Skip to main content
. 2021 May 28;15(4):653–681. doi: 10.1016/j.pcd.2021.05.011

Table 1.

Baseline characteristics of included studies.

Author, year of publication Period of data collection Pandemic period/lockdown Pre-pandemic period/pre-lockdown Historical control period/pre-COVID-19 Study design Country Location Source of data Male % Average age Quality score
Araiza-Garaygordobil, 2021 12 Mar to 15 Apr, 2020 1 Dec 2019 to 11 Mar 2020 Dec 2018 to April 2019 Ecological retrospective study 17 countries Intercontinental NA
Mafham, 2020 1 Jan 2019 to 24 May, 2020 March to May 2020 Jan 2019 to Feb 2020 Retrospective cohort England Europe Acute NHS hospital trusts 6
Perrin, 2020 13 Mar to 30 Apr 2020 13 Mar to 30 Apr 2019 and pre-pandemic period (7 Jan to 24 Feb 2020) Retrospective cohort Switzerland Europe Geneva University Hospitals Pandemic (80); Control (75) Pandemic (63.8); Control (68.0) 6
Tam, 2020 1 Nov 2019 to 31 Mar 2020 After 25 Jan 2020 Before 25 Jan 2020 Cross-sectional study Hong Kong Asia Accident and Emergency Department Pandemic (70.3); Pre-pandemic (65.9) Pandemic (69.4); Pre-pandemic (69.0) 6
Toniolo, 2020 Mar-20 Mar-19 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe Cardiology Division of Udine University Hospital 6
Huet, 2020 17−22 Mar 2020 2−6 Mar 2020 Cross-sectional study France Europe Intensive cardiac units of 9 cardiology centres 5
Kwok, 2020b Jan 2017 to April 2020 After 23 March 2020 Before 23 March 2020 Retrospective cohort UK Europe British Cardiovascular Intervention Society-National Institute of Cardiovascular Outcomes Research database 7
Boukhris, 2020 1 Jan to 30 April 2020 1 Jan to 30 April 2019 Cross-sectional study Russia, Brazil, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia Intercontinental 5
Braiteh, 2020 March to April 2020 March to April 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America Upstate New York Hospitals Pandemic (70.1); Control (61.9) Pandemic (65.1); Control (72.3) 6
Butt, 2020 January and March 2020 Mar-19 Retrospective cohort Qatar Asia Hamad Medical Corporation 6
De Filippo, 2020 20 Feb to 31 March 2020 1 Jan to 19 Feb 2020 20 Feb to 31 March 2019 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe 15 Hospitals Pandemic (76.8) Pandemic (68) 6
De Rosa, 2020 12−19 March 2020 12−19 March 2019 Cross-sectional study Italy Europe Cardiac care units Pandemic (68); Control (67.1) 6
Fileti, 2020 10 March to 10 April 2020 10 March to 10 April 2019 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe 2 Hospitals with cardiac catheterization facilities Pandemic (65.3); Control (64.9) Pandemic (69.7); Control (70.4) 6
Folino, 2020 2020 2019 Cross-sectional study Italy Europe 10 Cardiological centres in Northern Italy 6
Haddad, 2020 mid-March to mid-May 2020 Jan to mid-March 2020 mid-March to mid-May 2019 Retrospective cohort Canada North America Hospitals in the Greater Montreal area Pandemic (44); Pre-pandemic (42); Control (42) Pandemic (60.6); Pre-pandemic (61.1); Control (69.5) 6
Hauguel-Moreau, 2020 Weeks 8−7, 2018−2020 17 Feb to 26 April 2020 17 Feb to 26 April 2018; 17 Feb to 26 April 2019 Retrospective cohort France Europe High volume PCI coronary unit 6
Holy, 2020 Before and after 16 March 2020 (lockdown) Before and after 16 March 2019 Cross-sectional study Switzerland Europe University Heart Center Zurich 5
Metzler, 2020 2−29 March 2020 Cross-sectional study Austria Europe PCI centres 4
Montagnon, 2021 23 March to 5 April 2020 23 March to 5 April 2019 Cross-sectional study France Europe Hospital Sainte Anne ACS - Pandemic (71.4); Control (75)/Stroke plus TIA - Pandemic (70); Control (55.6) ACS - Pandemic (67); Control (72)/Stroke plus TIA - Pandemic (73); Control (76) 6
Showkathali, 2020 25 March to 31 May 2020 25 March to 31 May 2018; 25 March to 31 May 2019 Retrospective cohort India Asia Tertiary referral hospital Pandemic (59); Control (72.3) 6
Sokolski, 2020 1 March to 30 April 2020 1 March to 30 April 2019 Retrospective cohort 12 countries Europe 15 centres in Europe 7
Solomon, 2020 Before and after 4 March 2020 Before and after 4 March 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America Kaiser Permanente Northern California 6
Vacanti, 2020 1 Jan to 30 June 2020 2 Jan to 30 June 2018; 1 Jan to 30 June 2019 Retrospective cohort Germany Europe Cardiology Dept 6
Yalamanchi, 2020 22 March to 1 August 2020 22 March to 1 August 2018; 22 March to 1 August 2019 Retrospective cohort India Asia Cardiac intensive care unit 2020 (59); 2019 (63); 2018 (62) 6
Tsioufis, 2020 1 Jan to 30 April 2020 1 Jan to 30 April 2018; 1 Jan to 30 April 2019 Retrospective cohort Greece Europe Cardiology Dept of a Tertiary General Hospital 6
Gasior, 2020 9 March to 16 April 2020 9 March to 16 April 2019 Retrospective cohort Poland Europe Polish National Health Fund 6
Dreger, 2020 Weeks 2−21 2020 Weeks 2−21 2017 to 2019 Retrospective cohort Germany Europe Hospitals in Berlin 6
Anderson, 2020 11 March to 28 April 2020 11 March to 28 April 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America Hospital in Boston 6
Gluckman, 2020 30 Dec 2018 to 16 May 2020 29 March 2020 to 16 May 2020 23 Feb 2020 to 28 March 2020 30 Dec 2018 to 22 Feb 2020 Cross-sectional study USA North America 49 hospitals in the Providence St Joseph Health system Later COVID-19 period (66); Early COVID-19 period (68); Historical control (66) Later COVID-19 period (67); Early COVID-19 period (67); Historical control (68) 6
Mohammad, 2020 1 March to 7 May 2020 1 March to 7 May 2015−2019 Retrospective cohort Sweden Europe Swedish Coronary Angiography and Angioplasty Registry Pandemic (67.4); Control (67.4) Pandemic (70); Control (70) 6
Piccolo, 2020 30 Jan to 26 March 2020 4 weeks after 27 Feb 2020 4 weeks before 27 Feb 2020 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe PCI centres Pandemic (75%); Pre-pandemic (72%) Pandemic (65.6); Pre-pandemic (65.8) 6
Secco, 2020 Mar-20 Mar-19 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe 3 High volume hospitals Pandemic (67.4); Control (67.4) Pandemic (67.4); Control (67.4) 6
Ayad, 2021 1 Feb to October 2020 1 Feb to October 2019 Retrospective cohort Egypt Africa International Cardiac Center hospital Pandemic (81.5); Control (85.7) Pandemic (57.1); Control (58.9) 6
Bhatt, 2020 1 Jan 2019 to 31 March 2020 Mar-20 Mar-19 Retrospective cohort USA North America Mass General Brigham health system Pandemic (55.4); Control (57.8) Pandemic (70.3); Control (71.1) 6
Daoulah, 2021 1 January to 30 April 2020 1 January to 30 April 2018−2019 Retrospective cohort Saudi Arabia Asia 16 centres 2018 (89.8); 2019 (84.9); 2020 (90.8) 2018 (56.7); 2019 (56.5); 2020 (55.4) 6
Desai, 2020 Mar-20 March 2017−2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America Stroke center 6
Diegoli, 2020 After 17 March 2020 2019 Retrospective cohort Brazil South America Joinville Stroke Registry 6
Gitt, 2020 1 March to 21 April 2020 1 March to 21 April 2017−2019 Retrospective cohort Germany Europe Heart Center Ludwigshafen 6
Hammad, 2020 1 Jan to 15 April 2020 After 23 March 2020 Before 23 March 2020 Retrospective cohort USA North America Integrated 18-hospital system Pandemic (49); Pre-pandemic (67) Pandemic (66); Pre-pandemic (61.8) 6
Kerleroux, 2020 15 Feb to 30 March 2020 15 Feb to 30 March 2019 Prospective cohort France Europe 32 stroke centres Pandemic (51.2); Control (58.4) Pandemic (70.6); Control (71.8) 7
Montaner, 2020 Before and after 31 March 2020 Before and after 31 March 2019 Prospective cohort Spain Europe Stroke units 7
Neves Briard, 2020 30 March to 31 May 2020 30 March to 31 May 2019 Prospective cohort Canada North America Stroke center Pandemic (48); Control (51) Pandemic (69.4); Control (72.1) 8
Pop, 2020 1−31 March 2020 1−31 March 2019 Retrospective cohort France Europe 3 Stroke units Pandemic (65.5); Control (64) 6
Popovic, 2020 26 Feb to 10 May 2020 2008−2017 Prospective cohort France Europe University Hospital of Nancy Pandemic (56.3); Control (76.1) Pandemic (62.6); Control (59.6) 7
Range, 2020 15 Jan 2019 to 14 April 2020 15 March to 14 April 2020 Before 15 March 2020 Prospective cohort France Europe France PCI registry Pandemic (70.5); Control (76.1) Pandemic (62.9); Control (63.6) 7
Reinstadler, 2020 24 Feb (week 9) to 5 April 2020 (week 14) Retrospective cohort Austria Europe 7 tertiary care hospitals 73 61 5
Sarfo, 2020 January to June 2020 January to June 2019 Retrospective cohort Ghana Africa Komfo Anokye Hospital Pandemic (57.1); Control (53.4) Pandemic (60.6); Control (59.7) 7
Teo, 2020 23 Jan to 24 March 2020 23 Jan to 24 March 2019 Retrospective cohort Hong Kong Asia Queen Mary Hospital Pandemic (43.8); Control (50.6) Pandemic (70.1); Control (73.6) 6
Toner, 2020 16 March to 15 April 2020 16 March to 15 April 2014−2019 Prospective cohort Australia Oceania Tertiary hospital Pandemic (65.0); Control (71.6) Pandemic (68.1); Control (65.0) 7
Abdelaziz, 2020 1−31 March 2020 1−31 March 2019 Retrospective cohort UK Europe Tertiary cardiac center Pandemic (69.6); Control (76.8) Pandemic (63.2); Control (66.6) 6
Agarwal, 2020 01 June 2019 to 15 May 2020 1 March 2020 to 15 May 2020 1 June 2019 to 29 Feb 2020 Retrospective cohort USA North America Langone Health Stroke Center Pandemic (49.2); Pre-pandemic (54.7) Pandemic (68); Pre-pandemic (72) 6
Burgos, 2020 Feb to March 2020 Feb to March 2019 Retrospective cohort Argentina South America Cardiology center 6
Aldujeli, 2020 11 March to 20 April 2020 11 March to 20 April 2019 Retrospective cohort Lithuania Europe Lithuanian University of Health Sciences Kaunas Clinics NSTEMI: Pandemic (73); Control (60)/STEMI: Pandemic (72); Control (65) NSTEMI: Pandemic (70); Control (69.5)/STEMI: Pandemic (67); Control (68.5) 6
Andersson, 2020 1 Jan to 11 March 2020/12–31 Mar 2020 1 Jan to 11 March 2019/12–31 Mar 2019 Retrospective cohort Denmark Europe Danish Nationwide Patient Registry Pandemic: New-onset HF (61−62); Worsening HF (69−72)/Control: New-onset HF (62); Worsening HF (66−67) Pandemic: New-onset HF (73.3−74.8); Worsening HF (74.0−75.2)/Control: New-onset HF (73.4−74.3); Worsening HF (75.2−75.3) 7
Ball, 2020 28 Oct 2019 to 10 May 2020 28 Oct 2019 to 10 May 2018−2019 Cross-sectional study UK Europe 9 Hospitals 6
Boeddinghaus, 2020 March to April 2020 Jan to Feb 2020 March to April 2019 Retrospective cohort Switzerland Europe Tertiary University Hospital Pandemic (77.5); Pre-pandemic (76.8) Pandemic (66); Pre-pandemic (68) 6
Bromage, 2020 2 March to 19 April 2020 2 March to 19 April 2017−2019 Retrospective cohort UK Europe King’s College Hospital Pandemic (54); Control (58) Pandemic (73); Control (71) 6
Bryndza, 2021 March to April 2020 March to April 2020 Retrospective cohort Poland Europe Cardiology center 6
Cammalleri, 2020 1−31 March 2020 Mar-19 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe Cardiology Department Pandemic (85); Control (87) Pandemic (65); Control (62) 6
Candelaresi, 2021 9 March to 12 April 2020 2 Feb to 8 March 2020 Same period in 2019 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe 5 Campania stroke hubs 6
Chew, 2021 7 Feb to 31 March 2020 1 October 2019 to 6 Feb 2020 Retrospective cohort Singapore Asia National University Hospital Singapore Pandemic (56.8); Pre-pandemic (64.4) Pandemic (59); Pre-pandemic (57) 7
Choudhary, 2020 25 March to 24 April 2020 25 Feb to 24 March 2020 25 Jan to 24 Feb 2020 Retrospective cohort India Asia 4 Tertiary regional Eds 6
Çinier, 2020 5 March to 6 April 2020 5 March to 6 April 2020 Retrospective cohort Turkey Europe Dr. Siyami Ersek Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery Training and Research Hospital Pandemic (81.1); Control (85.6) Pandemic (59.3); Control (63.7) 7
Colivicchi, 2020 20 Feb to 20 April 2020 20 Feb to 20 April 2019 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe San Filippo Neri Hospital Pandemic (79); Control (57) Pandemic (78); Control (73) 7
Cummings, 2020 March to April 2020 March 2019 to Feb 2020 Retrospective cohort USA North America Telestroke registry at Medical University of South Carolina Pandemic (44); Control (46.9) Pandemic (69); Control (67) 6
Del Pinto, 2020 1 January to 31 March 2020 1 January to 31 March 2019 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe 5 Hospitals in L'Aquila 6
Enache, 2020 First 3 months of 2020 First 3 months of 2019 Retrospective cohort Monaco Europe Cardiology Departments 6
Erol, 2020 17 April to 2 May 2020 1−15 November 2018 Prospective cohort Turkey Europe Registries Pandemic (76.2); Control (73.7) Pandemic (60); Control (62) 8
Frisullo, 2020 11 March to 11 April 2020 11 March to 11 April 2019 Retrospective cohort Italy Europe ED of Policlinico A. Gemelli Hospital Pandemic (59.6); Control (46.3) Pandemic (71.6); Control (73.7) 6
Giannouchos, 2021 1 Jan to 31 Aug 2020 1 Jan to 31 Aug 2019 Cross-sectional study USA North America University of Utah Healthcare Systems 6
Hoyer, 2020 Weeks 1−15 2020 Weeks 1−15 2019 Retrospective cohort Germany Europe 4 stroke centers 6
Hsiao, 2020 Weeks 11−15 2020 Weeks 1−10 2020 mid-March to mid-April 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America 30 Healthcare facilities 6
JF Huang, 2020 11 March to 9 April 2020 10 Feb to 10 March 2020 Cross-sectional study USA North America Mayo Clinic telestroke network 6
Ikenberg, 2020 1 Jan to 19 April 2020 21 March to 19 April 2020 1 Jan to 20 March 2020 Retrospective cohort Germany Europe Bavarian Comprehensive Stroke Center 6
Jasne, 2020 1 Jan to 28 April 2020 1 Jan to 28 April 2019 Cross-sectional study USA North America 3 Connecticut hospitals 49.7 70 6
John, 2020 1 March to 10 May 2020 1 March to 10 May 2019 Retrospective cohort UAE Asia Cleveland Clinic Abu Dhabi Pandemic - Ischemic stroke (72.3); hemorrhagic stroke (66.7); Control - Ischemic stroke (67.9); hemorrhagic stroke (80.8) Pandemic - Ischemic stroke (57.5); hemorrhagic stroke (48.9); Control - Ischemic stroke (58.4); hemorrhagic stroke (49.3) 6
Kobo, 2020 20 March to 30 April 2020 20 March to 30 April 2019 Prospective cohort Israel Asia 4 Cardiac centers Pandemic (84.1); Control (81.5) Pandemic (63); Control (61) 8
Kuitunen, 2020 1 February to 30 April 2020 6 weeks after 16 March 2020 6 weeks before 16 March 2020 Corresponding period in 2019 Retrospective cohort Finland Europe 3 Emergency Departments 6
Lauridsen, 2020 12 March to 13 May 2020 12 March to 13 May 2015−2019 Retrospective cohort Denmark Europe Danish Civil Population Registry Pandemic (71); Control (75) Pandemic (69); Control (70) 7
Little, 2020 1 March to 30 April 2020 1 March to 30 April 2019 Retrospective cohort UK Europe 7 Heart Attack Centres Pandemic (80); Control (78) Pandemic (63); Control (63) 6
Nagamine, 2020 March to April 2020 March to April 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America Stroke center Pandemic (75); Control (61) Pandemic (65.3); Control (69) 6
Mitra, 2020 26 March to 23 April 2020 26 March to 23 April 2019 Cross-sectional study Australia Oceania Tertiary cardiology and neurosciences centre Pandemic (67.3); Control (84.2) Pandemic (71.1); Control (74.7) 6
Nguyen-Huynh, 2020 15 March to 9 May 2020 1 Jan 2019 to 14 March 2020 Retrospective cohort USA North America Kaiser Permanente Northern California Pandemic (47.9); Pre-pandemic (47.1) Pandemic (69); Pre-pandemic (68.8) 7
Oseran, 2020 1 March to 30 April 2020 1 Jan to 29 Feb 2020 1 March to 30 April 2019/1 Jan to 28 Feb 2019 Cross-sectional study USA North America 8 Acute care hospitals 6
Paliwal, 2020 November 2019 to April 2020 7 Feb to 30 April 2020 1 Nov 2019 to 7 Feb 2020 Retrospective cohort Singapore Asia Stroke center Pandemic (57); Pre-pandemic (20) Pandemic (64.6); Pre-pandemic (65.6) 6
Papafaklis, 2020 2 March to 12 April 2020 2 March to 12 April 2019 Retrospective cohort Greece Europe Public hospitals Pandemic (79.1); Control (76.2) Pandemic (64.3); Control (64) 6
Piuhola, 2020 Mar-20 Jan to Feb 2020 January to Feb 2017−2019 Retrospective cohort Finland Europe 5 Tertiary centers 6
Rashid Hons, 2020 1 Feb to 14 May 2020 1 Feb to 14 May 2019 Retrospective cohort UK Europe Myocardial Ischaemia National Audit Project/British Cardiovascular Intervention Society Pandemic (71.2); Control (79.5) Pandemic (67.1); Control (63.1) 7
Richter, 2021 16 March to 15 May 2020 16 Jan to 15 March 2020 16 March to 15 May 2019 Retrospective cohort Germany Europe 1463 Hospitals 6
Rodríguez-Leor, 2020 16 March to 14 April 2020 1−30 April 2019 Retrospective cohort Spain Europe 75 STEMI care centers Pandemic (78.4); Control (78.4) Pandemic (63.1); Control (63.7) 7
Ruparelia, 2020 After 20 March 2020 Jan to Feb 2020 Jan to March 2019 Retrospective cohort UK Europe 2 Large Hospitals Pandemic (65.3); Control (68.9) Pandemic (75.4); Control (73.2) 6
Schirmer, 2020 Feb to March 2020 Feb to March 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America 12 Stroke centers Pandemic (67); Control (70) 6
Seiffert, 2020 1 Jan 2019 to 31 May 2020 Jan to May 2020 Jan to May 2019 Retrospective cohort Germany Europe Insurance Claims Data 6
Sharma, 2020 30 Dec 2019 to 19 April 2020 31 Dec 2018 to 21 April 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America 5 Tertiary stroke centers 6
Siegler, 2020 1 March 2020 to 15 April 2020 1 October 2019 to 29 Feb 2020 Retrospective cohort USA North America Stroke center Pandemic (57); Control (59) Pandemic (68); Control (68) 7
Tejada Meza, 2020 30 Dec 2019 to 3 May 2020 After 14 March 2020 Before 14 March 2020 Retrospective cohort Spain Europe Tertiary hospitals of the NORDICTUS network 6
Uchino, 2020 9 March to 2 April 2020 1 Jan to 8 March 2020 Retrospective cohort USA North America 19 Emergency departments 6
Vensentini, 2020 March to April 2020 March to April 2010−2019 Prospective cohort Argentina South America 6 Cardiovascular Intensive Care Units 7
Wadhera, 2021 18 March to June 2020 1 Jan to 17 March 2020 Jan to June 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America National Center for Health Statistics 6
J Wang, 2020 12 March to 30 June 2020 1 Dec 2019 to 11 Mar 2020 Retrospective cohort USA North America Inova Fairfax Medical Campus Pandemic (53.3); Pre-pandemic (51.9) Pandemic (73); Pre-pandemic (70) 6
Yang, 2020 23 Jan to 7 March 2020 1 December 2019 to 14 Jan 2020 Retrospective cohort China Asia Stroke center Pandemic (71.4); Pre-pandemic (64.7) Pandemic (62.3); Pre-pandemic (65.2) 6
Zhao, 2020 Feb-20 Feb-19 Retrospective cohort China Asia Big Data Observatory Platform for Stroke of China & 280 stroke centers 6
Cox, 2020 22 March to 20 April 2020 22 March to 20 April 2019 Retrospective cohort USA North America Vanderbilt University Medical Center 6