Table 2.
Summary of the clinical, surrogate, and process outcomes considered in each study.
Study | Clinical outcomes | Surrogate outcome categoriesa | Process outcome categoriesa | Quality rating (%) | |
|
|
|
|
Quantitative measure | Qualitative measure |
Beuchat et al, 2005 [22] | N/Ab | + Decreased missed vital sign changes + Reduced time to detect vital sign changes |
+ Changed patterns of gaze behavior + Increased time focused on patient |
58 | —c |
Block et al, 1995 [29] | N/Md | N/M | + Clinician opinions | 25 | — |
Drake-Brockman et al, 2016 [30] | N/M | N/M | + Clinician opinions | 83 | — |
Iqbal et al, 2016 [23] | N/A | + Reduced time to detect vital sign changes | = Changed time to do other tasks + Clinician opinions |
63 | — |
Liebert et al, 2016 [24] | N/A | = Earlier identification of deterioration | + Changed patterns of gaze behavior + Increased time focused on patient |
92 | — |
Liu et al, 2009 [20] and Liu et al, 2010 [21]e | N/M | N/M | += Changed patterns of gaze behavior + Increased time focused on patient = Clinician opinions |
88 | — |
Liu et al, 2009 [19]: experiment 1 | N/A | = Increased unexpected events detected = Reduced time to detect unexpected events |
+ Changed patterns of gaze behavior + Increased time focused on patient = Clinician opinions |
75 | — |
Liu et al, 2009 [19]: experiment 2 | N/A | += Increased unexpected events detected += Reduced time to detect unexpected events |
+ Changed patterns of gaze behavior + Increased time focused on patient + Clinician opinions |
75 | — |
Ormerod et al, 2002 [25] | N/A | N/M | + Changed patterns of gaze behavior + Increased time focused on patient + Changed time to do other tasks + Clinician opinions |
29 | — |
Sanderson et al, 2008 [26] | N/A | = Increased unexpected events detected = Reduced time to detect unexpected events |
+ Clinician opinions | 83 | — |
Schaer et al, 2015 [27] | N/A | N/M | + Clinician opinions | 71 | — |
Schlosser et al, 2019 [28] | N/M | + Increased alarms detected = Reduced time to detect alarms |
+− Clinician opinions | 92 | 75 |
Via et al, 2002 [31] | N/M | N/M | + Clinician opinions | 59 | — |
Vorraber et al, 2014 [32] | N/M | N/M | + Changed patterns of gaze behavior + Clinician opinions |
— | 30 |
Yoshida et al, 2014 [33] | N/M | N/M | + Clinician opinions | — | 39 |
a“+” represents the positive effect of head-worn display; “−” represents the negative effect of head-worn display; “=” represents no difference between head-worn display and other conditions. If a study used more than one measure for an outcome, multiple symbols are shown.
bN/A: not applicable.
cNot relevant to this study.
dN/M: not measured.