Skip to main content
. 2021 May 21;100(20):e24571. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000024571

Table 1.

Study characteristics of the RCTs included in the meta-analysis.

Studies (first author, date of publication) Clinical inclusion criteria The presence and the degree of bleeding Sample size Intravenous iron dosage Total intravenous dose of iron Time of Hb, ferritin assessment after treatment initiation Quality of life
Lee 2019[16] Women with IDA due to menorrhagia (Hb < 10 g/dL, ferritin < 30 ng/mL) Menorrhagia with heavy cyclical menstrual blood loss (>80 mL per cycle) over 3 cycles FCM group, n = 52 FCM: body weight < 50 kg (500 mg iron), > 50 kg (1000 mg iron), single dose FCM: 923.1 ± 207.3 mg (at single visit) 2 wk Short Form-12 Health Survey (SF-12), no differences in outcomes between groups.
IS group, n = 49 IS: Ganzoni formula. (200 mg/wk × 3 wk) IS: 939.1 ± 352.3 mg (over 3–8 visits)
Jose 2019[17] Pregnant women with IDA (Hb > 6.0 g/dL, < 10 g/dL) No active bleeding FCM group, n = 50 FCM: Ganzoni formula. (1000 mg single dose, repeated after days 7 and 14) FCM: 1739.6 ± 105.5 mg (over 2 wk) 3, 6, 12 wk Fatigue (LASA; Linear Analogue Scale Assessment), lower in the FCM group compared with the IS group (P = 0.0048).
IS group, n = 50 IS: Ganzoni formula. (300 mg twice/wk) IS: 1,730.4 ± 121.9 mg (over 3 wk)
Naqash 2018[18] Obstetric (pregnancy, postpartum) and gynecologic (menorrhagia, uterus heavy bleeding, ovarian cyst) patients with IDA Menorrhagia (bleeding for more than 7 d with heavy clots, and doubling of pads or tampons to manage menstrual flow), Uterus heavy bleeding (more than 12 d with doubling of pads or tampons to manage menstrual flow) FCM group, n = 100 FCM: Ganzoni formula (1000 mg single dose) FCM: no details provided. 2, 4 wk Short Form 36 (SF-36), improved outcomes in the FCM group compared with the IS group (no comments for P value).
IS group, n = 100 IS: Ganzoni formula (200 mg × 2–3 times) IS: no details provided.
Sumathy 2017[19] Postpartum women with IDA (Hb 8–10 g/dL) Normal postpartum women at 24 h after delivery FCM group, n = 50 FCM: modified Ganzoni formula (single dose) FCM: 937.94 mg 2, 4 wk No details provided
IS group, n = 50 IS: modified Ganzoni formula (200 mg/d × 5 times) IS: 935.53 mg
Mahey 2016[20] Women older than 18 years with heavy menorrhagia and IDA (Hb 6.0–10.9 g/dL) Menorrhagia with a pictorial bleeding assessment chart score higher than 100 FCM group, n = 30 FCM: modified Ganzoni formula (1000 mg single dose) FCM: no details provided 1, 6, 12 wk Fatigue (LASA; Linear Analogue Scale Assessment), improved outcomes in both groups without any statistical differences
IS group, n = 30 IS: modified Ganzoni formula (300 mg twice weekly) IS: no details provided
Joshi 2016[21] Postpartum women with IDA (Hb ≤ 6.0 g/dL, ≥ 11 g/dL) Postpartum women with significant vaginal bleeding in 24 h prior was excluded FCM group, n = 90 FCM: 1000 mg single dose FCM: 1000 mg 30 d No details provided
IS group, n = 83 IS: 200 mg × 5 times IS: 1000 mg
Hol 2015[22] Postpartum women with IDA (Hb, 7–11 g/dL)—moderate anemia group Postpartum women suffering from acute blood loss was excluded FCM group, n = 20 FCM: 500 mg × 2 times FCM, 500 mg 1 d, 6 wk No details provided
IS group, n = 20 IS: 200 mg × 4 times IS, 500 mg
Garg 2015[23] Postpartum women with IDA (Hb < 7 g/dL) All normal delivery and cesarean delivery patient FCM group, n = 50 FCM: body weight (kg) × [target Hb (11 g/dL) – actual Hb (g/dL)] × 0.24 + storage iron (500 mg), single dose FCM: no details provided 2, 4 wk No details provided
IS group, n = 50 IS: body weight (kg) × [target Hb (11 g/dL) —actual Hb (g/dL)] × 0.24 + storage iron (500 mg), 200 mg × 5 times IS: no details provided
Rathod 2015[24] Postpartum women with IDA (Hb < 10 g/dL) No details about the bleeding FCM group, n = 14 FCM: body weight (kg) × [target Hb (12 g/dL) —actual Hb (g/dL)] × 0.24 + storage iron (500 mg), single dose FCM: no details provided 2, 6 wk General Well-Being Scale, higher scores in the FCM group compared with the IS group
IS group, n = 22 IS: body weight (kg) × [target Hb (11 g/dL) —actual Hb (g/dL)] × 0.24 + storage iron (500 mg), 200 mg × 5 times IS: no details provided