Skip to main content
. 2021 May 7;2021(5):CD010876. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010876.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Amat Santos 2012 Patient population not appropriate. Conference paper
Bakhshayesh 2018 Population
Batra 2012 Not a randomised trial
Brosseau 1995 Patient population not appropriate
Cargnin 2019 Inappropriate intervention
Chambers 2005 Letter to the Editor; not a randomised trial
Chan 2012 Not a randomised trial (systematic review of effectiveness of qigong in cardiac rehabilitation)
CTRI 2017 Inappropriate Intervention
de Charmoy 2000 Intervention not appropriate (chest physiotherapy)
Deepa 2018 Not an RCT
Dull 1983 Patient population not appropriate
Editorial 2018 Editorial to paper that compares CR referral and outcomes in TAVR vs SAVR patients
Fang 2002 Inappropriate intervention (rehabilitation guidance at 24 hours after surgery and QoL measure) and unclear patient population (including both patients with rheumatic heart disease and patients after valve replacement)
Ferreira 2009 Intervention not appropriate (inspiratory breathing exercises)
Fontes Cerqueira 2018 Inappropriate intervention
Gaita 1999 Patient population not appropriate (randomisation method and study population unclear)
Ghalamghash 2008 Not a randomised trial
Gortner 1988 Intervention not appropriate (nursing intervention, no physical exercise)
Green 2013 Not a randomised trial
Grunewald 1971 Not a randomised trial
Ha 2011 Not a randomised trial. Not possible to obtain full paper
Hokanson 2011 Letter to the Editor; not a randomised trial
Hui 2006 Patient population not appropriate
Jairath 1995 Not a randomised trial (non‐randomised cluster trial)
Johnson 1996 Intervention not appropriate (physical intervention in control group)
Kardis 2007 Not a randomised trial (a randomised case control study)
Kassirskii 1983 Not a randomised trial (an observational study)
Kassirskii 1991 Not a randomised trial
Kodric 2013 Patient population not appropriate (patients after all kinds of major cardiac surgery)
Kübler 1984 Patient population not appropriate
Liao 2004 Intervention not eligible (no physical intervention, only psychological and behavioural interventions)
Lim 1998 Patient population not appropriate
Martsinkiavichus 1980 Not a randomised trial
McDermott 2019 Inappropriate intervention
Nagashio 2003 Patient population not appropriate
Nehyba 2009 Not a randomised trial (a non‐randomised cluster trial); patient population including patients with coronary artery bypass surgery
Newell 1980 Not a randomised trial (a non‐randomised cluster trial)
Patel 2019 Investigators were looking into the rate of CR enrolment in the studied population
Peng 2018 Inappropriate population
Petrunina 1980 Not a randomised trial
Prasciene 2019 Inappropriate intervention
Pressler 2015 Conference abstract for included study
RBR‐8swgc3 2017 Inappropriate intervention
Rizwan 2012 Not a randomised trial
Rogers2018 Conference abstract for included study
Roseler 1997 Not a randomised trial and inappropriate patient population
Rosenfeldt 2011 Patient population not appropriate (patients with valve surgery and coronary artery bypass graft surgery)
Royse 2015 Inappropriate intervention
Song 2019 Non‐RCT
Stoickov 2018 Outcomes
Sumide 2009 Not a randomised trial
Tang 2019 The only RCT of interest in this study is the one that has been updated
Therrien 2003 Patient population not appropriate (repaired tetralogy of Fallot)
Ueshima 2004 Not a randomised trial
Viana 2018 Not an RCT
Weber 2019 Inappropriate intervention
Widimsky 2009 Patient population not appropriate (patients with acute myocardial infarction)
Yan 2016 Not an RCT
Yau 2018 Inappropriate intervention

CR: cardiac rehabilitation.
QoL: quality of life.
RCT: randomised controlled trial.
SAVR: surgical aortic valve replacement.
TAVR: transcatheter aortic valve replacement.