Skip to main content
. 2021 Jan 4;50(7):1389–1397. doi: 10.1007/s00256-020-03702-7

Table 1.

Mean values (± standard deviation, SD) for measurements and intra- and interobserver reliabilities expressed as ICCs (intraclass correlation coefficient). Statistically significant p-values are shown in italics. p < 0.05 are classed as statistically significant and ≥ 0.05 as not significant. R1, 2; rater 1 and 2; M1, 2; measurement 1 and 2. CI; confidence interval

Comparison Variable 1 Mean ± SD Variable 2 Mean ± SD Mean diff. ± SD p ICC 95% CI
Intrarater R1 Kanekasu Surg. M1 − 1.6; 2.78 Kanekasu Surg. M2 − 1.9; 2.93 0.31; 2.13 0.199 0.721 0.599 – 0.811
Anat. M1 2.65; 2.84 Anat. M2 2.96; 3.01 − 0.32; 1.6 0.077 0.850 0.777–0.901
2D-CT Surg. M1 − 0.45; 2.56 2D-CT Surg. M2 − 0.46; 2.77 0.01; 1.34 0.934 0.874 0.811–0.917
Anat. M1 2.96; 2.9 Anat. M2 3.15; 2.79 − 0.18; 1.14 0.148 0.920 0.879- 0 .948
Intrarater R2 Kanekasu Surg. M1 − 1.72; 2.57 Kanekasu Surg. M2 − 1.89; 2.33 0.17; 0.97 0.113 0.923 0.882–0.949
Anat. M1 3.29; 2.52 Anat. M2 3.02; 2.49 0.27; 1.1 0.030 0.904 0.854–0.937
2D-CT Surg. M1 − 1.22; 2.39 2D-CT Surg. M2 − 1.43; 2.46 0.21; 1.3 0.153 0.856 0.785–0.904
Anat. M1 3.07; 2.5 Anat. M2 2.9; 2.63 0.17; 1.39 0.268 0.854 0.783–0.903
Interrater Kanekasu Surg. R1 − 1.75; 2.65 Kanekasu Surg. R2 − 1.81; 2.41 0.05; 1.52 0.744 0.820 0.734–0.880
Anat. R1 2.81; 2.82 Anat. R2 3.16; 2.44 − 0.35; 1.46 0.031 0.846 0.771–0.898
2D-CT Surg. R1 − 0.46; 2.58 2D-CT Surg. R2 − 1.32; 2.34 0.87; 1.21 0.000 0.878 0.817–0.920
Anat. R1 3.06; 2.79 Anat. R2 2.99; 2.47 0.07; 1.17 0.605 0.901 0.851–0.935
Surg. vs. anat. Kanekasu Surg. − 1.78; 2.41 Kanekasu Anat. 2.98; 2.53 − 4.76; 1.07 0.000 0.907 0.859–0.939
2D-CT Surg. − 0.89; 2.39 2D-CT Anat. 3.02; 2.57 − 3.91; 0.82 0.000 0.946 0.917–0.965
Kanekasu vs. 2D-CT Kanekasu Surg. − 1.78; 2.41 2D-CT Surg. − 0.89; 2.39 − 0.89; 1.76 0.000 0.731 0.611–0.818
Anat. 2.98; 2.53 Anat. 3.02; 2.57 − 0.04; 1.77 0.839 0.760 0.651–0.838
With 3D-CT total Kanekasu Surg. − 1.78; 2.41 3D-CT Anat. 3.15; 2.93 − 4.92; 2.71 0.000 0.489 0.305–0.638
Anat. 2.98; 2.53 − 0.16; 2.4 0.537 0.614 0.459–0.733
2D-CT Surg. − 0.89; 2.39 − 4.04; 1.95 0.000 0.733 0.615–0.820
Anat. 3.02; 2.57 − 0.13; 1.65 0.494 0.821 0.736–0.881