Table 1.
Studies on mental health and general health
First author (journal) | Country (ies) | Type of study | Main subject | Objectives | Age (n) | Lockdown /school closure and time of data collection | Outcome measures | Other factors (inequalities) | Summary of results |
NR, et al. (J Youth Adolesc) | Australia (New South Wales) | Cohort study (Risks to Adolescent Wellbeing Project, the RAW Project) |
Mental health, life satisfaction | To assess the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on adolescents’ mental health, and moderators of change, as well as assessing the factors perceived as causing the most distress. | 13–16 years (response rate 53% at time T2 during lockdown, n=248) | T1=previous year (2019) T2=2 months after start lockdown) May 5 to May 14 | Generalised Anxiety, Depressive symptoms, Student’s Life Satisfaction Scale (SLSS) | Age, sex, schooling, peer and family relationships, social connection, media exposure, COVID-19 related stress, and adherence to government stay-at-home directives at T2 | Significant increase in depressive symptoms and anxiety, and a significant decrease in life satisfaction from T1 to T2, higher among girls. Moderators were COVID-19-related worries, online learning difficulties, and increased conflict with parents as predictors of increases in mental health problems from T1 to T2. Adherence to stay-at-home and feeling socially connected during the lockdown protected against poor mental health. |
Ezpeleta L, et al. (Int J Environ Res Public Health)20 | Barcelona (Spain) | Cohort study (started 10 years ago) | Mental health | To assess life conditions during lockdown associated with mental health problems in children, and to analyse the mental health status of the population during the lockdown period. | 226 parents (mainly mothers) answered the questionnaire (response rate 55%). Mean age=13.9 years | Lockdown March 13 to May 24. Questionnaires answered on June. Compare results with 2019 |
SDQ parent-proxy version | Physical environment, COVID-19 disease, the adults sharing the house, adolescents’ relationships, activities, and feelings/behaviours |
Total difficulties increased and peer, and prosocial, after adjusting for previous pathology. Effect size small to medium. |
Zhang L, et al. (JAMA Net Open)21 | China (Chizhou, Anhui Province) | Cohort | Mental health | To investigate psychological symptoms, nonsuicidal self-injury, and suicidal ideation, plans, and attempts among a cohort of children and adolescents | Age range 9:3–15.9. Mean age: 12.6 years fourth to eighth grades. N=1241 out of 1387 participants in two waves |
Two waves: wave 1, early November 2019; and 2 weeks after school reopening (wave 2, mid-May 2020). After 3 months of lockdown, schools in Chizhou were reopened on April 26 | Data on depressive and anxious symptoms (Mood and Feelings Questionnaire; MacArthur Health & Behavior Questionnaire), nonsuicidal self-injury, suicide ideation, suicide plan, and suicide attempt were collected in two waves | Adjusting for age, sex, body mass index, self-perceived household economic status, family cohesion, parental conflict, academic stress, parental educational level, family adverse life events, self-perceived health, sleep duration, and sleep disorders. | The prevalence of mental health outcomes among students in wave 2 increased significantly from levels at wave 1: depressive symptoms (24.9% vs 18.5%; adjusted OR (aOR), 1.50 (95% CI, 1.18–1.90); nonsuicidal self-injury (42.0% vs 31.8%; aOR, 1.35(95% CI, 1.17–1.55)°; suicide ideation (29.7% vs 22.5% aOR, 1.32(95%CI, 1.08–1.62); suicide plan (14.6% vs 8.7%; aOR, 1.71(95% CI, 1.31–2.24); and suicide attempt (6.4% vs 3.0% aOR, 1.74(95% CI, 1.14–2.67). No differences in anxiety symptoms. |
Tromans S, et al. (Br J Psy Open)23 | Leicester-UK | Electronic data register of aproximately 1 000 000 hab of the NHS | Mental health | To describe secondary mental health service utilisation prelockdown and during lockdown | Gral population. Children and adolescents’ mental healthcare services (CAMHS) | January 27–March 22 compared with March 23–May 17 (lockdown) | Mental health admissions and referrals | Admissions pre-lockdown n=14; lockdown n=17, referrals pre-lockdown n=2193; lockdown n=1081. | |
Isumi A, et al. (Child Abuse Negl)22 | Japan | Data on mortality by age in Japan | Suicides | To investigate the acute effect of the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic on suicide among children and adolescents during school closure in Japan. | Total number of suicides among children<20 years | School closure March–May 2020. Compare March to May 2020 with the same data on 2018 and 2019 | Suicide incidence rate ratio (IRR) by month | No change in suicide rates during the school closure (iIRR=1.15, 95% CI: 0.81 to 1.64) and no interaction with school closure. |