Skip to main content
. 2021 May 22;2021(5):CD012721. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012721.pub3

Aronow 1993.

Study characteristics
Methods Study design: parallel RCT
Centres: not reported
Start of enrolment: not reported
End of enrolment: not reported
Mean follow‐up: 3 months
Run‐in period: 2 mornings of control period
Participants Inclusion criteria: "New York Heart Association functional class III CHF associated with prior myocardial infarction and normal LV ejection fraction (>50%) who were able to perform a maximal treadmill exercise test were included in the study".
Exclusion criteria: "No patient had valvular heart disease, systolic blood pressure ~100 mm Hg, lung disease, hepatic disease or renal insufficiency."
Randomised (N): 21 (10 intervention, 11 control)
Withdrawn (N): not reported
Lost to follow‐up (N): not reported
Analysed (N): not reported
Age (years, mean, SD): intervention: 80, 3; control: 79, 4
Sex (% men): 14.3
Ethnicity (%): not reported
Systolic blood pressure (mmHg, mean, SD): intervention: 126, 12; control: 127, 10
Heart rate (beats/min, mean, SD): intervention: 85, 6; control: 84, 3
BMI not reported
Serum creatinine not reported
B‐type natriuretic peptide (pg/mL): not reported
NT pro B‐type natriuretic peptide (pg/mL): not reported
LVEF (%, mean, SD): intervention: 64, 9; control: 64, 7
NYHA class I (%): 0
NYHA class II (%): 0
NYHA class III (%): 100
NYHA class IV (%): 0
Hypertension not reported
Diabetes not reported
Atrial fibrillation not reported
Hospitalisation for heart failure: not reported
Coronary heart disease not reported
Stroke not reported
Diuretic (%): 100
Digoxin (%): 0
Beta‐blocker (%): 0
ACEI study drug
ARB not reported
MRA not reported
Interventions Intervention: enalapril. "The initial dose of enalapril was 2.5 mg/day, which was increased to 5 mg/day during week 2, to 10 mg/day (5 mg twice daily) during week 3, to 15 mg/day (7.5 mg twice daily) during week 4 and up to a maximum of 20 mg (10 mg twice daily) during week 5, tf tolerated. If the patient developed symptomatic hypotension or an increase in serum creatinine level, the dose of enalapril was reduced to the previous dose. At the time of the follow‐up studies, 3 months after beginning enalapril, the dose of enalapril was 2.5 mg/day in 1 patient, 5 mg/day in 1 patient, 10 mg/day in 3 patients, 1.5 mg/day in 2 patients, and 20 mg/day in 3 patients."
Comparator: no treatment
Concomitant medication: "All patients received diuretic treatment with furosemide for ~2 weeks before the beginning of the study and a constant dose of furosemide during the study. Digitalis and other cardiac drugs (except enalapril) were not administered to any patient during the study."
Outcomes Planned: not reported
Reported: NYHA class, blood pressure, heart rate, cardiothoracic ratio, treadmill exercise time, LVEF, peak mitral E/A ratio, left ventricular mass
Notes no outcome data relevant for this review.
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Random sequence generation (selection bias) Unclear risk not reported
Allocation concealment (selection bias) Unclear risk not reported
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias)
All outcomes Unclear risk not reported
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias)
All outcomes Unclear risk "Chest roentgenograms were interpreted by a radiologist who was unaware of the study medication. M‐mode, 2‐ dimensional and pulsed‐wave Doppler echocardiograms were interpreted by an experienced echocardiographer (IK) who was unaware of the study medication. Treadmill exercise tests were performed under the guidance of the senior author who was aware of which patients were receiving enalapril."
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias)
All outcomes Unclear risk not reported
Selective reporting (reporting bias) Unclear risk not reported
Other bias Unclear risk unable to assess