Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun;114:171–185. doi: 10.1016/j.semcdb.2021.03.013

Table 1.

Single cell datasets of normal mammary and tumour cells.

Reference Lab Species Tissue type (normal/ cancer/ both) Sample time points Mammary fraction (epithelial/stroma-immune/both) Preparation of cells prior to single cell sequencing Technique + technology Number of cells/nuclei profiled
Andersson et al. bioRxiv 2020 (preprint) Lundeberg Human Cancer 8x HER2 + breast tumours Both Cells spatially selected from fixed tissue sections Spatial transcriptomics developed by Ståhl et al. Science 2016 1007 spots (where spot refers to a small neighbourhood populated by multiple cells)
Azizi et al. Cell 2018 Pe’er and Rudensky Human Both 8x primary breast carcinomas tumour and matched normal breast tissue, peripheral blood and lymph nodes Stroma-imune CD45+ FACS sorted cells scRNA-seq using the inDrop platform 47,016 cells
Bach et al. Nature Comm 2017 Marioni and Khaled Mouse Normal Mammary cells taken during pregnancy (day 14.5), lactation (day 6), involution (day 11) and from virgin 8 week old C57BL/6N mice Epithelial Live lineage negative EpCAM+ cells sorted using FACS scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 23,184 cells
Bach and Pensa et al. Nature Comm 2021 Khaled and Marioni Mouse Both Tumourogenesis data set: 13 x Blg-Cre; Brca1f/f;p53 + /- mice (aged 30–48 weeks, nulliparous) and 2x C57BL/6N mice (aged 36–40 weeks old) Both Viable cells were isolated using MACS Dead Cell Removal Kit scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 102,829 cells
Pregnancy data set: 9x C57BL/6N mice at 4.5/9.5/14.5 days gestation as well as 3x C57BL/6N mice (aged 12 weeks old)
Bartoschek et al. Nature Comm 2018 Pietras Mouse Cancer Tumours from 14 week old MMTV-PyMT mice Stroma-imune EpCAM-/CD45-/CD31-/NG2- FACS sorted mesenchymal cells scRNA-seq using Smart-Seq2 768 cells
Baslan et al. eLife 2020 Hicks Human Cancer Fresh pre-treatment core biopsies were taken from 16 patients’ enroled in phase II clinical trials conducted by the Brown University Oncology Group (BrUOG) Both Nuclei was isolated and FACS sorted for ploidy Single-nuclei copy number analysis developed by Baslan et al. Nature Protocols 2012 Mean of 116 single-nuclei per tumour
Carli et al. J Mammary Gland Biol Neoplasia 2020 Rudolph Human Normal Human milk cells from two participants Both Viable cells were isolated using FACS scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 3740 cells
Casasent et al. Cell 2018 Edgerton and Navin Human Cancer 10x ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) and invasive ductal carcinoma (IDC) tumour samples Both Cells selected using single cell laser dissection Topographic single cell sequencing (TSCS, scDNA sequencing) On average 129 cells per patient
Chung et al. Nature Comm 2017 Park Human Cancer 11x tumour cells from different breast cancer subtypes Both Dead cells were removed using Ficoll-Paque PLUS scATAC-seq using the Fluidigm C1 platform 515 cells
Chung et al. Cell Reports 2019 Wahl Mouse Normal Mammary cells from E18 foetal and 8-week old adult CD1 mice Epithelial EpCAM+/Lin- FACS sorted cells snATAC-seq 7846 high quality single nuclei
Engelbrecht and Twigger et al. bioRxiv 2020 (preprint) Scheel and Khaled Human Normal Mammary tissue from one participant was digested 3 ways (3 h vs. 16 h digest and 10 rpm vs. 100 rpm. shaking speed). Both Viable cells were isolated using MACS Dead Cell Removal Kit scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq 11,191 cells
Gao et al. Nature Comm 2017 Navin Human Cancer Breast cancer cell lines for technique validation and a single triple negative breast tumour sample Both Nuclei isolated from frozen tumour and cell lines Nanogrid snRNA-seq 796 primary cell nuclei
Giraddi et al. Cell Rep 2019 Wahl and Spike Mouse Normal Mammary cells isolated from day 16/18 embryonic (E16, E18), postnatal day 10 (P10) and 10–16-week-old adult C57BL/6 mice Epithelial EpCAM+ FACS sorted cells scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq and Fluidigm C1 platforms 6060 cells using 10x and 262 cells using Fluidigm C1
Gkountela et al. Cell 2019 Aceto Human Cancer Blood samples containing circulating tumour cells (CTCs) from 43 patients with progressive breast cancer Both Live CTSs were stained for EpCAM, HER2 and EGFR and sorted for CTCs Single Cell Whole-genome Bisulfite Sequencing developed by Farlik et al. Cell Rep. 2015 89 single CTCs and 71 CTC clusters from patients and xenographs
Grosselin et al. Nature Genetics 2019 Griffiths, Vallot and Gérard Mouse and Human Cancer Patient derived xenogrft mouse models of luminal and treatment resistant breast cancers Both Viable cells were isolated using MACS Dead Cell Removal Kit scChIP-seq and scRNA-seq 2728 cells profiled by scRNA-seq
Han et al. Cell 2018 Guo Mouse Normal Mammary cells taken during pregnancy, lactation, involution and from virgin C57BL/6 mice Both* Cells from all major mice organs including mammary gland. *However, no mention was made of removal of the mammary lymph nodes prior to mammary gland dissociation. scRNA-seq using microwell-seq 61,196 mammary gland cells
Kanaya et al. Commun Biol 2019 Chen Mouse Normal Mammary cells from 9-week-old BALB/cj mice which underwent ovariectomy (surgical menopause) and were treated with vehicle, E2 and/or PBDE Both Dead cells were removed using microbeads scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 14,856 cells
Karaayvaz et al. Nature Comm 2018 Ellisen Human Cancer 6x primary triple negative breast tumours Both Viable tumour cells were isolated by FACS sorting scRNA-seq using Smart-seq2 1189 cells
Knapp et al. Cell Reports 2017 Eaves Human Both 7x breast cancer cell lines and 8x normal primary breast tissue samples Both N/A Mass cytometry using 35 markers (16 extracellular and 19 intracellular) Not disclosed
Li et al. Cell Reports 2020 Brugge Mouse Normal Mammary cells from young (3–4 month, n = 3) and aged (13–14 month, n = 4) old virgin C57BL/6 J mice Both None scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 13,684 cells
Lo et al. Cancers 2020 Zhou Mouse Normal Mammary cells were isolated from normal and high fat diet (HFD) fed 2 month old C57BL/6 Brca1-/-;p53+/- mice Stroma-imune EpCAM- FACs sorted viable stromal and immune cells scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 3892 cells
Murrow et al. bioRxiv 2020 (preprint v4) Gartner Human Normal Mammary cells isolated from 28x premenopausal women of varying BMI and age Both Live (DAPI-) cells were sorted using CD31-/CD45-/EpCAM+/-/ CD49f+/- and CD45+ scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 87,793 cells
Nguyen et al. Nature Comms 2018 Kessenbrock Human Normal Mammary cells isolated from 7x individuals whom underwent reduction mammoplasties Epithelial CD31-/CD45- epithelial cells enriched by FACs sorting using CD49f and EpCAM scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq and Fluidigm C1 platforms 24,646 cells using 10x and 868 cells using Fluidigm C1
Pal et al. Nature Comms 2017 Visvader Mouse Normal Mammary cells were isolated from early postnatal (2 week old), mid-pubertal (5 weeks old) and mature adult (10 weeks, either from virgin or pregnant) FVB/NJ mice Epithelial CD45-/CD31-/CD24+ epithelial cells were FACS enriched scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq and Fluidigm C1 platforms 3308 cells using 10x and 460 cells using Fluidigm C1
Pervolarakis et al. Cell Reports 2020 Watanabe and Kessenbrock Mouse Normal Mammary cells were isolated from 10-week-old FVB/NJ mice Both FACS sorting using markers CD31, CD45, EpCAM and CD49f separated live cells for scRNA-seq and basal/luminal cells for scATAC-seq scRNA-seq and scATAC-seq was performed using 10x Genomics Chromium platforms 26,859 cells were profiled using scRNA-seq and 23,338 cells were profiled using scATAC-seq
Salmén et al. bioRxiv 2018 (preprint) Lundeberg Human Cancer Tumour tissue sections from 10 patients diagnosed with HER2 + breast cancer Both N/A Spatial Transcriptomics developed by Ståhl et al. Science 2016 and others 1007 spatial spots
Sebastian et al. Cancers 2020 Loots Mouse Cancer Mammary cells were extracted from 10-week-old BALB/c mice with 4T1 derived mammary tumours (a synergistic model for triple negative breast cancer) Stroma Using magnetic cell separation, CD45 depleted or CD45/CD90.1 depleted cells were sequenced, as well as bulk cells and CD140a+/EpCAM-/CD45-/7AAD- FACS sorted fibroblasts. scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 6420 cells
Sun et al. J. Biol. Chem. 2018 Deng Mouse Normal Mammary cells were isolated from 3 to 4 month-old virgin or day 12.5 pregnant FVB mice Epithelial Lineage positive (Lin+, endothelial or immune) cells were excluded using the EasySeq mouse epithelial cell enrichment kit. Luminal and basal cells were FACS sorted for using CD24 and CD29 scRNA-seq using Fluidigm C1 platform 239 cells
Thong et al. Front. Cell Dev. Biol. 2020 Colacino Human Normal Mammary cells were isolated from 3x normal mammoplasty tissue samples. Additionally, mammary cells from the 3 patients were conditionally reprogrammed in vitro and also sequenced. Both None scRNA-seq using drop-seq protocols developed by Macosko et al. 2015. Not disclosed
The Tabula Muris Consortium Nature 2020 Mouse Normal Mammary cells taken from at 3, 18 and 21 months from C57BL/6JN mice Both* Cells from all major mice organs including mammary gland. *However, no mention was made of removal of the mammary lymph nodes prior to mammary gland dissociation. scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 15,577 mammary cells
Tognetti et al. bioRxiv 2020 (preprint) Bodenmiller Human cell lines Both 62x breast cancer cell lines and 5x normal cell lines N/A N/A Mass cytometry using 34 markers > 80 million cells
Twigger et al. bioRxiv 2020 (preprint) Khaled and Scheel Human Normal 4x samples from participants donating mammoplasty tissue and 4x human milk samples from lactating women Both None scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 24,666 non-lactating breast cells and 27,023 human milk cells
Vatter et al., Cell Reports 2018 Bodenmiller, LaBarge and Lorens Human Normal 57 samples were profiled consisting of cultured cells from 44 women and 13 uncultured breast epithelia samples. Epithelia N/A Mass cytometry using 29 markers 880,000 cells
Wagner at al. Cell 2019 Bodenmiller Human Both 144x human breast tumours and 50x normal breast tissue samples Both N/A Mass cytometry using 73 markers 26 million cells
Wang et al. eLife 2020 Schwertfeger Mouse Normal Mammary cells isolated from 10-week-old dioestrus FVB/NJ mice Stroma-imune CD45+ cells were enriched for using magnetic cell separation scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 13,000 cells were targeted
Wu et al. EMBO J 2020 Swarbrick Human Cancer 5x triple negative breast tumours Both Viable cells were enriched for using EasySep Dead Cell Removal Kit scRNA-seq using Chromium 10x Drop-Seq platform 24,271 cells
Wuidart et al. Nat Cell Biol 2018 Blanpain Mouse Normal Mammary cells were isolated from embryonic day 14 (E14) and > 8-week-old adult mice Epithelial Embryonic CD49fHi/Lgr5Hi cells, adult CD24+/CD29Hi basal and adult CD24+/CD29Lo luminal cells were FACS enriched scRNA-seq using Smart-seq2 193 cells