Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 26;23(9):3191–3206. doi: 10.1039/d1gc00561h

Enzyme formulations, their advantages, challenges, and some examples in different solvent systems. GMO: genetically modified organism. More information, examples and literature is shown in the ESI†.

Enzyme formulation Advantages Challenges Selected examples in the different reaction systems
Crude cell extract • High activity • Likely unstable in organic solvents Cosolvent67
graphic file with name d1gc00561h-u7.jpg • Relatively easy and cheap to produce • Hard to retain in continuous systems Biphasic80
• Cofactors potentially already present in extract • Hard to recycle for reuse
• Possible interfering native background reactions
Soluble purified enzyme • No native background reactions • Laborious and expensive to produce Cosolvent67
graphic file with name d1gc00561h-u8.jpg • High activity • Likely unstable in organic solvents Biphasic33,81
• No GMO license needed • Hard to recycle for reuse MARS30
• Hard to separate from reaction mixture Neat58
Immobilized enzyme • No native background reactions • Laborious and expensive to produce Cosolvent82
graphic file with name d1gc00561h-u9.jpg • No GMO licence needed • Additional material needed Biphasic83
• Easy to retain and reuse • Not always biodegradable MARS33,83,84
• Possible enhanced stability in organic solvents • Unpredictable effect on enzyme activity and stability possible Neat56,57,83
Whole cells • Easy and cheap to produce • Possible interfering native background reactions Cosolvent85,86
graphic file with name d1gc00561h-u10.jpg • Possible enhanced stability in organic solvents • Viable cells can be susceptible to reaction components Biphasic55,87
• Easy to separate from reaction mix • Often GMO licence needed MARS48,88
Neat45
Immobilized whole cells • Relatively cheap to produce • Possible interfering native background reactions Biphasic89
graphic file with name d1gc00561h-u11.jpg • Potentially stable in organic media • Viable cells can be susceptible to reaction components MARS55,90,91
• Easy to retain in continuous systems • Possibly laborious to produce Neat76
• Easy to separate from reaction mixture • Often GMO licence needed