Skip to main content
. 2021 May 17;18(10):5344. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18105344

Table 1.

Characteristics of analyzed studies (N = 8).

Authors Sample/Group/Age (Years)/Country Exercise Protocol Cognitive, Psychological and Behavior Measures Main Outcomes
[39] N = 65
EG1 = 21, EG2 = 22; C = 22
Age = 14–16 years
Australian and New Zealand
Exercise Intervention
EG1: WU + GMCardio + Stretch (work-to-rest 30 s:30 s)
EG2: WU + CombCR + Stretch (work-to-rest 30 s:30 s)
C: PE
3 sessions/week in 8 weeks
EF
TMT—TA and TB
PWB
The Flourishing Scale
PD
Kessler Psychological Distress ScalePSC
Physical Self-Description Questionnaire
EG1 EF (TMT B), d = 0.26, +11.45%
EG2 EF (B-A), d = 0.28, + 17.73% | EF (TMT B), d = 0.39, +17.33%
EG1 PWB, d = 0.19, +3.32%
EG2 PWB, d = 0.21, +3.62%
EG2 PSC, d = 0.50, +23.58%
[20] N = 38
Age = 9–15 years
Australia
EG1: intermittent fast running for shorts periods + long active recovery periods (30 min, HIIT, ≥85 HRmax)
3 sessions/week in 12 weeks
Psychological assessment
Piers-Harris Children’s Self-Concept Scale
EG1 PSYA total score, d = 0.28, +8.71%
[24] N = 30
Age = 11–13 years
UK
EG1: 3′ WU at 20 W + 8 × 1-min work intervals at 85% peak power interspersed with 75 s active recovery at 20 W + 2′ Stretch at 20 W Affective responses
FS
Perceived enjoyment
During exercise EES; post-exercise PACES
Perceived exertion
Pictorial Children’s OMNI scale
Behavioral activation and behavioral inhibition
BIS and BAS
BAS/BIS with enjoyment responses
PACES high BAS d = 0.55, +2.67%
PACES low BIS d = 0.22, +1.35%
Self-efficacy with enjoyment responses
PACES high efficacy d = 0.55, +2.70%
PACES low efficacy d = 0.83, +4.11%
[41] N = 54
Age = 12–15 years
UK
HIIT protocol: 3′ WU at 20 W + 8 × 1-min intervals at 90% peak power + 75 s recovery at 20 W + 2′ Stretch
CMIE protocol: continuous moderate intensity cycling at 90% GAS)
Exercise Enjoyment
Modified PACES for adolescents (perceived enjoyment)
HIIT protocol in PACES score (boys, d = 0.73, + 32.43%; girls, d = 0.39, + 11.58%)
[22] N = 184
EG1 = 90, C = 94
Age = 12–15 years
Spain
2 sessions/week in 12-weeks intervention
EG1: 4′WU + 16′ over 85% HRmax within PE classes (work-to-rest between 20 s:40 s to 40 s:20 s)
C: static stretch within PE classes)
Memory
Ad hoc test of 1 min (RIAS test)
Selective attention and concentration
Brickenkamp’s d2 Test
Linguistic reasoning
Ad hoc test (reading speed and semantic comprehension)
EG1 selective attention, d = 0.29, +10.68%
EG1 concentration, d = 0.28, +8.00%
EG1 linguistic reasoning, d = 0.25, +7.66%
[21] N = 158
EG1 = 77, C = 81
Age = 12–16 years
Spain
Exercise Intervention
EG1: 4′WU + 16′ combination cardiorespiratory and coordinative exercise (4 sets, 4 exercises, work-to-rest 30 s:30 s)
C: static stretching
Cognitive Performance
Ad hoc test 1 min (memory test)
Brickenkamp’s d2 test (selective attention and concentration capacity)
Measurements on baseline, immediately post, and after 2, 3, 4, 24, 48 h)
EG1 (after training) selective attention, d = 0.81, + 60.73%
EG1 (after training, and 2 h after training) Concentration, d = 0.71, + 61.10%, and d = 0.72, + 62.49%
[23] N = 56
EG1 = 27, C = 29
Age = 8–12 years
Japan
Exercise Intervention
EG1: 10′WU + 8′aerobic and core exercise + 5′Stretch (work-to-rest 30 s:30 s)
C: PE
3 sessions/week in 4 weeks
Executive Function
DFS/DBS test
ToH
EG1 DFS test total score d = 0.33, +10.56%
EG1 DFS test MS d = 0.22, +6.36%
EG1 DBS test total score d = 0.30, +14.14%
EG1 DBS test MS d = 0.34, +13.37%
EG1 ToH 3-disk d = 0.75, +78.56%
C ToH 4-disk d = 0.84, +66.18%
[40] N = 67
EG1 = 26, EG2 = 23, C = 18
Age = 12–14 years
Spain
EG1: PE, 4 sessions (55 min)/week for 16 weeks
EG2: PE + high intensity training, 4 sessions (55 min)/week for 16 weeks
C: PE, 2 sessions (55 min)/week for 16 weeks
Cognitive Performance
IGF-M (non-verbal and verbal abilities, abstract reasoning, spatial ability, verbal reasoning and numerical ability)
Non-verbal abilities
EG1, d = 0.39, +5.29%
EG2, d = 0.88, +47.70%
Verbal abilities
EG2, d = 1.58, +22.61%
Abstract Reasoning
EG1, d = 0.34, +5.37
EG2, d = 0.75, +44.50%
Spatial Ability
EG2, d = 37.19, + 22.85%
Verbal Reasoning
EG2, d = 1.00, + 15.71%
Numerical Ability
EG2, d = 1.20, +8.28%

EG: experimental group; C = control group; PE: physical education classes; GMCardio: gross motor cardiorespiratory exercises; CombCR: combination of cardiorespiratory and body weight resistance training exercises; WU: warm-up; EF: execution function; PWB: psychological well-being; PSC: physical self-concept; PD: psychological distress; TMT: Trail Making Test; TA: Trail A; TB: Trail B; DFS/DBS test: Digit Span Forward/Backward test; ToH: Tower of Hanoi; GAS: gas exchange threshold; HIIT: high-intensity interval training; PACES: Physical Activity Enjoyment Scale; FS: feeling scale; EES: during exercise 7-point exercise enjoyment scale; PACES: post-exercise physical activity enjoyment scale; BAS: Behavioral Activation Scale; BIS: Behavioral Inhibition Scale; RPE: rating of perceived exertion; PSYA: psychological assessment; IGF-M: medium version of the Spanish Overall and Factorial Intelligence Test; d = effect size of Cohen’s d.