Table 6.
Study, Country, Outcome | No. of CPP* | AI methods | Predictors | Val. methods | Performance (AUC, Accuracy (Acc%), Sensitivity (SEN%), Specificity (SPE%), PPV/NPV (%), (95% CI)) | Risk of Bias**: Participants/Predictors/Outcome/Analysis/Overall | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fakhfakh et al. [42], Prognosis | 42 | RNN, CNN | Unclear | unspecified | Acc 92 | H | U | U | L | H |
Zhu et al. [66], China, Disease progression prediction | 408 | SVM, LR | Imaging features | 5-FCV | Acc 85.91 | L | U | U | H | H |
Qi et al. [67], China, Hospital stay prediction (Short-term (<10 days), long-term (>10 days)) | 31 | LR, RF | Imaging features (CT radiomics) | 5-FCV | AUC 0.97, SEN 100, SPE 89, (95%CI 0.83–1.0) | U | L | L | H | H |
Xiao et al. [68], China, Severity assessment, disease progression | 408 | DL, CNN, ResNet34 (RNN) | Imaging features | 5-FCV | AUC 0.987 (95% CI: 0.968–1.00), Acc 97.4 | L | U | U | H | H |
Cohen et al. [36], Severity assessment for COVID19 Pneumonia | 80 | NN | CXR features | not performed | U | U | U | H | H | |
Salvatore et al. [69], Italy, Prognosis prediction (discharging at home, hospitalization in stable conditions, hospitalization in critical conditions, death) | 98 | LR | Imaging features | not performed | Acc 81, SEN 88, SPE 78 | H | U | U | H | H |
Liu et al. [44], China, Severity assessment | 134 | CNN | Imaging features (APACHE-II, NLR, d-dimer level) | Ext. val. | AUC 0.93, (95% CI: 0.87–0.99) | L | U | U | U | U |
*CPP = COVID-19 Positive Patients, Abbreviations of medical terms included in this Table are provided in the Appendix.
**L: Low, H: High, U: Unclear