Ortholan et al. [20] |
69 patients: 12 patients with Tis, 57 patients with T1, all ≤1 cm; 66 received RT, 3 Tis treated with local excision alone |
91% local control in RT group; 5-year OS 94%, CFS 85%, and DFS 89% |
Fallai et al. [21] |
62 patients: 9 stage I, with 8 patients treated with CRT |
5-year OS and LRC both 100% for stage I patients |
Zilli et al. [22] |
146 patients: 29 patients with T1, 117 with T2 disease; RT alone in 71 and CRT in 75 |
5-year LRC of 75.5% for RT vs. 86.8% for CRT, p = 0.155; 5-year CSS of 88.5% for RT vs. 94.9% for CRT, p = 0.161 |
De Bari et al. [23] |
122 patients: 24 patients with T1, 98 patients with T2; RT alone in 52 and CRT in 70 |
CRT improved LC on multivariate analysis (RR = 0.34, 95% CI 0.16–0.75, p = 0.007) |
Miller et al. [4] |
3839 stage I patients: RT alone in 287 and CRT in 3552 |
CRT associated with a 31% reduction in the risk of death compared to RT alone (HR = 0.69, 95% CI 0.50–0.95, p = 0.023) |
Buckstein et al. [3] |
299 stage I patients: RT alone in 99 and CRT in 200 |
After propensity score matching, no difference in OS, CSS, CFS, or DFS between the groups. |