Table 1.
Bibliography | Sensors Included | Advantages and Disadvantages | Novelty of the Proposal |
---|---|---|---|
Shin, D. M. et al. (2013). |
GPS, ambient light sensor, accelerometer, wireless communications |
It stands out for including GPS and implementing location-based positioning. |
It is an intelligent surveillance system, for the use and improvement of living conditions of patients with dementia. |
Perez, M. N. et al. (2015). |
Optical heart rate sensor, accelerometer, a capacitive sensor, and thermistor |
It measures activities, such as exercise and sleep quality, that have not been considered in our work. |
Monitor the user’s daily activities, including exercise, sleep quality, heartbeat and food types |
Shin, D. et al. (2014). |
GPS, ambient light sensor, accelerometer, wireless communications |
The work is focused on dementia and includes positioning. It also highlights the algorithm for fall detection. |
The main purpose of the bracelet is to prevent dementia patients from getting lost and to detect falls. |
Sendra, S. et al. (2018). |
Accelerometer, microphone, heart rate, and blood oxygen sensor with photoplethysmography, GPS, elastic band to measure breathing and thermometer |
It is focused on disease measurement and incorporates sensors not considered in our article. |
Control of chronic diseases of children with remote monitoring constantly with the help of remote devices. |
Chen, M. et al. (2018). |
Electrocardiogram, temperature and the amount of oxygen in the blood |
It measures oxygen in the blood, a sensor that has not been considered in our work. |
Monitoring the psychological state of the user using Smart Personal Health Advisor (SPHA) systems |
Kajornkasirat, S. et al. (2018). |
Heart rate sensor, vibrator, audio support, connection via Bluetooth |
Aspects of daily life are detected but no accidents or anomalies. |
Counts the steps, the calories burned, monitors our sleep, and analyzes the calories we eat at lunch |
Maglogiannis, I. et al. (2014). |
Accelerometer, gyroscope and contact sensors, vibrator, magnetometer, ambient light sensor and Bluetooth 4.0 |
Falls are detected with the CUSUM algorithm and we detect the falls through the IMU itself. |
Initial evaluation of fall detection using the CUSUM algorithm |
Alsulami, M. H. et al. (2016). |
Heart rate sensor | Heart rate is monitored with an expert system called KBS. In our case we extend this to other variables. |
The use of smart watches to monitor heart rate in older people using expert system called KBS capable of making decisions and taking action. |
Karakaya, M. et al. (2017). |
Accelerometer and gyroscope | It only uses an IMU with a KNN classifier as a sensor, so our proposal is more complete |
Remote monitoring of elderly people’s activities using Smart Watch using a KNN classifier |
Reeder, B. et al. (2016). |
Gyroscope, microphones, optical heart rate sensor, contact sensor for temperature measurement and light sensor for sun exposure |
Very comprehensive review in which several sensors not covered in our work are used. |
Systematic review of the uses of intelligent surveillance for health and well-being with different watch models |
Nguyen, D. N. et al. (2017). |
Shock sensor, microphone, pulse sensor, temperature sensor and GPS |
Detection of parameters for anomaly detection using a microphone as an extra to our work. |
Smart Watch with automatic voice recording and alarm |
Parara, A., & Sekka, S. (2016). |
Heart rate sensor, GPS, touch screen and microphone |
A system including positioning and a microphone as additional components is presented. |
Intelligent user care security surveillance device |
Mukhopadhyay, S. C. (2014). |
Body temperature sensor, heart rate meter with photoplethysmography (PPG), microphone, camera, accelerometer, and electrocardiogram |
It focuses on Human Behavior Activity and is not aimed at alarm detection. |
Review of wearable sensors for monitoring human activity |
Gope, C. (2015). | Accelerometer, GPS, panic button | It is aimed at the detection of epileptic movements and does not cover other areas of interest in our case. |
Smart Watch for surveillance and monitoring of seizures / abnormal movement activities or epileptic seizures. |
Wile, D. J. et al. (2014). |
Accelerometer | It is aimed at tremor analysis and does not cover other areas of interest in our case. |
Smart Watch accelerometry for tremor analysis and diagnosis |
Kumari, P. et al. (2017) |
Electroencephalogram (EEG), electrooculogram (EOG), electromyography (EMG), electrocardiogram (ECG) |
This is similar work that focuses on aspects of monitoring people rather than detecting alarms caused by accidents. |
Review of wearables and multimodal interface for human activity monitoring |
Manisha, M. et al. (2016) |
Heart rate and blood pressure sensor | The application is heart attack detection. So it only uses sensors aimed at detecting heart attacks. |
Device targeting heart disease, monitoring heartbeats and blood pressure, to try to reduce the number of deaths due to heart attacks |
Dhull, R. et al. (2020) |
Failure of respiratory system of human, body temperature, heart rate, and blood pressure. |
The smartwatch is used for COVID detection and the sensors it implements and its software are closed to this application. |
Discuss the design, principle of operation and features of different smartwatches |
Adjiski, V. et al. (2019) |
Accelerometer, gyroscope, magnometer, and heart rate sensor |
It is dedicated to mining and the smartwatch does not implement fall detection. |
Real-time safety situation awareness and predict health and safety incidents before they occur |