Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Amat Santos 2012 | Patient population not appropriate. Conference paper |
Bakhshayesh 2018 | Population |
Batra 2012 | Not a randomised trial |
Brosseau 1995 | Patient population not appropriate |
Cargnin 2019 | Inappropriate intervention |
Chambers 2005 | Letter to the Editor; not a randomised trial |
Chan 2012 | Not a randomised trial (systematic review of effectiveness of qigong in cardiac rehabilitation) |
CTRI 2017 | Inappropriate Intervention |
de Charmoy 2000 | Intervention not appropriate (chest physiotherapy) |
Deepa 2018 | Not an RCT |
Dull 1983 | Patient population not appropriate |
Editorial 2018 | Editorial to paper that compares CR referral and outcomes in TAVR vs SAVR patients |
Fang 2002 | Inappropriate intervention (rehabilitation guidance at 24 hours after surgery and QoL measure) and unclear patient population (including both patients with rheumatic heart disease and patients after valve replacement) |
Ferreira 2009 | Intervention not appropriate (inspiratory breathing exercises) |
Fontes Cerqueira 2018 | Inappropriate intervention |
Gaita 1999 | Patient population not appropriate (randomisation method and study population unclear) |
Ghalamghash 2008 | Not a randomised trial |
Gortner 1988 | Intervention not appropriate (nursing intervention, no physical exercise) |
Green 2013 | Not a randomised trial |
Grunewald 1971 | Not a randomised trial |
Ha 2011 | Not a randomised trial. Not possible to obtain full paper |
Hokanson 2011 | Letter to the Editor; not a randomised trial |
Hui 2006 | Patient population not appropriate |
Jairath 1995 | Not a randomised trial (non‐randomised cluster trial) |
Johnson 1996 | Intervention not appropriate (physical intervention in control group) |
Kardis 2007 | Not a randomised trial (a randomised case control study) |
Kassirskii 1983 | Not a randomised trial (an observational study) |
Kassirskii 1991 | Not a randomised trial |
Kodric 2013 | Patient population not appropriate (patients after all kinds of major cardiac surgery) |
Kübler 1984 | Patient population not appropriate |
Liao 2004 | Intervention not eligible (no physical intervention, only psychological and behavioural interventions) |
Lim 1998 | Patient population not appropriate |
Martsinkiavichus 1980 | Not a randomised trial |
McDermott 2019 | Inappropriate intervention |
Nagashio 2003 | Patient population not appropriate |
Nehyba 2009 | Not a randomised trial (a non‐randomised cluster trial); patient population including patients with coronary artery bypass surgery |
Newell 1980 | Not a randomised trial (a non‐randomised cluster trial) |
Patel 2019 | Investigators were looking into the rate of CR enrolment in the studied population |
Peng 2018 | Inappropriate population |
Petrunina 1980 | Not a randomised trial |
Prasciene 2019 | Inappropriate intervention |
Pressler 2015 | Conference abstract for included study |
RBR‐8swgc3 2017 | Inappropriate intervention |
Rizwan 2012 | Not a randomised trial |
Rogers2018 | Conference abstract for included study |
Roseler 1997 | Not a randomised trial and inappropriate patient population |
Rosenfeldt 2011 | Patient population not appropriate (patients with valve surgery and coronary artery bypass graft surgery) |
Royse 2015 | Inappropriate intervention |
Song 2019 | Non‐RCT |
Stoickov 2018 | Outcomes |
Sumide 2009 | Not a randomised trial |
Tang 2019 | The only RCT of interest in this study is the one that has been updated |
Therrien 2003 | Patient population not appropriate (repaired tetralogy of Fallot) |
Ueshima 2004 | Not a randomised trial |
Viana 2018 | Not an RCT |
Weber 2019 | Inappropriate intervention |
Widimsky 2009 | Patient population not appropriate (patients with acute myocardial infarction) |
Yan 2016 | Not an RCT |
Yau 2018 | Inappropriate intervention |
CR: cardiac rehabilitation. QoL: quality of life. RCT: randomised controlled trial. SAVR: surgical aortic valve replacement. TAVR: transcatheter aortic valve replacement.