Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 14;2020(9):CD013574. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013574.pub2
Author and year Was the model a dynamic (transmission) model? Did the authors conduct uncertainty analyses on key assumptions that may have had an impact of the conclusions? Do the results provide estimates of the change in the burden of infection due to the intervention? Quality
Becker 2005 Yes Unclear Unclear Moderate concerns
Cao 2020 Yes Unclear Unclear Moderate concerns
Chau 2003 Yes No Unclear Major concerns
Choi 2020 Unclear No Unclear Major concerns
Day 2006 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Fang 2020 Yes Yes Unclear Moderate concerns
Ferguson 2020 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Fraser 2004 Yes Unclear Unclear Moderate concerns
Geng 2020 Yes No Yes Major concerns
Gumel 2004 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Gupta 2005 Unclear Yes Yes Moderate concerns
Hamidouche 2020 Unclear Yes No (only very limited) Major concerns
Hoertel 2020 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Hou 2020 Yes Yes No Major concerns
Hsieh 2007 Yes Unclear Yes Moderate concerns
Hu 2020 Yes Yes No (only very limited) Major concerns
Koo 2020 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Kucharski 2020 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Liu 2020b Yes Yes No (only very limited) Major concerns
Lloyd‐Smith 2003 Yes Yes Unclear Moderate concerns
Madubueze 2020 Yes Yes Unclear Moderate concerns
Mubayi 2010 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Nishiura 2004 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Pandey 2020 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Peak 2017 Yes Unclear Yes Moderate concerns
Peak 2020 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Pourbohloul 2005 Yes Yes Unclear Moderate concerns
Rocklöv 2020 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Ryu 2020 Yes Unclear No (only very limited) Major concerns
Semenova 2020 Yes No Yes Major concerns
Shen 2020 Yes Unclear Yes Moderate concerns
Sjödin 2020 Yes Unclear Yes Moderate concerns
Su 2020 Yes Unclear Yes Moderate concerns
Tang 2020a Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Tang 2020b Yes Unclear Yes Moderate concerns
Tuite 2020 Yes Unclear Yes Moderate concerns
Wang 2004 Yes Unclear No Major concerns
Wang 2020 Unclear (but missing compartment E is an issue) Yes Yes Moderate concerns
Wu 2020b Yes No Yes Major concerns
Yip 2007 Yes No Unclear Major concerns
Yue 2020 Yes No Yes Major concerns
Zhang 2017 Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Zhao 2020a Yes Yes Unclear Moderate concerns