Skip to main content
. 2021 May 7;21:431. doi: 10.1186/s12879-021-06072-0

Table 2.

Summary of characteristics of included studies

ID Name of intervention Design Participant characteristics Sample size Participants on ART? Perinatal or sexual transmission Country & Setting Outcomes
Belzer et al. (2014); Sayegh et al. (2018) [40, 41] Cell Phone Support RCTa – parallel group

Age 15–24

History of non-adherence (< 90%)

62.2% Male

70.27% Non-Hispanic/ Black/African American

n = 37

Intervention = 19

Control (usual care) = 18

Yes Both - 54% behaviourally infected and 46% perinatally infected

USA

High income

Urban

Community/home

Confidence - self-efficacy for adherence

Adherence

Self-care abilities - substance use

Viral suppression

Mental health - depression

Emotional health - stress

Psychological health - problem solving / distraction

Healthcare utilisation

Bhana et al. 2014) [42] Vuka Family Programme RCT – parallel group

Age 10–14

Child and caregiver

51% Female

Black South Africans, Zulu

Receiving childcare grant: n = 45 (82%)

n = 65

Intervention = 33

Control (wait list) = 32

Yes Perinatal

South Africa

Middle-income

Urban

Health facility

Knowledge - HIV treatment knowledge

Confidence - self-identity, self-satisfaction, self-esteem

Social support - youth and caregiver communication and comfort

Adherence

Mental health - strengths and difficulties, child depression

Dow et al. (2018, 2020) [43, 44]

Mental Health Intervention

Sauti ya Vijana

(SYV; The Voice of Youth)

RCT – parallel group

Age 12–24

50.5% Female

n = 93

Intervention = 55

Control (usual care) = 38

Yes Both (84% perinatal)

Tanzania

Low-income

Urban

Health facility

Internal stigmab

Adherence

Viral suppression

Mental health - strengths and difficulties, post traumatic stress, depression

Donenberg et al. (2019); Fabri et al. (2015) [45, 46] Peer-led TI-CBT RCT – parallel group Age 14–21

n = 356

Intervention = 178

Control (other intervention with no SM components) = 178

Yes Unclear

Rwanda

Low income

Urban

Health facility

Adherence

Health/risk behaviour - sexual behaviour and drug use

Healthcare utilisation

Holden et al. (2019) [47] Stepping Stones Non-RCT (Historical controls)

Age 5–14

Limited ART adherence/school attendance

53.7% > 10 years

52% Female

n = 177

Intervention = 86

Control (usual care) = 91

Yes Unclear sexual, mostly perinatal

Tanzania

Low income

Urban

Community

Adherence

CD4

Hosek et al. (2018) [48] ACCEPT (Adolescents Coping, Connecting, Empowering, and Protecting Together) RCT – parallel group

Age 16–24

Diagnosed with HIV for less than 15 months

68% Gay/lesbian

80.6% Male

51.5% Currently in school

83.5% African American

n = 103

Intervention = 57

Control (other intervention with SM components) = 46

Unclear (71.8% taking ART) Sexual

USA

High income

Urban

Heath facility

Stigmac

Social support

Networks and communication - engagement with healthcare provider

Adherence

Viral suppression

CD4

Health-related quality of life

Mental Health - psychological distress

Healthcare utilisation

Jeffries et al. (2016) [49] UCare4Life RCT – parallel group

Age 15–24

Own a phone with text-messaging capability

85% Age 21–24

86% Male

76% Black or African American

68% Diagnosed less than 3 years ago

n = 136

Intervention = 91

Control (usual care) = 45

Unclear Unclear

USA

High income

Urban

Home/ICT

Adherence

Self-care abilities - binge drinking

Viral suppression

Letourneau et al. (2013) [50] Multisystemic therapy Non-RCT – parallel group

Age 9–17

Poor adherence/risky behaviour

65% Female

91% African American

n = 34

Intervention = 20

Control (other intervention with SM components) = 14

Yes Perinatal (33/34)

USA

High income

Urban

Community/ICT

Adherence

Viral suppression

CD4

Mimiaga et al. (2019) [51] Positive STEPS RCT – parallel group

Age 16–24

Self-report adherence difficulty

n = 14

Intervention =7

Control (usual care) = 7

Yes Sexual (82% behaviourally infected)

USA

High income

Urban

Community/ICT/ Health Facility

Confidence - adherence readiness, medication taking, self-efficacy

Social support

Interpersonal skills

Adherence

Naar-King et al. (2006) [52] Healthy Choices RCT – parallel group

Age 16–25

51% Male

88% African American

58% Heterosexual

n = 62

Intervention = 31

Control (wait list) = 33

Unclear – 1/3 on ART Sexual (91%)

USA

High income

Urban

Health facility

Health/risk behaviour - sexual risk behaviour

Self-care abilities - illicit drug and alcohol use

Viral suppression

Naar-King et al. (2009) [53] Healthy Choices RCT – parallel group

Age 16–24

At least 1 of 3 HIV risk behaviours

56.6% Heterosexual

52.7% Male

83.3% African American

n = 186

Intervention =94

Control (usual care) = 92

Unclear – 34.4% on ART at baseline Unclear

USA

High income

Urban

Health facility

Viral suppression
Rongkavilit et al. (2014) [54] Healthy Choices RCT – parallel group

Age 16–25

Mean age 21.7

80% Male

41.8% HIV diagnoses in last 6 months

n = 110

Intervention = 55

Control (other intervention with no SM components) = 55

Unclear – 45.5% diagnosed in past 6 months Yes, 70% MSM

Thailand

Middle income

Urban

Health facility

Confidence - self-efficacy for health promotion and risk reduction

Adherence

Health/risk behaviour - Consistent condom use

Self-care abilities - alcohol and substance use

Viral suppression

Mental health

Emotional health - anxiety

Webb et al. (2017) [55] Mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) RCT – parallel group

Age 14–22

CD4 count > 200

Mean age 18.7

32.2% Female

n = 93

Intervention = 48

Control (Other intervention with no SM components) = 45

Unclear Unclear

USA

High income

Urban

Health facility

Mindfulnessd

Adherence

Viral suppression

CD4 s

Health-related quality of life

Mental health - coping Emotional health - perceived stress

Psychological health – problem solving / distraction

Whiteley et al. (2018) [56] iPhone game (BattleViro) RCT – parallel group

14–26

Detectable viral load

74% Non-heterosexual

Mean age 22.4

78.7% Male

96.7% Black, African American or Haitian

n = 61

Intervention = 32

Control (other intervention with no SM components) = 29

Yes Sexual

USA

High income

Urban

Community/ICT/Home

Knowledge - HIV treatment, ART knowledge

Confidence - motivation, self-efficacy

Social support

Adherence

Health / risk behaviour - Sexual risk behaviour

Viral suppression

Mental health - psychological distress

Key: HCW Healthcare worker, ICT Information Communications Technology

aRCT randomised controlled trial

bNot an outcome of this review, but included for completeness

cNot an outcome of this review, but included for completeness

dMindfulness not an outcome of this review, but included for completeness under Confidence