Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: Clin Superv. 2021 Apr 15;40(1):88–111. doi: 10.1080/07325223.2021.1904312

Table 1.

Study Characteristics

Citation Study Design Methodological
Rigor
Examined
Practices
Examined
Characteristics
Examined
Formative
Outcome
Examined
Restorative
Outcome
Supervisor
Sample Size
Provider
Sample Size
Setting Country
Anderson et al., 2012 One-group pre-post 2 Yes No Yes No 2 16 Clinic US
Bambling & King, 2014 Correlational 1 No Yes Yes No 40 50 Clinic Australia
Bearman et al., 2013 Correlational 1 Yes Yes Yes No 12 57 Clinic, School US
Bearman et al., 2017 Randomized controlled trial 4 Yes No Yes No Not Reported 40 Other US
Bradshaw et al., 2007 Quasi-experimental trial 3 Yes No Yes No Not Reported 23 Clinic, Hospital UK
Carmel et al., 2016 Randomized controlled trial 4 Yes No Yes Yes 5 8 Clinic US
Dodenhoff, 1981 Correlational 1 No Yes Yes No 12 44 Clinic US
Fukui et al., 2019 Correlational 1 No Yes No Yes N/A 195 Clinic US
Henggeler et al., 2002 Correlational 1 No Yes Yes No 12 74 Not reported US
Kavanagh et al., 2003 Correlational 1 Yes Yes Yes Yes Not Reported; Total N = 272 Not Reported; Total N = 272 Clinic, Hospital Australia
Kim et al., 2018 Correlational 1 No Yes No Yes N/A 688 Clinic US
Knudsen et al., 2008 Correlational 1 No Yes No Yes N/A 1001 Clinic US
Laschober et al., 2013 Correlational 1 Yes Yes Yes No 162 392 Clinic US
Livni et al., 2012 One-group pre-post 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes 10 37 Clinic Australia
Locke et al., 2018 Correlational 1 No Yes No Yes 47 187 Clinic US
Martino et al., 2016 Randomized controlled trial 4 Yes No Yes No 22 66 Clinic US
Rakovshik et al., 2016 Randomized controlled trial 4 Yes No Yes No Not Reported 61 Clinic, Hospital Russia, Ukraine
Roncalli & Byrne, 2016 Correlational 1 No Yes No Yes N/A 77 Clinic Ireland
Schoenwald et al., 2009 Correlational 1 No Yes Yes No 122 429 Clinic US
Smith et al., 2007 One-group pre-post 2 Yes No Yes No 5 13 Clinic US
Webster & Hackett, 1999 Correlational 1 No Yes No Yes N/A 151 Clinic US
Weck et al., 2016 Randomized controlled trial 4 Yes No Yes No 9 23 Clinic Germany