Table 1.
Description of the systems, parameterization and trajectory lengths simulated in this work, together with a brief description of the key observations compared to the behavior expected based on experimental knowledge of the different systems.
| System | Parameterization(protein-water) | Replicas × length | Expected behavior (italics) vs. observations in the simulations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single Htt-1-19 peptide in 100 mM KCl at neutral pH | Soluble and disordered but with ~10–30% helical propensity according to circular dichroism spectra that peaks at residues 14–18[45]. | ||
| ff14SB-TIP3P | 1 × ~ 10 µs | Helix propensity too high (45%), highest for residues 3–12. | |
| CHARMM36m-TIP3P* | 1 × ~ 10 µs | 22% helix propensity, highest for residues 9–15. | |
| a99SBdisp-TIP4PD | 1 × ~ 10 µs | 28% helix propensity, highest for residues 3–14. | |
| ff19SB-OPC | 1 × ~ 10 µs | 29% helix propensity, highest for residues 4–11. | |
| 3 ubiquitin molecules around 5 mM, in 100 mM KCl at neutral pH | Soluble but undergoing weak dimerization through a favored interface (residues 4–12, 42–51 and 62–71), exchanging in the microsecond timescale[40]. | ||
| ff14SB-TIP3P | 3 × ~ 1.7 µs | Aggregation into dimers and then trimers that get increasingly more compact. | |
| CHARMM36m-TIP3P* | 3 × ~ 2 µs | Aggregation into dimers and then trimers but less compact than with ff14SB-TIP3P. | |
| a99SBdisp-TIP4PD | 3 × ~ 1.9 µs | Soluble with a few short-lived encounters that do not match the NMR data; no trimers. | |
| ff19SB-OPC | 3 × ~ 2.2 us | Dimers lasting for tens to few hundreds nanoseconds, contacts most consistent with NMR data yet not perfect; no trimers. | |
| 9 ubiquitin molecules around 5 mM, in 100 mM KCl at neutral pH | Soluble but undergoing weak dimerization through a favored interface (residues 4–12, 42–51 and 62–71), exchanging in the microsecond timescale[40]. | ||
| ff14SB-TIP3P | 1 × ~ 0.95 µs | Aggregates form and grow bigger and more compact. | |
| CHARMM36m-TIP3P* | 1 × ~ 0.88 µs | Aggregates form and grow bigger, but less compact than ff14SB-TIP3P. | |
| a99SBdisp-TIP4PD | 1 × ~ 1.1 µs | Highly soluble, only collisions through no preferred surface. | |
| ff19SB-OPC | 1 × ~ 1.1 us | Some dimers form that then grow into bigger aggregates, but slower than C36m. | |
| 10 Aβ 16–22 molecules at around 10 mM, in 50 mM KCl at neutral pH | Totally insoluble in water. Forms β-rich fibrils and amorphous aggregates depending on conditions and concentration[41]. | ||
| ff14SB-TIP3P | 1 × ~ 1.8 µs | Aggregate of large β content | |
| CHARMM36m-TIP3P* | 1 × ~ 1.8 µs | Aggregate of large β content | |
| a99SBdisp-TIP4PD | 1 × ~ 2 µs | Remains soluble, some reversible formation of different pairs of strands | |
| ff19SB-OPC | 1 × 1.95 us | Largely soluble, with small aggregates of β content | |
| Fiber stretch of 10 Aβ-40 strands from PDB 2LNQ, in 50 mM KCl at neutral pH | Totally insoluble fiber that does not dissociate in water[51]. | ||
| ff14SB-TIP3P | 3 × ~ 3 µs | Rigid, max Cα RMSD 5–6 Å | |
| CHARMM36m-TIP3P* | 3 × ~ 3 µs | Less rigid than ff14SB, max Cα RMSD 8–10 Å. | |
| a99SBdisp-TIP4PD | 3 × ~ 3 µs | Similar to CHARMM36m, max Cα RMSD 8–10 Å. | |
| ff19SB-OPC | 3 × ~ 3 us | As rigid as ff14SB-TIP3P, max Cα RMSD 5–6 Å | |