < female recreational CB (β = −564.93, p = .025, d = −0.52), female HC (β = −702.11, p = .012, d = −0.55), male dependent CB (β = −574.76, p = .010, d = −0.41), male recreational CB (β = −527.65, p = .022, d = −0.45) and male HC (β = 701.54, p = .010, d = −0.43).
dFemale dependent CB < male dependent CB (β = −1136.554, p = .028, d = −0.26) and male recreational CB (β = −1652.85, p = .002, d = −0.45);
ed = −12.
fd = −0.09;
gFemale dependent CB < female recreational CB (β = −1269.72, p = 0.042, d = −0.36), female HC (β = −1564.76, p = 0.024, d = −0.34), male dependent CB (β = −1620.06, p = 0.004, d = −0.32), male recreational CB (β = −2029.51, p < 0.001, d = −0.48) and male HC (β = −1398.28, p = 0.039, d = −0.23).