Skip to main content
. 2021 May 18;22(10):5312. doi: 10.3390/ijms22105312

Table 2.

The advantages and disadvantages of the methods to investigate protein–RNA interactions.

Method Advantages Disadvantages Analysis of the Interactions Specific to the RNAP II Machinery
RIP
  • Well-studied

  • Easy-to-use

  • Dependent on antibody specificity

  • Low signal-to-noise ratio

  • Requires substantial amounts of input materials

  • Does not determine the exact location of RBP-binding sites

  • Difficult to isolate RNAP II fraction keeping physiological protein–RNA interactions

CLIP
irCLIP [54]
eCLIP [55]
tRIP [56]
  • Identification of direct protein–RNA interaction sites at single nucleotide resolution

  • High signal-to-noise ratio

  • Dependent on antibody specificity

  • Low crosslinking efficiency

  • Requires substantial amounts of input materials

  • Complicated procedures

  • tRIP succeeded in the RNAP II-specific detection

  • Requires further enhancement of detection sensitivity for the precise analysis

KIN-CLIP [59]
  • High crosslinking efficiency

  • Requires dedicated devices

  • Not examined.

  • Requires optimization for less input materials

RNA editing
TRIBE [60]
STAMP [63]
  • No need to purify protein–RNA complexes

  • No dependence on crosslinking

  • High detection sensitivity (from single-cell level)

  • Requires artificial expression of an RBP fused with an RNA-editing enzyme

  • The distribution of detected sites is biased, reflecting the preference of the fused RNA-editing enzyme

  • Not examined

  • Requires isolation or labeling of RNA specific to the RNAP II machinery

Proximity labeling
Proximity-CLIP [69]
APEX-RIP [70]
CAP-seq [73]
  • No dependence on crosslinking

  • Efficient isolation of RNA in a specific subcellular fraction

  • Requires artificial expression of a PL enzyme specific to the fraction of interest

  • Does not identify specific binding sites of an RBP of interest

  • Not examined

  • Requires development of the labeling strategy specific to the RNAP II machinery