Table 1.
Author (Year) | Country | Study Type | Healthcare Setting | Subjects and Samples (n); HCW Categories Sampled |
---|---|---|---|---|
Horikawa, 2001 [20] | Japan | Cross-sectional | Hospital | 50 nurses |
150 samples | ||||
Perry, 2001 [26] | UK | Cross-sectional | Hospital wards: Renal Medicine, Renal Transplantation, Vascular Surgery, General Medicine and Obstetrics | 57 nurses |
112 samples (56 pre-duty and 56 post-duty) | ||||
Osawa, 2003 [21] | Japan | Observational | Four hospital wards on two separate occasions (April 1998 and March 1999) |
|
| ||||
Ditchburn, 2006 [27] | Scotland | Cross-sectional | Hospital | 40 physicians |
Koh, 2009 [22] | Malaysia | Cross-sectional | Group 1 (physicians); hospitals | 100 participants |
Group 2 (students); university | Physicians (50) and medical students (50) | |||
Gaspard, 2009 [28] | France | Cross-sectional descriptive | Three geriatric long-term care facilities | 512 total samples (256 samples (90 from nurses and 166 from care assistants) per zone) |
Treakle, 2009 [8] | USA | Cross-sectional | Tertiary care hospital | 148 participants |
38 students, 64 residents, 12 fellows and 31 attending physicians | ||||
McGovern, 2010 [9] | Ireland | Cross-sectional | Hospital | 95 physicians |
Uneke, 2010 [30] | Nigeria | Cross-sectional | University teaching hospital | 103 physicians |
Burden, 2011 [9] | USA | Prospective randomized controlled | University hospital | 100 participants |
Group 1 (white coats) (n = 50) | ||||
Group 2 (short-sleeved uniforms) (n = 50) | ||||
Wiener–Well, 2011 [23] | Israel | Cross-sectional | University hospital | 135 participants |
238 samples | ||||
75 nurses and 60 physicians | ||||
Banu, 2012 [24] | India | Cross-sectional | Tertiary medical hospital | 100 participants |
83 students, 10 interns, 7 postgraduates | ||||
Bearman, 2012 [10] | USA | Prospective cross-over | ICU | Thirty-one HCWs were sampled weekly. |
Two thousand samples: 1019 study scrubs and 981 antimicrobial-impregnated scrubs (controls) | ||||
Morgan, 2012 [11] | USA | Prospective cohort | Six ICUs in a tertiary hospital | Sampling of hands and gowns reported as 585 HCW–patient interactions |
HCWs: nurses, therapists/physicians | ||||
Munoz–Price, 2012 [12] | USA | Cross-sectional | 5 ICUs in a hospital | Total: 119 |
White coats: 22 | ||||
Scrubs: 97 | ||||
Roghmann, 2015 [3] | USA | Observational | 13 community nursing homes | 954 patient interactions |
Williams, 2015 [14] | USA | Cross-sectional | 5 ICUs | 348 HCWs (252 nurses): 179 universal gowning/gloving and 169 usual care apparel |
Anderson, 2017 [15] | USA | Randomized control | Medical and surgical ICUs of a tertiary care hospital | 40 nurses |
2185 samples from clothing (120 shifts) | ||||
Control group: standard cotton–polyester scrubs | ||||
Scrub 1: scrubs with silver alloy embedded in fibers | ||||
Scrub 2: scrubs with organosilane-based quaternary ammonium and hydrophobic fluoroacrylate copolymer emulsion | ||||
Pineles, 2017 [16] | USA | Multisite prospective observational | 7 nursing homes | Interactions with MRSA-positive patients (n = 1543) |
Interactions with MRSA-negative patients (n = 1462) | ||||
Abu Radwan, 2019 [25] | Jordan | Cross-sectional | ICU—large military hospital | 115 participants |
305 samples | ||||
Nurses (58), physicians (20), resp. therapists (14), students (17), housekeepers (6) | ||||
Batista, 2019 [17] | Brazil | Cross-sectional | Hospital laboratories | 100 college students |
300 samples | ||||
Jackson, 2019 [18] | USA | Cross-sectional | 13 nursing home | Developmental set: 2200 interactions |
residents’ cohorts | ||||
|
Validation set: 3011 interactions | |||
| ||||
Kanwar, 2019 [19] | USA | Cross-sectional | Acute care hospital | 41 HCWs: |
25 (61%) nurses | ||||
16 (39%) physicians |
HCW: healthcare worker; ICU: intensive care unit; MRSA: methicillin-resistant S. aureus.