Table 2.
Summary of characteristics of included studies
ID | Name of intervention | Design | Participant characteristics | Sample size | Participants on ART? | Perinatal or sexual transmission | Country & Setting | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Belzer et al. (2014); Sayegh et al. (2018) [40, 41] | Cell Phone Support | RCTa – parallel group |
Age 15–24 History of non-adherence (< 90%) 62.2% Male 70.27% Non-Hispanic/ Black/African American |
n = 37 Intervention = 19 Control (usual care) = 18 |
Yes | Both - 54% behaviourally infected and 46% perinatally infected |
USA High income Urban Community/home |
Confidence - self-efficacy for adherence Adherence Self-care abilities - substance use Viral suppression Mental health - depression Emotional health - stress Psychological health - problem solving / distraction Healthcare utilisation |
Bhana et al. 2014) [42] | Vuka Family Programme | RCT – parallel group |
Age 10–14 Child and caregiver 51% Female Black South Africans, Zulu Receiving childcare grant: n = 45 (82%) |
n = 65 Intervention = 33 Control (wait list) = 32 |
Yes | Perinatal |
South Africa Middle-income Urban Health facility |
Knowledge - HIV treatment knowledge Confidence - self-identity, self-satisfaction, self-esteem Social support - youth and caregiver communication and comfort Adherence Mental health - strengths and difficulties, child depression |
Dow et al. (2018, 2020) [43, 44] |
Mental Health Intervention Sauti ya Vijana (SYV; The Voice of Youth) |
RCT – parallel group |
Age 12–24 50.5% Female |
n = 93 Intervention = 55 Control (usual care) = 38 |
Yes | Both (84% perinatal) |
Tanzania Low-income Urban Health facility |
Internal stigmab Adherence Viral suppression Mental health - strengths and difficulties, post traumatic stress, depression |
Donenberg et al. (2019); Fabri et al. (2015) [45, 46] | Peer-led TI-CBT | RCT – parallel group | Age 14–21 |
n = 356 Intervention = 178 Control (other intervention with no SM components) = 178 |
Yes | Unclear |
Rwanda Low income Urban Health facility |
Adherence Health/risk behaviour - sexual behaviour and drug use Healthcare utilisation |
Holden et al. (2019) [47] | Stepping Stones | Non-RCT (Historical controls) |
Age 5–14 Limited ART adherence/school attendance 53.7% > 10 years 52% Female |
n = 177 Intervention = 86 Control (usual care) = 91 |
Yes | Unclear sexual, mostly perinatal |
Tanzania Low income Urban Community |
Adherence CD4 |
Hosek et al. (2018) [48] | ACCEPT (Adolescents Coping, Connecting, Empowering, and Protecting Together) | RCT – parallel group |
Age 16–24 Diagnosed with HIV for less than 15 months 68% Gay/lesbian 80.6% Male 51.5% Currently in school 83.5% African American |
n = 103 Intervention = 57 Control (other intervention with SM components) = 46 |
Unclear (71.8% taking ART) | Sexual |
USA High income Urban Heath facility |
Stigmac Social support Networks and communication - engagement with healthcare provider Adherence Viral suppression CD4 Health-related quality of life Mental Health - psychological distress Healthcare utilisation |
Jeffries et al. (2016) [49] | UCare4Life | RCT – parallel group |
Age 15–24 Own a phone with text-messaging capability 85% Age 21–24 86% Male 76% Black or African American 68% Diagnosed less than 3 years ago |
n = 136 Intervention = 91 Control (usual care) = 45 |
Unclear | Unclear |
USA High income Urban Home/ICT |
Adherence Self-care abilities - binge drinking Viral suppression |
Letourneau et al. (2013) [50] | Multisystemic therapy | Non-RCT – parallel group |
Age 9–17 Poor adherence/risky behaviour 65% Female 91% African American |
n = 34 Intervention = 20 Control (other intervention with SM components) = 14 |
Yes | Perinatal (33/34) |
USA High income Urban Community/ICT |
Adherence Viral suppression CD4 |
Mimiaga et al. (2019) [51] | Positive STEPS | RCT – parallel group |
Age 16–24 Self-report adherence difficulty |
n = 14 Intervention =7 Control (usual care) = 7 |
Yes | Sexual (82% behaviourally infected) |
USA High income Urban Community/ICT/ Health Facility |
Confidence - adherence readiness, medication taking, self-efficacy Social support Interpersonal skills Adherence |
Naar-King et al. (2006) [52] | Healthy Choices | RCT – parallel group |
Age 16–25 51% Male 88% African American 58% Heterosexual |
n = 62 Intervention = 31 Control (wait list) = 33 |
Unclear – 1/3 on ART | Sexual (91%) |
USA High income Urban Health facility |
Health/risk behaviour - sexual risk behaviour Self-care abilities - illicit drug and alcohol use Viral suppression |
Naar-King et al. (2009) [53] | Healthy Choices | RCT – parallel group |
Age 16–24 At least 1 of 3 HIV risk behaviours 56.6% Heterosexual 52.7% Male 83.3% African American |
n = 186 Intervention =94 Control (usual care) = 92 |
Unclear – 34.4% on ART at baseline | Unclear |
USA High income Urban Health facility |
Viral suppression |
Rongkavilit et al. (2014) [54] | Healthy Choices | RCT – parallel group |
Age 16–25 Mean age 21.7 80% Male 41.8% HIV diagnoses in last 6 months |
n = 110 Intervention = 55 Control (other intervention with no SM components) = 55 |
Unclear – 45.5% diagnosed in past 6 months | Yes, 70% MSM |
Thailand Middle income Urban Health facility |
Confidence - self-efficacy for health promotion and risk reduction Adherence Health/risk behaviour - Consistent condom use Self-care abilities - alcohol and substance use Viral suppression Mental health Emotional health - anxiety |
Webb et al. (2017) [55] | Mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) | RCT – parallel group |
Age 14–22 CD4 count > 200 Mean age 18.7 32.2% Female |
n = 93 Intervention = 48 Control (Other intervention with no SM components) = 45 |
Unclear | Unclear |
USA High income Urban Health facility |
Mindfulnessd Adherence Viral suppression CD4 s Health-related quality of life Mental health - coping Emotional health - perceived stress Psychological health – problem solving / distraction |
Whiteley et al. (2018) [56] | iPhone game (BattleViro) | RCT – parallel group |
14–26 Detectable viral load 74% Non-heterosexual Mean age 22.4 78.7% Male 96.7% Black, African American or Haitian |
n = 61 Intervention = 32 Control (other intervention with no SM components) = 29 |
Yes | Sexual |
USA High income Urban Community/ICT/Home |
Knowledge - HIV treatment, ART knowledge Confidence - motivation, self-efficacy Social support Adherence Health / risk behaviour - Sexual risk behaviour Viral suppression Mental health - psychological distress |
Key: HCW Healthcare worker, ICT Information Communications Technology
aRCT randomised controlled trial
bNot an outcome of this review, but included for completeness
cNot an outcome of this review, but included for completeness
dMindfulness not an outcome of this review, but included for completeness under Confidence