Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 5;2020(7):CD012527. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012527.pub2

NCT03518359.

Study name Public title: Enhanced Stress Resilience Training for Residents (ESRT‐R)
Scientific title: Enhanced resilience training to improve mental health, stress and performance in resident physicians
Methods Study design: 2‐arm RCT
Study grouping: parallel assignment
Unit of randomisation: individuals
Power (power sample size calculation, level of power achieved): not specified
Imputation of missing data: not specified
Participants Country: USA
Setting: Emergency Medicine, Internal Medicine, Paediatrics, Family Practice, Obstetrics and Gynaecology (OBGYN) and Surgery Departments of University of California San Francisco
Age: see inclusion criteria; age not specified
Sample size (randomised): 45 (actual enrolment)
Sex: not specified
Comorbidity (mean (SD) of respective measures in indicated, if available) at baseline: not specified, but participants with lifetime history of organic mental illness excluded
Population description: resident physicians/medical interns
Inclusion criteria: 1) any consented medical intern from Emergency Medicine, Internal Medicine, Paediatrics, Family Practice, OBGYN and Surgery Departments in‐coming to University of California San Francisco in the study year; 2) aged 18 ‐ 64 years
Exclusion criteria: 1) current personal mindfulness practice, once a week or more frequent; 2) use of medications with Central Nervous System effects; 3) lifetime history of an organic mental illness; 4) acute or chronic immune or inflammatory disorders; 5) pregnancy
Attrition (withdrawals and exclusions): not specified
Reasons for missing data: not specified
Interventions Intervention: Enhanced Stress Resilience Training (ESRT) (n not specified)
  • delivery: face‐to‐face, CDs and videos; group sessions

  • providers: not specified

  • duration of treatment period and timing: 6 weekly 90‐minute classes (weekly teaching sessions on workday morning protected time; guided meditation CDs, videos of movement‐based practice) + single 2‐ to 4‐hour retreat + 20 minutes daily homework)

  • description:

    • mental training for residents

    • CLASSES: focus on developing mindfulness skills (i.e. sustained attention, open monitoring, emotional regulation, meta‐cognition) in the context of skills and concepts for managing stress, particularly in practising medicine

    • DAILY HOMEWORK: mindfulness exercises following guided meditation CDs or videos of movement‐based practice (practice reported periodically by text)

    • RETREAT: 3‐hour outdoor retreat at week 6

    • central exercises of ESRT: body scan, sitting meditation, chi gong, yoga

  • compliance: not specified

  • integrity of delivery: not specified

  • economic information: not specified

  • theoretical basis: modified form of MBSR


Control: active control (n not specified)
  • delivery: face‐to‐face; group sessions

  • providers: not specified

  • duration of treatment period and timing: 6 weekly 90‐minute classes + 20 minutes daily homework

  • description:

    • externalised attention via “shared reading and listening” model

    • CLASSES: focus on stress management through rest and exercise, with equivalent protected time and small‐group bonding but without the use of contemplative practices

    • Topics include: history of surgery, patient perspective, the physician personality, technical mastery, fallibility and limits, balancing compassion and detachment, knowing when not to operate

    • DAILY PRACTICE: participants asked to devote 20 minutes a day to stress management through rest and exercise (reported daily by text)

  • compliance: not specified

  • integrity of delivery: not specified

  • economic information: not specified

  • theoretical basis: “shared reading and listening” model, stress management

Outcomes Outcomes collected and reported:
  • executive function ‐ National Institutes of Health Executive Abilities, Measures and Instruments for Neurobehavioral Evaluation and Research (NIH EXAMINER) battery

  • psychological well‐being ‐ Mental Health Continuum

  • perceived stress ‐ PSS

  • burnout ‐ 2‐item MBI

  • anxiety ‐ Spielberger’s STAI

  • depression and suicidal ideation ‐ PHQ

  • mindfulness ‐ CAMS‐R

  • alcohol misuse ‐ Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Scale (Alcohol Consumption Questions)

  • functional neuro‐anatomic changes ‐ fMRI Blood‐oxygen‐level‐dependent imaging (BOLD) and Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) brain scans

  • motor skills ‐ Fundamentals of Laparoscopic Surgery modules

  • mind‐wandering ‐ Mind‐Wandering Questionnaire

  • change in emotional regulation: decentring ‐ Experiences Questionnaire

  • consultation and relational empathy ‐ Consultation and Relational Empathy Measure

  • change in performance: patient experience ‐ Patient Enablement Instrument


Outcomes reported: not specified
Time points measured and reported: 1) pre‐intervention; 2) post‐intervention (9 ‐ 10 weeks after baseline); 3) 6‐month follow‐up; time points reported not specified
Adverse events: not specified
Starting date Study start/end date: June 2018; estimated primary completion date: June 2021; estimated study completion date: June 2022; active, not recruiting according to trial registration
Contact information Principal investigator: Carter K Lebares, MD; Ekaterina V Guvva, BS
Address: University of Californisa, San Francisco, California, United States, 94143
Email: carter.lebares@ucsf.edu; ekaterina.guvva@ucsf.edu
Telephone: 415‐502‐5588
Notes Contact with authors: We contacted the authors for the trial status. According to the authors, the recruitment for study is closed and the results will be published in the next 6 months (Guvva 2019 [pers comm]).
Funding source: University of California, San Francisco
Declaration of interest: not specified
Ethical approval needed/obtained for study: not specified
Comments by study authors: not specified
Miscellaneous outcomes by the review authors: trial registration number: NCT03518359 (assigned 8 May 2018)