Table 1.
Identified Themes and Categories Condensed From Meaning Units on Providers’ View of the Transplant Center in Ethiopia.
Meaning units | Codes | Categories | Main themes |
---|---|---|---|
I believe every department in the center should have been well
structured and organized Both critical care and Post OP beds are around in the same area, I think that should be managed Water, machines, medicines and some supplies were in short supply initially How much skilled man power do you have, how many beds do you need to place, and what actual number of patients are you planning to admit or give a service to |
Poor organization No plan No plan |
Gaps on organization and system planning | Challenges experienced during and after launching the center |
People are not equipped with up-to-date special training on
transplantation services, most are selected from the main
hospital The gap was due to the lack of studying every challenge to come and opportunity earlier, the house was rented, there was no generator initially It was only limited number of people who have been trained, that was a challenges and source of frustration during the time A special person to procure the items may be necessary, sometimes, items might not be obtained through a planned regular procurement process We are also limited to the number of services to be delivered, the capacity we had is a rate-limiting factor |
No training No personnel Knowledge gap No personnel Low capacity |
Challenges related to personnel and capacity building | |
When you request listed items, PFSA (Pharmaceuticals Fund and
Supply Agency) in Ethiopia may respond but we have no reserves
to tackle with shortages or lead time needs Some items, such as stitches, reagents and supplies might be in short supply I suggest a permanent system to be established for sustained availability There were only few suppliers to collect input bid for some startup materials |
Supply uncertainties Limited supply Trusted source Few suppliers |
Challenges related to suppliers | |
I suggest the government arrange homes especially for those from
the countryside There are costs related to medication, diet, and transplantation Because all patients are not rich, costs even after 2 months and, those coming while on their follow up may suffer from the challenges |
High rental costs Costs Unaffordable costs |
Patients’ capacity to afford costs | |
One possible challenge I experienced from transplantation is
setting the issue of finding a donor Donor should be from relatives and be compatible in all aspects I noted the main challenge facing during transplantation was lack of a donor Those being volunteer may fail due to the incompatibility of their blood Your donor mainly matters; compatibility tests, and other processes till patient reaches post OP stage |
No donor Donor Lack of donor Lack of donor Donor matters |
Challenges related to donor | |
The space is limited for providing services by all
professionals I have a fear that the center is ready well to satisfy all needs to arise in the future We have more patients waiting for the service, and that may require 2 months to complete we do not have adequate beds |
Limited space Unmet need High patient load Limited space |
Unmatched demand and supply | |
Everyone in the center feels stressed throughout the care,
because all want that patient recover from surgery I could prefer to do more scrub of other surgery than 1 renal transplant. It is tedious and intensive |
Stressful Tedious |
Demand for commitment | Commitment, sympathy and satisfaction |
I believe the professional team is motivated despite incentive
issues We mourn with those searching for donors, and strive to help those with donors amid of less attractive incentive packages The big satisfaction is to see a patient cured that has been suffering on dialysis |
Professionalism Share feeling Share feeling |
The sympathy of providers | |
People are happy for the service they get here They say they are back to work, they say they are free from dialysis costs |
Satisfaction Lowered cost |
Providers’ view on patients’ satisfaction | |
Dialysis may require 15000-20000 birr per month, but in
transplant they might need 4000birr on average for the first
month Because you may need to go for 3-4 times per week in dialysis, this may include family costs to care, even immunosuppressant drug costs could be better than service by dialysis |
Low cost Low cost |
Economic outcomes | Outcomes of renal transplant |
You will see people with good quality of life and they learn
each other about their life changes After 4 months, they will be advised to commence their work |
Improved quality Productivity |
Clinical and humanistic outcomes | |
Even though there was no proper plan to premise standards, we
sat and discussed with physicians on the needs to be
fulfilled We get ready of everything before 1 week of the procedure |
Discussion Preparation |
Actions taken to improve quality of service | |
I have a fear that the center is equipped well to cover all
needs to arise in the future Stakeholders, particularly, the ministry of health, and PFSA need to collaborate intensively as time goes on |
Concern Engagement |
Need for an active engagement of stakeholders | How the transplant center should operate |
Those with low income may still suffer as they have to cover
their costs I suggest the government arrange homes especially for those from the countryside The government must also make sure that drugs are readily available in public sectors like the ‘Kenema’ (public) pharmacies |
High cost Seek support Availability and affordability |
Continuity of support to patients | |
Still more is needed to be done for meeting international
standards Assuring the availability of reagents and medications should be mandatory as this cannot be stopped once started |
Standard Availability |
Sustaining the service in the center |