Table 2.
Study # | Quality Rating | Citation, Year | Q1: Prevalence Questionnaire [Cut-Point], % (95% CI)* | Q1: Severity Questionnaire [Full Scale Range], Mean (SD, if provided) | Q1: Prevalence (P) and/or Severity (S) Relative to CG (of Non-TC Survivors) | Q2: Demographic, Disease and Treatment Correlates | Q3: Associations Between PROs |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Anxiety | |||||||
1 | Good | Bandak et al, 201832 | HADS [≥7], 20% | NR | NA | NR | NR |
3 | Good | Skott et al, 201934 | HADS [>7], 21.08% | NR | NA | Non-sig: age | NR |
4 | Fair | Adams et al, 201830 | NR | SSAS-10 [20–80, unclear how they weighted the scores]: baseline exercise group: 18.6 (5.5), baseline control: 16.2 (4.7). | NA | NR | NR |
5 | Fair | Manhães et al, 201933 | HADS [≥8], 6.9% | HADS [0–21], 3.2 (3.8) | NA | NR | Sexual Confidence and Functioning (p = 0.04), Cognitive-Emotional Regulation (p = 0.001), and Specific Sexual Functioning (p = 0.04) were predictors of anxiety symptoms (R2= 61%). |
8 | Fair | Whitford et al, 201929 | NA | HADS [0–21], Baseline Group A: 6.16 (4.08), baseline group B: 4.13 (3.69); FU Group A: 4.72 (3.36), FU Group B: 3.25 (3.69) | NA | Non sig: Treatment type (surgery alone vs surgery + chemo) | NR |
Depression | |||||||
1 | Good | Bandak et al, 201832 | HADS [≥7], 7% | NR | NA | NR | NR |
3 | Good | Skott et al, 201934 | HADS [>7], 4.7% | NR | NA | Non-sig: age | NR |
4 | Fair | Adams et al, 201830 | NR | CES-D10 [0–30]: baseline exercise group: 5.3 (4.7), baseline control: 4.5 (4.4) | NA | NR | NR |
5 | Fair | Manhães et al, 201933 | HADS [≥9], 6.9% | HADS [0–21], 1.8 (3.7) | No | NA | Sexual Confidence and Functioning was associated with symptoms of depression (p = 0.01). Cognitive-Emotional Regulation (p = 0.001) and Specific Sexual Functioning (P = 0.005) were predictors of symptoms of depression (R2N = 74%). |
7 | Fair | Wang & Hoyt, 202035 | NR | CES-D20 [0–60], 12.99 (12.08) | NA | NR | Depression was significantly and positively correlated with cancer-related masculine threat. Depression was significantly and negatively correlated with benefit finding |
8 | Fair | Whitford et al, 201929 | NR | HADS [0–21], Baseline Group A: 3.05 (3.66), baseline group B: 2.1 (2.21); FU Group A: 2.09 (2.55), FU Group B: 1.8 (2.72) | NA | Non sig: Treatment type (surgery alone vs surgery + chemo) | NR |
Distress | |||||||
2 | Good | Kreiberg et al, 202031 | PSS [≥16], 25% | PSS [0–40], 11.5 (6.3) | Multivariate adjusted prevalence ratio to reference population 1.56 (95% CI 1.40–1.73, P<0.0001)’. | Age (higher P of stress in TCS until 70 years of age, it changes after this age and the CG becomes the most stressed). Significantly higher S than the general male population in multivariable adjusted analysis for all treatment groups, but no direct comparison between treatment groups. High distress associated with being single, unemployed, and poor self-rated fitness. |
NR |
4 | Fair | Adams et al, 201830 | NA | PSS [0–40]: baseline exercise group: 19.7 (8.5), baseline control: 16.3 (9.1). | NA | NR | NR |
5 | Fair | Manhães et al, 201933 | DT [≥4], 41.4% | DT [0–10], 3.2 (2.8) | NA | Cognitive-Emotional Regulation predicted distress (p = 0.01; R2 = 37%). | NR |
Fear of Cancer Recurrence | |||||||
6 | Fair | Van Leeuwen et al, 201728 | NA | QLQ-TC26 future perspective subscale [0–100], 77 (24) | NR | Marital status: single men had worse FCR (future perspective sub-domain of the QLQ-TC-26) | NR |
Note: *or proportions of patients with high levels of the outcome.
Abbreviations: TC, testicular cancer; Q1, research question 1; Q2, research question 2; Q3, research question 3; P, prevalence; S, severity; SD, standard deviation; CG, control group; FU, follow-up; PROs, patient-reported outcomes; FCR, fear of cancer recurrence; HADS, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; PSS, Perceived Stress Scale; CES-D10, Centre for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale 10 item scale; CES-D20, Centre for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale 20 item scale; SSAS-10, Spielberger State Anxiety Scale 10-item inventory; QLQ-TC26, Quality of Life Questionnaire - Testicular Cancer-26; DT, Distress Thermometer; MOS-HDS, Medical Outcomes Study - Health Distress Scale; Sig, significant; NR, none reported; NA, not applicable.