Skip to main content
. 2021 May 12;21(10):3372. doi: 10.3390/s21103372

Table 1.

Proposals related to wearable monitoring and sensor networks in a wrist band.

Bibliography Sensors Included Advantages and Disadvantages Novelty of the Proposal
Shin, D. M.
et al. (2013).
GPS, ambient light sensor, accelerometer,
wireless communications
It stands out for including GPS and
implementing location-based positioning.
It is an intelligent surveillance system, for the use and improvement
of living conditions of patients with dementia.
Perez, M. N.
et al. (2015).
Optical heart rate sensor, accelerometer,
a capacitive sensor, and thermistor
It measures activities, such as exercise
and sleep quality, that have not been
considered in our work.
Monitor the user’s daily activities, including exercise, sleep quality,
heartbeat and food types
Shin, D. et al.
(2014).
GPS, ambient light sensor, accelerometer,
wireless communications
The work is focused on dementia and
includes positioning. It also highlights
the algorithm for fall detection.
The main purpose of the bracelet is to prevent dementia patients
from getting lost and to detect falls.
Sendra, S. et al.
(2018).
Accelerometer, microphone, heart rate, and
blood oxygen sensor with
photoplethysmography, GPS, elastic
band to measure breathing and thermometer
It is focused on disease measurement
and incorporates sensors not considered
in our article.
Control of chronic diseases of children with remote monitoring
constantly with the help of remote devices.
Chen, M. et al.
(2018).
Electrocardiogram, temperature and the
amount of oxygen in the blood
It measures oxygen in the blood, a
sensor that has not been considered
in our work.
Monitoring the psychological state of the user using Smart Personal
Health Advisor (SPHA) systems
Kajornkasirat, S.
et al. (2018).
Heart rate sensor, vibrator, audio support,
connection via Bluetooth
Aspects of daily life are detected
but no accidents or anomalies.
Counts the steps, the calories burned, monitors our sleep, and
analyzes the calories we eat at lunch
Maglogiannis, I.
et al. (2014).
Accelerometer, gyroscope and contact sensors,
vibrator, magnetometer, ambient light
sensor and Bluetooth 4.0
Falls are detected with the CUSUM
algorithm and we detect the falls
through the IMU itself.
Initial evaluation of fall detection using the CUSUM algorithm
Alsulami, M. H.
et al. (2016).
Heart rate sensor Heart rate is monitored with an expert
system called KBS. In our case we
extend this to other variables.
The use of smart watches to monitor heart rate in older people
using expert system called KBS capable of making decisions
and taking action.
Karakaya, M.
et al. (2017).
Accelerometer and gyroscope It only uses an IMU with a KNN
classifier as a sensor, so our proposal
is more complete
Remote monitoring of elderly people’s activities using Smart Watch
using a KNN classifier
Reeder, B. et al.
(2016).
Gyroscope, microphones, optical heart rate
sensor, contact sensor for temperature
measurement and light sensor for sun exposure
Very comprehensive review in
which several sensors not covered
in our work are used.
Systematic review of the uses of intelligent surveillance for health
and well-being with different watch models
Nguyen, D. N.
et al. (2017).
Shock sensor, microphone, pulse sensor,
temperature sensor and GPS
Detection of parameters for anomaly
detection using a microphone as an
extra to our work.
Smart Watch with automatic voice recording and alarm
Parara, A., &
Sekka, S. (2016).
Heart rate sensor, GPS,
touch screen and microphone
A system including positioning and a
microphone as additional components
is presented.
Intelligent user care security surveillance device
Mukhopadhyay,
S. C. (2014).
Body temperature sensor, heart rate meter
with photoplethysmography (PPG), microphone,
camera, accelerometer, and electrocardiogram
It focuses on Human Behavior Activity
and is not aimed at alarm detection.
Review of wearable sensors for monitoring human activity
Gope, C. (2015). Accelerometer, GPS, panic button It is aimed at the detection of epileptic
movements and does not cover other
areas of interest in our case.
Smart Watch for surveillance and monitoring of seizures / abnormal
movement activities or epileptic seizures.
Wile, D. J.
et al. (2014).
Accelerometer It is aimed at tremor analysis
and does not cover other
areas of interest in our case.
Smart Watch accelerometry for tremor analysis and diagnosis
Kumari, P.
et al. (2017)
Electroencephalogram (EEG), electrooculogram
(EOG), electromyography (EMG),
electrocardiogram (ECG)
This is similar work that focuses on
aspects of monitoring people rather than
detecting alarms caused by accidents.
Review of wearables and multimodal interface for human activity
monitoring
Manisha, M.
et al. (2016)
Heart rate and blood pressure sensor The application is heart attack detection.
So it only uses sensors aimed at
detecting heart attacks.
Device targeting heart disease, monitoring heartbeats and blood
pressure, to try to reduce the number of deaths due to heart attacks
Dhull, R.
et al. (2020)
Failure of respiratory system of human, body
temperature, heart rate, and blood pressure.
The smartwatch is used for COVID
detection and the sensors it implements
and its software are closed to this
application.
Discuss the design, principle of operation and features of
different smartwatches
Adjiski, V.
et al. (2019)
Accelerometer, gyroscope, magnometer,
and heart rate sensor
It is dedicated to mining and the
smartwatch does not implement
fall detection.
Real-time safety situation awareness and predict health and safety
incidents before they occur