Table 3.
Summary of Benefits and Challenges when Adapting to Remote Sessions, as Reported by Music Therapists | |
---|---|
It is an alternative, rather than a substitute for in-person therapy. [2,19,23] | |
Benefits outweigh the challenges. [2,18,19] | |
Benefits (not necessarily associated with the pandemic): | |
Benefits for the training of music therapists (teaches them to be flexible). [19] | |
Easy access for clients [19]; e.g., remote locations or immunocompromised [2]; for clients in the hospital setting on respiratory support with difficult transportation, e.g., for the infants with tracheostomies, or those on isolation. [20] | |
The expansion of boundaries, which provides a directly contextualized view into patients’ home lives. [16] | |
Using technology spurs creativity–a lot can be done. [2] | |
The amount of staff required to assist with organizing MT in a hospital setting decreased. [20] | |
Off-site family members of hospitalized children in therapy were able to attend. [20] | |
Interpreting services could connect easily. [20] | |
Benefits directly related to the COVID-19 pandemic: | |
It brings joy and love to overpower the terror of COVID-19. [22] | |
Benefits related to the possibility of avoiding the protective measures: Masks and social distancing disrupt both verbal and non-verbal communication, can muffle voices, and limit a therapist’s assessment of patient affect. [16,20] | |
Engagement in some respects has increased, virtual groups have been well attended—due to the isolation caused by the pandemic, patients were enthusiastic about finding different channels of communication/provided therapy. [16] | |
Opportunity to continue earning money and providing services. [2] | |
Challenges: | |
It feels weird [for the client] at first. [17] | |
It can feel very isolating [for the client]. [17] | |
Problems with the Internet and technology–Internet’s lag-time causes delays in rhythm and harmony not in perfect synchronization. [22,23] | |
Risk of losing boundaries in the client-therapist relationship due to the home environment. [16] | |
Virtual service technology is difficult to learn. [2] | |
Virtual service technology is not appropriate for all clients. [2] | |
Virtual service technology is cost-prohibitive for many clients and clinicians. [2] | |
Connected with barriers and inequities, which keep clients from accessing these services. [2] | |
Not all companies/organizations allow telehealth options. [2] | |
For child clients, there is a need to set a time limit for screen time. The therapist had to look for signs of overstimulation. [20] |
|
It may not be possible to offer music therapy exactly as usual. [23] | |
Clients’ feedback: | |
Pleased to have the option of continuing therapy in some form. [16,17] |